Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 8;9:1033821. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2022.1033821

Table 1.

List of indicators selected to test on-field reliability and feasibility, and sentinels assigned according to their availability, area of daily performance and experience.

Sentinels assigned to the on-field feasibility and reliability test of each indicator
External Zoo staff (departments)
Researchers V N Bi Be AC AWMP
Nutrition domain
Body condition score (ABM) Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes
Food intake (ABM) Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes
Food availability (RBM) Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes
Nutritional quality and safety of food (RBM) Yes No Yes No No No Yes
Macroscopic condition of food (RBM) Yes No Yes No No No Yes
Food presentation (RBM) Yes No Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Water intake (ABM) Yes No Yes No No Yes Yes
Availability of water (RBM) Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes
Macroscopic quality of water (RBM) Yes No Yes No No Yes Yes
Presentation of water (RBM) Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Environment domain
Substrate (RBM) Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Temperature/humidity/ventilation (RBM) Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
Lighting (RBM) Yes Yes No Yes No Yes Yes
Enclosure maintenance (RBM) Yes No No No No Yes Yes
Enclosure hygiene (RBM) Yes No No No No Yes Yes
Enclosure dimensions (RBM) Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Environmental complexity (RBM) Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Surrounding enclosures (RBM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Shelter availability (RBM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Public (RBM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Group composition (RBM) Yes No No Yes No No Yes
Environmental choice and control opportunities (RBM) Yes No No No No Yes Yes
Management choice and control opportunities (MBM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Environmental enrichment (MBM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Training procedures (MBM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Health domain
Defecation behavior (ABM) Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
Stool score (ABM) Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
Micturition behavior (ABM) Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
Urine appearence (ABM) Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
Coat/feathers/tegument (ABM) Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
Lesions/injuries (ABM) Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
Hooves/claws/teeth (ABM) Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
Locomotion (ABM) Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
Sleep/wakefulness (ABM) Yes Yes No Yes No Yes Yes
Signs of illness (ABM) Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
Behavior and affective states domain
Reaction to strangers (ABM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Interaction with zookeepers (ABM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Exploration (ABM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Social, affiliative and maternal-filial behavior (ABM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Reproductive behavior (ABM) Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Agonistic behavior (ABM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Use of environmental enrichment (ABM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Stereotypic behavior (ABM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes
Behavioral diversity (ABM) Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Space use (ABM) Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes

V, Veterinary; N, Nutrition; Bi, Biology; Be, Behavior; AC, Animal Care; AWMP, Animal Welfare Management and Planning; ABM, Animal-based measurement; RBM, Resources-based measurement; MBM, Management-based measurements.