Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb;103(2):120–129. doi: 10.1308/rcsann.2020.7005

Table 3 .

Likert scale of the likelihood of the use of the laparoscopic approach for seven common emergency surgical scenarios depending on various patient and environmental factors

Scenario 1: A patient with suspected appendicitis. They have no significant comorbidities. You decide to operate. How likely are you to approach this laparoscopically?
Patient Never
Rarely
Sometimes
Frequently
Always
(n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%)
a) 6-yr-old female 61 40.4 14 9.3 14 9.3 16 10.6 45 29.8
b) 12-year-old male 23 15.2 12 7.9 15 9.9 42 27.8 58 38.4
c) 25-year-old female 3 2.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 14 9.3 133 88.1
d) 65-year-old male 3 2.0 4 2.6 8 5.3 31 20.5 104 68.9
Scenario 2: A 50-year-old male with a computed tomography diagnosed perforated duodenal ulcer. You decide to operate. How likely are you to approach this laparoscopically?
Patient Never Rarely Sometimes Frequently Always
  (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%)
a) No significant comorbidities 37 24.5 20 13.2 31 20.5 30 19.9 32 21.2
b) ASA grade 3 43 28.5 27 17.9 28 18.5 32 21.2 20 13.2
c) Body mass index 42kg/m2 42 27.8 26 17.2 28 18.5 32 21.2 22 14.6
d) Previous abdominal surgery 51 33.8 34 22.5 41 27.2 12 7.9 12 7.9
e) Evidence of small bowel dilatation on CT 59 39.1 38 25.2 33 21.9 14 9.3 6 4.0
Scenario 3: A 60-year-old female with Hinchey grade 3 diverticulitis diagnosed on computed tomography. You decide to operate. How likely are you to approach this laparoscopically?
Patient Never Rarely Sometimes Frequently Always
  (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%)
a) No significant comorbidities 43 28.5 26 17.2 39 25.8 30 19.9 12 7.9
b) ASA grade 3 50 33.1 29 19.2 36 23.8 29 19.2 6 4.0
c) Body mass index 42kg/m2 56 37.1 29 19.2 34 22.5 24 15.9 7 4.6
d) Previous abdominal surgery 66 43.7 36 23.8 30 19.9 16 10.6 2 1.3
e) Evidence of small bowel dilatation on CT 73 48.3 41 27.2 23 15.2 11 7.3 2 1.3
Scenario 4: 60-year-old female with Hinchey grade 4 diverticulitis diagnosed on computed tomography. You decide to operate. How likely are you to approach this laparoscopically?
Patient Never Rarely Sometimes Frequently Always
  (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%)
a) No significant comorbidities 92 60.9 29 19.2 18 11.9 8 5.3 3 2.0
b) ASA grade 3 97 64.2 29 19.2 17 11.3 5 3.3 2 1.3
c) Body mass index 42kg/m2 96 63.6 33 21.9 15 9.9 4 2.6 2 1.3
d) Previous abdominal surgery 104 68.9 28 18.5 12 7.9 4 2.6 2 1.3
e) Evidence of small bowel dilatation on CT 106 70.2 29 19.2 10 6.6 3 2.0 2 1.3
Scenario 5: You have performed a laparoscopic repair of a perforated duodenal ulcer. Two days later the patient deteriorates on the ward. Computed tomography shows a large amount of free fluid and free air. You decide to operate. How likely are you to approach this laparoscopically?
Patient Never Rarely Sometimes Frequently Always
  (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%)
a) No significant comorbidities 74 49.0 16 10.6 27 17.9 19 12.6 13 8.6
b) ASA grade 3 82 54.3 20 13.2 24 15.9 15 9.9 8 5.3
c) Body mass index 42kg/m2 81 53.6 17 11.3 21 13.9 21 13.9 9 6.0
d) 50-year-old male 79 52.3 15 9.9 25 16.6 19 12.6 11 7.3
e) 80-year-old male 90 59.6 17 11.3 19 12.6 15 9.9 8 5.3
Scenario 6: A patient has had a laparoscopic anterior resection four days ago (primary anastomosis and not defunctioned). Today they have deteriorated and computed tomography shows a probable leak at the anastomosis. You decide to operate. How likely are you to approach this laparoscopically?
Patient Never Rarely Sometimes Frequently Always
  (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%)
a) No significant comorbidities 68 45.0 19 12.6 24 15.9 23 15.2 15 9.9
b) ASA grade 3 72 47.7 22 14.6 21 13.9 23 15.2 11 7.3
c) Body mass index 42kg/m2 73 48.3 23 15.2 21 13.9 23 15.2 8 5.3
d) 50-year-old male 71 47.0 18 11.9 24 15.9 21 13.9 15 9.9
e) 80-year-old male 76 50.3 22 14.6 20 13.2 23 15.2 8 5.3
Scenario 7: A patient presents with small-bowel obstruction confirmed on computed tomography. They have had no previous surgery and the radiologist reports an abrupt transition point in the pelvis. You decide to operate. How likely are you to approach this laparoscopically?
Patient Never Rarely Sometimes Frequently Always
  (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%) (n) (%)
a) No significant comorbidities 39 25.8 31 20.5 39 25.8 30 19.9 20 13.2
b) ASA grade 3 42 27.8 25 16.6 43 28.5 28 18.5 11 7.3
c) Body mass index 42kg/m2 47 31.1 28 18.5 37 24.5 22 14.6 15 9.9
d) 50-year-old male 39 25.8 24 15.9 39 25.8 27 17.9 20 13.2
e) 80-year-old male 47 31.1 27 17.9 36 23.8 23 15.2 15 9.9
f) A patient who has had previous open abdominal surgery 63 41.7 31 20.5 34 22.5 14 9.3 7 4.6

ASA, American Society of Anesthesiologists; CT, computed tomography