Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 24;16(10):853–874. doi: 10.1002/term.3335

TABLE 2.

Advantages and disadvantages of the selected cardiac tissue models and their possible applications

Model Advantages Disadvantages Application
Organoids Robust; high throughput Difficult to control, many cardiac lineages, low perfusability; limited maturity and pharmaceutical responses; no organotypic behavior Screening for cardiotoxicity in early drug development phases
Muscular thin films (MTFs) Organized structures, robust, high‐throughput; well‐developed and real‐time response measurement system Medium‐to‐low maturity; limited tissue organization; limited possibility for ECM development Screening of drug effects and cardiotoxicity
Cell sheets Well established and standardized manufacturing procedures; unlimited tissue source; easy to handle in the laboratory Difficult for application for inexperienced medical staff; rely on proper homing and adhesion; limited complexity; use limited to the size of the tissue injury; relatively low throughput Regenerative medicine; heart infarction treatment
Engineered heart tissue (EHT) Advanced maturation due to the mechanical stimulation in 3D environment; ECM allows for modeling of the larger than cellular scale disease effects; reproduces physiological features and complicated structural mechanisms of the heart tissue; response to the stimuli similar to mature human heart tissue; possibility to employ several cell types Complicated culture system; difficult to handle and measure (requires specific equipment); hard to standardize; low throughput Disease modeling; drug screening in preclinical phases; regenerative medicine (limited use)
Heart‐on‐a‐chip Higher CM maturity; direct experimental access to the cell/tissue; controlled environment for cell development; medium–high throughput; automated cultures Complicated system requiring installation of the specific equipment and supply of additional gases and media; relatively low flexibility (requires changes in chip design, specific expertize, and equipment). High chip prices Drug screening for functionality and toxicity; studies of paracrine effect of the cells (combined media systems)
De‐/Recellularized heart Mimic the properties of native heart matrix, maintain cell–cell contact and stiffness, mechanical anisotropy Difficult to reproduce, hard to recellularize in terms of cells compartmentalization; species/personal differences; require access to the source of human heart tissues in good shape—limits the accessibility of the technique (the only model to still have this limit); currently low physiological functionality; lowest throughput Heart transplantation procedures, replacement of the viable human heart organs
In vivo mouse heart model Possibility to study hormonal regulation and organ‐to‐organ interactions in the whole organism Difference in physiology (ex. Action potential duration, heat rate), differences in ion channels expression (ex.) Basic research, preclinical studies (currently major model)