Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 9;12(12):3111. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics12123111

Table A1.

Qualitative data distilled from each included review on imaging modalities, AI techniques, and the corresponding review highlights.

No. References Imaging
Modalities
AI Techniques Cited By * Highlights
Traditional Review
1 [84] Thermography CNN 21
  • Summarize the recent progress in breast cancer detection based on optical imaging (i.e., thermography) CNNs

  • Application of deep neural networks for breast thermogram classification

  • Future works in development of datasets, feeding the segmented image, assigning good kernel, and construction of a lightweight CNN model to enhance the CNN performance

2 [85] Thermography ANN: RBFN, KNN, PNN, SVM, ResNet50, SeResNet50,
V Net, Bayes Net, CNN, C-DCNN, VGG-16, Hybrid (ResNet-50 and V-Net), ResNet101, DenseNet, and InceptionV3
11
  • Comprehensive review on related progress with AI in optical imaging (i.e., thermography)

  • Highlight the contributions and limitations of each study

  • Identify research gap

  • Identify bottlenecks of ANN in breast thermography

3 [86] X-ray, CT, ultrasound, MRI, nuclear, and microscopy Deep learning 38
  • Summarize different medical imaging technologies

  • Highlight the need of efficient medical data management techniques

  • Summarize the advent algorithms for disease classification and organ/tissue segmentation using AI methods

4 [87] Mammogram, ultrasound, and MRI Machine learning and deep learning 1
  • Summarize the AI application in mammogram, ultrasound, and MRI

  • Discuss the challenges and road ahead of AI in medical imaging

5 [88] Mammogram, ultrasound, MRI, FDG PET/CT Augmented intelligence and machine learning 16
  • Comprehensive overview on augmented intelligence in different breast imaging modalities

6 [89] Mammogram, ultrasound, MRI, Machine learning, CADe, ANN, CNN, and NLP 36
  • Discuss the potential of AI in breast imaging

  • Identify the limitations and bottlenecks of AI application

7 [90] Mammogram and ultrasound Machine learning 1
  • Summarize the essential elements in data engineering, typically preparation of data for machine learning application

  • Comprehensive review on databases, perspective, data integrity, and characteristic of a good data in the context of machine learning application

8 [91] Thermography and electrical
impedance tomography
Machine learning and CADe 15
  • Summarize the background, technical characteristics of machine learning techniques and CADe in thermography and electrical impedance tomography

  • Identify the methods to enhance global performance

  • Highlight recommendations for 3D breast simulation, pre-processing techniques, as well as relevant biomedical modality that has the potential in tumor localization and tumor size prediction

9 [92] Transillumination imaging,
diffuse optical imaging, and
near-infrared spectroscopy
Machine learning 13
  • Comprehensive review on applicability (i.e., diagnostic ability and practical deployment) of the new spectroscopy techniques in discrimination of normal and cancerous tissue

10 [93] Mammogram, Tomosynthesis, ultrasound, DBCT, MRI, DWI, CT, NIR fluorescence, and SPECT SVM, ANN, and robotics 6
  • Overview on past and present AI methods in different breast cancer diagnostic imaging modalities

11 [94] PET and MRI Fuzzy logic and neural network 26
  • Summarize recent progress, key strengths, and weakness of PET/MRI in cancer imaging

12 [9] Mammogram, tomosynthesis, DCE-MRI, and ultrasound CADe and CADx systems 449
  • Comprehensive state-of-the-art review on AI approaches in medical imaging for four tumor types: lung, brain, breast, and prostate

  • Identify the common clinical problem in medical imaging

13 [95] MRI Analytical radiomic-based (human-engineered) and deep learning-based CADe 44
  • Discuss the goal of AI in the context of breast cancer imaging, typically in MRI

  • Review on current progress, potential application, and limitations of AI in breast MRI

14 [96] MRI Machine learning and deep learning 4
  • Discuss the current progress and future perspective of AI in breast MRI

  • Highlight the importance of developing quantitative imaging biomarkers for precision medicine

  • Discuss potential of machine learning and deep learning in breast MRI

  • Discuss the future challenge of deep learning in the context of breast MRI and recommend AI-augmented clinical decision techniques

15 [97] MRI 3D printing, augmented reality. Radiomics, and machine learning 12
  • Discuss the role of breast MRI in detection of DCIS with the aid of AI approaches

16 [98] Mammogram, ultrasound, and MRI ANN, CNN, CADe, and GANs 0
  • Comprehensive review on insight, impact, and role of AI in breast imaging

17 [99] Mammogram Machine learning (supervised, unsupervised, reinforcement, and deep learning) 6
  • Highlight and discuss key terminology, concepts, and common AI models in breast imaging

18 [100] Mammogram and DBT Deep learning 89
  • Comprehensive review on current progress and head ahead of the AI-based clinical application in mammogram, DBT, and radiomics

19 [101] Ultrasonography CNN 9
  • Current progress and potential application of AI models in breast ultrasonography

20 [102] Mammogram, ultrasound, and MRI Deep learning and CADe 32
  • Comprehensive review on state-of-the-art deep learning methods in mammogram, ultrasound, and MRI

  • Discuss the challenges and bottlenecks which may impinge the advancement and integration of AI in clinical imaging workflow

21 [103] Mammogram Machine learning and radiomics 19
  • Discuss the CEM technique, screening, and diagnostic uses, and future applications with AI and radiomics

22 [104] Mammogram, sonography, MRI, and image-guided biopsy Deep learning and radiomics 2
  • Recent progress and potential value of digital analysis in breast imaging

23 [105] Mammogram, ultrasound, PET, and MRI ANN, SVM, and radiomics 1
  • Discuss key concept, state-of-the-art studies, and potential clinical use cases in breast imaging

24 [106] Ultrasound Deep learning 5
  • Discuss recent progress of deep learning in ultrasound imaging

  • Discuss the workflow enhancement, typically on view recognition, image quality assessment, scanning guide, and quantification

  • Recommend future perspective of deep learning in imaging workflow

25 [107] Mammogram and ultrasound Eye tracking tool and CADe 10
  • Highlight the importance of visual search in breast imaging

  • Identify the underlying reasons for diagnostic error in breast imaging

26 [108] Mammogram CADe, CADx, machine learning, deep learning, and CNN 48
  • Review of recent progress of AI approaches in breast imaging

  • Commentary on AI in medical diagnostic imaging

27 [109] Mammogram and tomosynthesis Deep learning 0
  • Synthesis recent progress of AI in mammography analyzing the risk in breast cancer

  • Highlight the key priority, challenges, and future prospective of AI application in clinical workflow

28 [110] Nuclear medicine Deep learning and radiomics 1
  • Introduce the basic design of neural network

  • Review of influential works, strengths, and limitations of deep learning approaches as compared to the conventional approaches

29 [111] MRI, CT, PET, SPECT, ultrasound, tomosynthesis, and radiology Neural network, deep learning, and machine learning 227
  • Discuss the basic terms of AI (e.g., machine and deep learning) and analyze the integration of AI in radiology

30 [112] Mammogram, ultrasound, MRI, and tomosynthesis ANN, CADe, CADx, CNN, deep learning, and machine learning 8
  • Overview on current application of deep learning approaches in breast radiology

  • Identify and highlight the challenges and research gap of AI application in breast radiology

31 [113] Mammogram, ultrasound, and MRI Deep learning 5
  • Review of current knowledge and future prospective of AI-enhanced breast imaging modalities in clinical workflow

32 [114] Mammogram, ultrasound, MRI SNN, SDAE, DBN, and CNN 2
  • Review on state-of-the-art AI approaches in the last decade to detect breast cancer using different breast imaging modalities

33 [115] Mammogram, ultrasound, MRI, and tomosynthesis Deep learning and AI-CADe 79
  • Review the current limitations and future prospective of AI-CADe in breast imaging

34 [116] Tomosynthesis, CT, and FDG PET/CT ANN, DNN, SVM 84
  • Review the recent progress and strength of AI applications in cancer diagnostic and prognostic

  • Identify how AI technology can improve cancer diagnostic and prognostic from the clinical perspective

35 [117] Ultrasound Machine learning and deep learning 8
  • General overview on the context of AI, machine learning, and deep learning technologies

  • Review of current progress in deep learning technologies and highlight future perspective, challenges, and research gap of biomedical AI systems in ultrasound

36 [118] Mammogram, tomosynthesis, ultrasonography, and MRI CADe, radiomics, IoT, and machine learning tools 17
  • Critical review on advent methods for screening, diagnostic, staging, grading, molecular, and genetic biomarkers

  • Highlight the interdisciplinary key terms of such methods for scientists and physicians

37 [119] Mammogram and CT Deep learning, CADe 6
  • Highlight major areas in oncology imaging with great potential of AI application

  • Identify potential bottlenecks of AI application in oncology imaging

38 [120] Mammogram, ultrasound, PET, CT, and MRI CADe, ANN 127
  • Outline the progress of AI and CADe in general clinical imaging

39 [121] Ultrasound CADx 20
  • Highlight recent progress in CADx in breast ultrasound

  • Recommend future direction of CADx in breast ultrasound

40 [122] Mammogram, ultrasound, MRI, and thermography Machine learning, deep learning, and CADx 42
  • Highlight new application of deep learning and machine learning approaches in detection and classification of breast cancer and outline the overview of such progress

  • Review different breast imaging modalities and correlate these modalities with AI

41 [123] Mammogram Radiomics 0
  • Highlight the potential role of radiomics in mammography

  • Identify the bottlenecks and research gap of such application

42 [124] MRI and DCE-MRI Radiogenomics 0
  • Review multidimensional mining algorithms in the context of MRI radiogenomics for CADe and CADx of breast tumors

43 [125] Tomosynthesis, MRI, ultrasound, MBI Machine learning and CADx 3
  • Review the current progress in imaging of high-density breast for diagnostic of breast lesions

44 [126] Thermography SVM, ANN, and CADx 42
  • Review of recent advances, recommendation, and road ahead for detection of breast cancer using infrared thermography

45 [127] Mammogram AI-CADe 62
  • Review of past, present, and future role of AI in medical imaging

  • Highlight the challenges of AI application in imaging

  • Highlight the role of AI-CADe with PACS

46 [128] Mammogram and MRI CNN 1
  • Highlight the fundamental in AI and its application in medical imaging analysis

47 [70] General breast imaging Machine learning, ANN, deep learning 11
  • Explore the evaluation and use of AI in breast imaging

  • Explore the application of AI in breast imaging from the ethical, technical, and legal perspective

Purpose Specific Review
48 [129] Mammogram, ultrasound, SWE, SWV, and sonoelastography CADx, SVM, CNN, LASSO, and ridge regression 4
  • Highlight the functions of ultrasomics and its capability in disease diagnostic (precision medicine) in different organs

  • Highlight the limitations, challenges, and opportunities in ultrasomics application

49 [130] Mammogram, ultrasound, and MRI Deep learning and radiogenomics 13
  • Highlight the functions and integration process of radiogenomics

  • Remark the strategies and relevant algorithms in such application

50 [131] Mammogram, ultrasound, and tomosynthesis Machine learning and deep learning 54
  • Highlight the functions and role of AI in early detection of breast cancer

  • Highlight the readiness of AI in breast cancer imaging

51 [132] EIT PSO, ANN, GA, and other machine learning algorithms 44
  • Highlight the functions and roles of EIT and its application with AI

52 [133] DOT Deep learning 3
  • Highlight the roles, background, and relevant tools of AI in DOT

53 [134] Ultrasound Deep learning 2
  • Highlight the roles of AI in cancer, dermatology, cardiology, respiratory problems, neurodegenerative disorders, and gastroenterology

54 [135] PET/CT and PET/MRI Radiomics 16
  • Highlight the solutions and challenges of radiomics application in hybrid PET/CT and PET/MRI

55 [136] Mammogram CADe and CADx 28
  • Highlight the roles of CADe and CADx in mammography

56 [137] Mammogram, ultrasound, DBT, and MRI Deep learning, CADe, and CADx 3
  • Highlight the functions of AI applications in medical tasks and reasons for AI to be classified as a medical device

  • Review the functions of CADe and its sub-elements

  • Outline the FDA process in approving the CADe software

57 [138] Ultrasound CADe and CNN 0
  • Highlight the variation of ultrasound for dense breast imaging amongst average risk women

58 [139] Thermography SVM, ANN, BN, CADe, CNN, and GA 0
  • Highlight the roles of AI in thermography for early detection in breast cancer

59 [140] Thermography ANN 13
  • Highlight the roles of infrared thermography in breast imaging associated with clinical evidence that favor and unfavored such application

  • Outline the historical timeline of infrared thermography

Systematic Review
60 [141] Mammogram, ultrasound, MRI, DBPET, DWI, PWI, CT, PET/CT, and PET/MRI Radiomics, machine learning, and deep learning 5
  • Analyze and compare the conventional and advent breast imaging techniques

  • Highlight the roles and future perspectives of advent breast imaging techniques in prediction of the response to NAC

61 [142] Thermography SVM, ANN, DNN, and RNN 81
  • Analyze and compare the studies in breast cancer detection using CADe and deep learning models

62 [143] Mammogram, CT, and MRI Machine learning, deep learning, and ANN, 1
  • Analyze the potential of AI in medical imaging

  • Discuss the methodology, application, limitations, challenges, and future perspective in radiology

63 [144] Mammogram, ultrasound, CT, and MRI Deep CNN 2
  • Systematic review of current progress and state-of-the-art methods in intrafractional target motion management in breast cancer radiation therapy

64 [65] Mammogram, DCE-MRI Machine learning and deep learning 3
  • Systematic survey on 185 papers in cancer prediction and diagnostic using AI

65 [64] Mammogram, ultrasound CNN, ANN, DNN, MLP, SVM, DT, GA, KNN, NB, LR, LA, and GMM 12
  • Structured review on image processing, machine learning, and deep learning in breast imaging

Mixed Method Review
66 [145] Ultrasound and tomosynthesis DNN, RCNN, faster RCNN, deep CNN, and ReLU 4
  • Commentary on current progress of DNN in computational radiology in the context of breast imaging and diagnostic

67 [146] Mammogram, tomosynthesis, ultrasound, tomography, and MRI Multilayered DNN 12
  • Review of novel approaches in breast imaging aided with AI

68 [147] Mammogram and MRI Radiomics 22
  • Review of various medical imaging modalities in the context of early detection

  • Highlight the applications of various medical imaging modalities, the respective benefits, and the application of radiomics in such modalities

69 [148] MRI Machine learning and transfer learning 0
  • Systematic survey on application of machine learning in assessment of ALNM using MRI

70 [149] Mammogram, ultrasound, and MRI ANN, SNN, CNN, and CADe 41
  • Systematic survey of breast cancer classification in different breast imaging modalities aided by DNN approaches

Qualitative Review
71 [150] Mammogram, CT, and MRI Machine learning 51
  • Qualitative survey of the impact of AI on radiology

* Data retrieved from the Scopus database as of 17 June 2022. AI: artificial intelligence; CNN: Convolutional Neural Networks; ANN: Artificial Neural Network; RBFN: Radial Basis Function Network; KNN: K-Nearest Neighbors; PNN: Probability Neural Network; SVM: Support Vector Machine; C-DCNN: DeConvolutional Neural Networks; CT: Computer tomography; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging; FDG: fluorodeoxyglucose; PET: Positron Emission Tomography; CADe: computer-aided detection; NLP: natural language processing; 3D: three dimensional; DBCT: Dedicated breast computed tomography; DWI: diffusion-weighted imaging, NIR: Near-Infrared; SPECT: Single-photon emission computed tomography; CADx: computer-aided diagnosis; DCE-MRI: dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging; DCIS: ductal carcinoma in situ; GANs: generative adversarial networks; DBT: digital breast tomosynthesis; CEDM: Contrast-enhanced digital mammography; SNN: Shallow Neural Network; SDAE: Stacked Denoising Autoencoder; DBN: Deep Belief Network; DNN: deep neural networks; IoT: Internet of things; MBI: molecular breast imaging; PACS: picture archiving and communications system; SWE: shear wave elastography; SWV: shear wave viscosity; LASSO: least absolute shrinkage and selection operator; MRE: Magnetic resonance elastography; EIT: Electrical impedance tomography; PSO: particle swarm optimization; GA: genetic algorithm; DOT: Diffuse optical tomography; BN: Bayesian network; CE-MRI: contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging; NAC: Neoadjuvant chemotherapy; DBPET: Dedicated breast positron emission tomography; PWI: perfusion weighted imaging; RNN: recurrent neural network; MLP: Multi-layer Perceptron; DT: decision tree; NB: naïve bayes; LR: Logistic Regression; LA: Linear discriminant analysis; GMM: Gaussian Mixture Modelling; RCNN: Region-Based Convolutional Neural Network; ReLU: rectified linear unit; ALNM: axillary lymph node metastasis.