Table 1.
A brief overview of the literature.
Research Areas | Technique(s)/References | Research Focus |
Finding(s) | Application(s) | Limitation(s) | Author(s) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Image monitoring |
Thermal imaging [1] |
Nondestructive plant physiology monitoring | Stress at an early stage was alleviated. Irreversible damage and yield loss were prevented. | Scales | A few square centimeters can be studied | Chaerle L. et al., 2000. |
RGB imaging [2,28,29,30] |
Identification, quantification, and monitoring of plant diseases | Diseases in Cotton, Apple, Grapefruit, and Canadian goldenrod were identified. | Precision in agriculture, plant phenotyping |
Low image quality, low detection accuracy | Mahlein, 2016 Camargo and Smith, 2009; Bock et al., 2008; Wijekoon et al., 2008 |
|
Fluorescent imaging [3] |
Leaf damage without visible signs, photosynthesis analysis, and fluorimeter comparison of PSM, MFMS, PAM101 |
A significant difference between same-population leaves and photosynthesis changes was observed. Tree and branch damage patterns were identified. | Natural vegetation, ecological research |
Application-dependent | Bolhar-Nordenjampf et al., 1989 | |
Hyperspectral imaging [4] |
Ground-based hyperspectral reflectance of yellow rust disease inoculation. Nutrient-stressed treatment to detect and discriminate yellow rust disease from nutrients. | At major growth stages, four vegetation indices clearly responded to disease. Disease and nutrient stress affected most spectral features. The physiological reflectance index was disease-sensitive. | Disease monitoring and mapping | Cost and complexity | Zhang J et al., 2012 | |
Spectroscopy | X-ray fluorescence [5] |
Benchtop XRF to evaluate the elemental distribution change in living plant tissue exposed to X-rays | Higher Zn content than Mn in stems was found. The latter micronutrient presented a higher concentration in leaf veins. | Plant tissue analyses under in vivo conditions | X-rays injure biological tissue | Montanha et al., 2020 |
Mass [6] |
Monitoring the auxin-regulated nicotine biosynthesis in tobacco and evaluating possible biological effects | Rupture of trichomes and cell damage were observed on spots exposed to Low-Temperature Plasma. | Biosynthesis of plant surface in vivo measurement | Destructive to live cell structure | Martínez-Jarquín et al., 2018 | |
Raman [7] |
High-throughput stress phenotyping of plant measurement | Unique negative correlation between concentration levels of anthocyanins and carotenoids was observed. | Plant stress in vivo | Destructive method | Altangerel et al., 2017 | |
Electrical-based sensor approaches | Microneedle electrodes [8,9] |
Measure the xylem sap flow to understand plant physiology | Good adaptation of the microneedle probe in the plant tissue was possible. | Plant physiology (tomato) |
Not accurate | Baek et al., 2018; Daskalakis et al., 2018 |
Organic electrochemical transistor [10] | Real-time monitoring of the electrolyte of tomato plant’s physiological state | A circadian pattern of variation was revealed, which shows the possibility to detect signs of abiotic stress. | Precision farming, plant physiology | Slow response to plant change, low accuracy | Coppedè et al., 2017 | |
EIS | ZARC-cole and CPE model; CNLS using LEVM7 [14] | Develop EIS for nondestructively evaluating plant root growth of willows | Sum of R1 and R2 in the distributed electric model decreased with an increase in root mass. | Root growth assessment | Minor damage due to insertion of needle’s electrode | Repo et al., 2005 |
Single-DCE model; CNLS using LEVM v.6 program [15] |
Cold acclimation and measurement of frost hardening. | Both quantitative and qualitative changes in cell membranes and water-status were observed. EIS results indicate weaker hardiness than other tests. | Frost hardening capability measurement | System dependent with limited functionality | Väinölä and Repo, 2000 | |
Different models; nlmin function in S-PLUS [16,17] |
Track the electrical change response of fruit physiology and analyze their ripening | Cell wall and vacuole resistance decreased by 60% and 26%, respectively, and membrane capacitance decreased by 9%. | Fruit and vegetable quality measurement | System-dependent, which may limit functionality | Bera et al., 2017; Harker and maindonald, 1994 |
|
Electrical parameter (Z, R, Y, G), with simple linear regression analysis [19] | Determining the effect of Total Soluble Solids (TSS) on the electrical conductivity of reconstituted apple juice. | EIS parameters are good for determining TSS content. Rapid determination of the TSS content in different fruit juices, detection of their adulteration |
Food quality measurement | Lack of changes in physicochemical qualities | Żywica and Banach, 2015. | |
Sensor based on four electrodes and three indexes as indicators of leaf water content [20] | Develop water-saving agriculture and increase water-use efficiency | Negative correlation with all three parameters was observed. Relative water content showed the best correlation with the leaf property. | Crop production (leaf water content) | Existence of a severe fringe effect | Zheng et al., 2014. | |
Four different models; CNLS method [24] | Determine the best electrical model for plant tissues analysis | Plant tissue conformed better to a double-shell model than others. | Plant tissue analysis | - | Zhang and Willison, 1991. | |
* Finding R-C with DSM to understand plant physiology | Monitor and understand leaf physiology for 16 h using double-shell model parameters and a comparative analysis. | were obtained. The results confirmed previous studies in the literature of. Rapid changes in R1, R2, C3, and C5 were noticeable after water uptake. Possibility of detecting a plant with slow growth status. | Plant physiology for crop production and precision in agriculture. | System-dependent | Proposed |
* The outcome of this study is presented in this table (in the last row) and can be used as a comparison with previous studies.