Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 15;9(12):808. doi: 10.3390/bioengineering9120808

Table 1.

Main systems for adoptive cell therapy cultivation.

Culturing Method Maximum Cell Density Available Volume/
Size
Advantages Disadvantages
Stirred Flask 1.7 × 106 cells/mL 50 mL–35 L Availability
Scalability
High level of aeration
Controversial efficacy data for the cultivation of some cell products
Careful selection of the shape of blades is required
G-Rex flask 10–40 × 106 cells/cm2 2 cm2–500 cm2
8 mL–5 L
High density of cultivation
Relatively low cost
Can be operated using standard laboratory equipment (laminar flow hood, cell culture incubator)
Quality control check is required for each flask
Additional steps needed for manual processing of the cell product
Higher risk of contamination
Rocking motion bioreactors 10 × 106 cells/mL 250 mL–100 L Scalable to large volumes
Uniform cell mixing
High level of media aeration
Perfusion capability
Sensors for pH, dO, temperature
Aseptic media addition and sampling
Low efficacy for some cell types
Additional expensive equipment is required
Stirred tank bioreactors 2 × 106 cells/mL 250 mL–1 × 104 L Great scalability
Effective mixing with adjustable intensity
High level of media aeration
Range of sensors for monitoring cell culture
Flexibility of control settings (rpm, shape of paddles, etc.)
Controversial efficacy data for the cultivation of some cell products
Additional expensive equipment is required
Careful selection of the shape of blades is required
Hollow fiber 1 × 109 cells/mL area (cm2) to volume (mL) ratio = approx. 100–200 Capability to culture cells at extremely high density
Scalability
Versatility (fibril configuration, cartridge size, etc.)
Continuous addition of fresh medium and waste removal
Additional expensive equipment is required
Need to carefully select the membrane/fibril properties (porosity, packing density, diameter, etc.)
Complicated collection of the cell product
CliniMACS Prodigy 8 × 106 cells/mL 500 mL Semi-automated system
Multicomponent device (all-in-one)
Suitability for clinical application
Availability of ready-made kits for various steps of the processes
High cost of the system and consumables
Cell expansion is carried out in a centrifuge chamber (CentriCult Unit, a part of CliniMACS Prodigy system)