Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 25;13:1046315. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2022.1046315

Table 2.

Response of Nacobbus spp. to the interaction with different biological control agents in in vivo experiments.

Biocontrol agent (BCA) Nacobbus spp. and origin Conditions tested Response to BCA-nematode interaction Reference
Bacteria
Pseudomonas protegens CHA0 N. celatus*; Argentina: Buenos Aires Tomato cv. Platense, cell suspensions ↓ Galls, egg masses, nematode reproduction
No effect on shoot/root weight/length
Lax et al. (2013b)
Entomopathogenic nematodes/symbiotic bacteria
Steinernema rarum ACAB, Heterorhabditis
bacteriophora RACA
N. celatus; Argentina: Córdoba Tomato cv. Platense, IJ application No effect on galls and egg masses
↓ Nematode reproduction
Caccia et al. (2013)
S. rarum/Xenorhabdus szentirmaii N. celatus; Argentina Tomato cv. Platense, IJ and SB application ↓ Galls, nematode reproduction Lax et al. (2013c)
H. bacteriophora CBA/Photorhabdus luminescens
Steinernema sp./Xenorhabdus sp.
S. rarum RACA/X. szentirmaii
N. celatus; Argentina: Córdoba and Tucumán Tomato cv. Platense, IJ application No effect on galls, egg masses or nematode reproduction
↑ Biomass only with H. bacteriophora CBA-Córdoba
Caccia et al. (2018)
Tomato cv. Platense, SB suspensions and cell-free supernatants ↑ Biomass with BS suspension of Xenorhabdus sp.-Tucumán
↓ Biomass with supernatant of P. luminescens-Tucumán
Supernatants of Xenorhabdus sp. and P. luminescens: most effective in ↓ galls, egg masses and nematode reproduction
Mycorrhizal fungi
Glomus sp. N. aberrans s.l.; Mexico Tomato ↓ Galls Gardezi et al. (1995)
Rhizoglomus intraradices N. celatus; Argentina: Buenos Aires Tomato cv. Platense ↓ Root gall index
↓ Nematode reproduction
No consistent effect on biomass
↑ Mycorrhizal colonization
Lax et al. (2011b)
R. intraradices N. celatus; Argentina: Córdoba Tomato cv. Platense ↓ Galls, nematode reproduction
↑ Shoot and root dry weight
↑ Mycorrhizal colonization
Marro et al. (2014)
R. intraradices, Funneliformis mosseae N. celatus; Argentina: Córdoba and Tucumán Tomato cv. Platense, pepper cv. California wonder ↓ Galls, nematode reproduction
↑ Shoot and root dry weight
Marro (2018)
R. intraradices, F. mosseae N. celatus; Argentina: Tucumán Tomato cv. Platense ↓ Nematode root invasion Marro et al. (2018)
R. intraradices (B1, A2), F. mosseae N. aberrans s.l.; Argentina Pepper cv. Paco f1 ↑ Mycorrhizal colonization
↓ Nematode reproduction
↓ Contents of chlorophyll, carotenoids and soluble proteins
Bernardo et al. (2020)
Nematophagous fungi
Purpureocillium lilacinum N. aberrans s.l.; Argentina Tomato cv. Platense ↓ Galls, nematode reproduction
↑ Egg masses parasitism
Mareggiani et al. (1985)
P. lilacinum N. aberrans s.l. Tomato cv. Jefferson LD50: J2 mortality in soil Eguiguren-Carrión (1995)
P. lilacinum (LPSC# 876) N. aberrans s.l.; Argentina: Buenos Aires Tomato cv. Platense No consistent results Gortari and Hours (2016)
P. lilacinum (SR7, SR14, SR38) N. celatus; Argentina: Córdoba Tomato cv. Platense ↓ Egg masses
↑ Plant growth
Sosa et al. (2021a)
Pochonia chlamydosporia (MHCH, SM4, SMB3, SMB3A, SC1, VC10) N. aberrans s.l.; Mexico: Mexico, Puebla and Zacatecas Tomato cv. Río Grande; bean cv. Canario Criollo ↑ Egg masses and eggs/g root parasitism
↓ Egg hatching
Flores-Camacho et al. (2007)
P. chlamydosporia (SC1, IZ1) N. aberrans s.l.; Mexico: Zacatecas Bean cv. Flor de Mayo Criollo ↓ Galls, nematodes inside roots
↑ Foliage dry and fresh root weight
Franco-Navarro et al. (2012)
P. chlamydosporia (MPc1-MPc5) N. aberrans s.l.; Mexico: Puebla Tomato cv. Río Grande ↓ Galls, nematodes inside roots
↑ Leaf dry weight
Pérez-Rodríguez et al. (2007)
Fusarium solani (Fs03),
F. oxysporum (Fo07, Fo10), Penicillium janthinellum (Pe11)
N. aberrans s.l.; Mexico Pepper cv. Yolo Wonder ↓ Galls, J2/g root
No consistent effect on growth plant
Cortez-Hernández et al. (2019)

*All N. celatus populations were previously identified as N. aberrans. J2, second-stage juveniles; SB, symbiotic bacteria; IJ, infective juveniles; LD, lethal dose.

Up and down arrow mean increase and decrease, respectively.