TABLE 1.
References | Intervention | Setting | Population | Minimum criteria for RC | Maximum criteria for RC | % RCBD | Current Episode |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Antipsychotics | |||||||
Tohen et al. 2006 | Olanzapine vs. Placebo | IN/OP | BD‐I | ≥4 episodes in last year | n/a | 50% | Euthymia |
Baldessarini et al. 2003 a , b | Olanzapine vs. Placebo | VAR | BD‐I | DSM‐IV | n/a | 35% | Mania, mixed |
Sanger et al. 2003 a | IN/OP | 100% | Mania, mixed | ||||
Suppes et al. 2014 | Quetiapine vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | ≥4 episodes in last year | ≥8 episodes in last year | 27% | Depression |
Cutler et al. 2011 | Quetiapine vs. Placebo | IN/OP | BD‐I | DSM‐IV | ≥8 episodes in last year | 31% | Mania, mixed |
Vieta et al. 2007 a | Quetiapine vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | ≥4 episodes in last year | n/a | 21% | Depression |
Thase et al. 2006 | Quetiapine vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | DSM‐IV | n/a | 31% | Depression |
Muzina et al. 2008 a | Aripiprazole vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I | DSM‐IV | n/a | 100% | Euthymia |
Suppes et al. 2008b a , b | Aripiprazole vs. Placebo | IN/OP | BD‐I | DSM‐IV | n/a | 20% | Mania/mixed |
Bobo et al. 2011 | Risperidone LAI vs. TAU | OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | ≥4 episodes in last year | n/a | 100% | Depression, (hypo)mania |
Mood stabilisers | |||||||
Kemp et al. 2012 | Lamotrigine vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | DSM‐IV | n/a | 100% | Depression |
Wang et al. 2010 | Lamotrigine vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | DSM‐IV | n/a | 100% | Depression, mixed, (hypo)mania |
Suppes et al. 2008 | Lamotrigine vs. Lithium | OP | BD‐II | DSM‐IV | n/a | 72% | Depression |
Calabrese et al. 2000 a | Lamotrigine vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | DSM‐IV | n/a | 100% | (partially) remitted |
Goldsmith et al. 2003 | Lamotrigine vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | DSM‐IV | >20 episodes in last year | 100% | (partially) remitted |
Walden et al. 2000 | Lithium vs. Lamotrigine | OP | BD‐I | ≥4 episodes in last year | >12 episodes in last year | 100% | Mania |
Antidepressants | |||||||
Ghaemi et al. 2021 | Citalopram vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | DSM‐IV | n/a | 28% | Depression |
Parker et al. 2006 | Escitalopram vs. Placebo | CO | BD‐II | ≥1 episode per month | n/a | 100% | Depression, euthymia |
Post et al. 2006 a | Venlafaxine vs. Bupropion vs. Sertraline | OP | BD‐I/II/NOS | DSM‐IV | n/a | 27% | Depression |
Other classes | |||||||
Walshaw et al. 2018 | Levothyroxine vs. T3 vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | ≥4 episodes in last year | n/a | 100% | Depression, (hypo)mania |
Keck et al. 2006 | Ethyl‐EPA vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐I/II/NOS | DSM‐IV | n/a | 51% | Depression, (hypo)mania |
Lenz et al. 2016 | CPT vs. Bibliotherapy | OP/IN | BD‐I/BD‐II c | ≥8 episodes in last 2 years | n/a | 16% | (partially) remitted |
Multiple classes | |||||||
Amsterdam et al. 2017 a | Venlafaxine vs. Lithium | OP | BD‐II | DSM‐IV & ≥4 episodes per year average | n/a | 47% | Depression |
Amsterdam et al. 2013 | Fluoxetine vs. Lithium vs. Placebo | OP | BD‐II | ≥4 episodes per year average | n/a | 31% | Euthymia |
Amsterdam et al. 2009 | Venlafaxine vs. Lithium | OP | BD‐II | ≥4 episodes per year average | n/a | 32% | Depression |
Suppes et al. 2005 a | Olanzapine vs. Divalproex | IN/OP | BD‐I/BD‐II | ≥4 episodes in last year | n/a | 58% | Mania, mixed |
Tohen et al. 2003 | Olanzapine vs. Placebo vs. OFC | IN/OP | BD‐I | ≥4 episodes in last year | n/a | 37% | Depression |
Langosch et al. 2008 | Quetiapine vs. Na Val | NR | BD‐I/BDII | DSM‐IV | n/a | 100% | (partially) remitted |
McElroy et al. 2010 | Quetiapine vs. Paroxetine vs. Placebo | NR | BD‐I/BDII | ≥4 episodes in last year | >8 episodes in last year | 18% | Depression |
Abbreviations: BD‐I, bipolar disorder type I; BD‐II, type II; CO, community; CPT, cognitive psychoeducational therapy; DSM‐IV, Diagnostic & Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edition; ethyl‐EPA, ethyl‐eicosapentanoate; IN, inpatient; LAI, long‐acting injectable; Na Val, sodium valproate; NA, not applicable; NOS, not otherwise specified; NR, not reported; OFC, olanzapine fluoxetine combination; OP, outpatient; OTH, other; RC, rapid cycling; RCBD, rapid cycling bipolar disorders; T3, triiodothyronine; TAU, treatment as usual.
Secondary analyses/multiple articles per study (see Supplement 2).
Data pooled from 2 trials (each). NB for Baldessarini/Sangar et al., Baldessarini (and other secondary articles; see Supplement 2) pools two trials, while Sangar et al. includes data from one of these trials; the overlap of data here is indicated via apparent merging of rows in the table.
ICD rather than DSM criteria.