Table 3.
Characteristics of the main review articles on BCAA supplementation in cirrhosis.
Study, Year | Study Type | Number of Studies Included | Population | BCAA Intervention | Comparison | Measurements | Main Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Konstantis et al., 2022 [37] | Meta-analysis | 20 | Adults with cirrhosis, including HCC | Hypo- or hyper- caloric formulas |
Diet, snacks, M-DXT, L-ALB & casein | SMI and/or MAMC | Slight significant increase in BCAA group compared to control group |
Tricipital skinfold | Decreasing trend in the BCAA group, without differences with the control | ||||||
BMI | Significant increase in the BCAA compared to control | ||||||
Ismaiel et al., 2022 [36] | Meta-analysis | 17 | Adults with cirrhosis, excluding HCC | Hypo- or hyper- caloric formulas |
M-DXT, diet, L-ALB & No group of comparison |
SMI and/or MAMC | Significant increase in BCAA group, without differences compared to control |
Handgrip strength | Non-significant increase at the end of BCAA therapy and compared to control | ||||||
Tricipital skinfold | Non-significant decrease with BCAA vs control therapy | ||||||
Ooi et al., 2018 [35] | Systematic review | 40 | Children & adults with cirrhosis or hepatic failure, including HCC | Hypo- or hyper- caloric formulas |
Diet, casein, etc & No group of comparison |
Fat free mass | No variation in 75% of studies |
Muscular strength | Increased in 75% of studies | ||||||
Fat mass | No variation in 75% of studies | ||||||
Body weight | No variation in 76% of studies |
HCC: hepatocellular carcinoma, M-DXT; maltodextrins, L-ALB: lactalbumin, SMI: skeletal muscle index, MAMC: mid-arm muscle circumference, BMI: body mass index.