Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Mar 22.
Published in final edited form as: J Water Clim Chang. 2022 Mar 22;13:1684–1705. doi: 10.2166/wcc.2022.363

Table 3 |.

Summary of factors affecting resilience of selected forestry BMPs

BMP Class Climate Change Sensitivity Adaptation Strategies
Wildland fire control and suppression • Increased frequency and severity of drought will necessitate more severe suppression techniques, making it more difficult to minimize adverse effects
• Drier conditions and unstable soil will increase the amount of soil disturbed and ground cover lost, further increasing erosion and runoff from suppression activities
• Increase public awareness about how wildfires may change with climate change as fire suppression efforts become more costly with warming climate
• Remove active fuels from sites to control fires before they occur
• Maintain natural fire regimes to reduce long-term intensities of wildfires
• Manage fuel buildup by thinning or prescribed fires
Use of prescribed fire • Increased frequency and severity of drought may limit the applicability of controlled burns as forests become drier, especially with increasing intensity and unpredictability of winds
• Invasive species and pest infestations may increase difficulty in selectively administering controlled burns
• Promote use of controlled fires in areas where severe wildfires are expected
• Consider use of mechanical thinning in forests with very high fuel loads and extreme drought
Road location and design • Increased risk of road-related landslides and soil erosion due to severe and frequent precipitation, storm events • Modify culvert size to reduce risk of flood damage
• Avoid construction of roads near unstable soils to minimize risks of slope failure from precipitation and snowmelt
Stream crossings • Changes in timing and volume of peak flows may damage infrastructure, pose threats to aquatic life, and impact potable water where stream crossings occur if they are not designed appropriately
• Existing crossings may not be adequate if high flow events increase
• Increase culvert size below roads to reduce risk of flood damage to existing stream crossings and downstream resources
• Evaluate established crossings to assess present suitability
• Design stream crossings to be compatible with geomorphology of streams
Landing area management • Soil is extensively disturbed at log landings, leading to erosion and runoff that is amplified by increased precipitation and storm events • Scatter logging slash over landings and skid trails to stabilize and reduce erosion after operations
• Consider placing landings a significant distance from streams likely to be affected by extreme precipitation events
Yarding operation • Erosion may increase due to increasing frequency of heavy precipitation
• Increased precipitation may also increase the hazard of slope failure in forested areas where ground-based operations are placed
• Erosion may increase in select areas with permafrost melting
• Establish operational sites on stable soils
• Consider precipitation and storm potential before establishing skidding and yarding infrastructure
Erosion prevention and control • Mitigating the effects of mechanical vegetation treatment post-operation will likely increase in difficulty as changing precipitation and storm patterns increase erosion, runoff, soil instability, and slope failure • Perform low-impact harvesting
• Adjust harvest schedules to focus on winter harvesting
• Consider partial harvests
• Switch to pre-operation erosion prevention rather than post-operation control
Harvest unit planning and design • Increased runoff and flooding after harvesting in response to increased heavy precipitation • In cold areas use winter harvest to mitigate impacts of wet soils on harvesting
• Reduce large-scale clearcutting
• Promote natural regeneration
• Increase rotation periods in coppices
Selective cutting • Increased climatic variability, heavy precipitation and permafrost melt may lead to soil instability
• Forests may require increased frequency and intensity of selective cutting due to increased prevalence of insect infestation and disease
• Modify harvest schedule to remove stands that are vulnerable to disturbance
• Use persistent wood products to mitigate carbon losses when harvested
• Adjust harvest schedules to winter-focused harvesting
Streamside management zones (SMZs) • Heavy precipitation could increase flow velocity and decrease efficiency of buffer filtering and promote gullies in buffers
• Increased tree mortality changes the width, density, and composition of buffers
• Increase buffer width and density where possible to enhance the ability of the buffer to absorb nutrients and filter sediment
• Use Effective Function Width tool to assess and maintain effectiveness of stream buffers

Note: See Supplementary material for references.