Advantages
True representation of CNS cell types needed to study HIV reservoirs
All cell types of human origin and real reflection of the disease time course
Prefect for therapeutic targeting and reliable disease outcome from longitudinal studies
|
Advantages
Macaques are closer to humans in terms of physiologic make up
SIV infection of macaques follow a progressive disease pattern similar to that of humans
SIV infection in primates respond to cART therapy as like in humans
Myeloid reservoir cell types from CNS can be isolated at different time points to study and perform long‐term in vitro mechanistic studies
Larger animal size allows more sample collection at a particular time point
Both HIV and SIV have similar histone acetylation pattern in the brain
Replication‐competent virus carrying macrophages were reported in macaques
Cells of myeloid origin have more or less similar distribution in HIV and SIV
|
Advantages
HIV‐infected humanized mice have shown hall mark signs of HIV infection in the brain such as neuronal death, neurocognitive impairments and activation of microglia
Microglia and lymphocytes in humanized mice represent brain reservoir
Replication‐competent virus was isolated from virally suppressed humanized mice brains and shown to establish fresh infection in new humanized mice
Fewer brain cells are required to perform QVOA in humanized mice for validation of HIV cure studies
Myeloid cells isolated from MoM mice have been shown to carry and spread viral infection independent of T cells
Low cost maintenance and these colonies can be established around the world for any longitudinal studies
Shorter duration to get accurate data on any proposed model to look at CNS reservoirs
Have a complete functional human immune system, which lasts up to 1 year for any neurologic and CNS reservoir studies
|
Limitations
Difficult to obtain CNS samples
The variability of the timing of infection and comorbidities
Variability in viral load and immune cell expression because of recent late‐stage patients
Variability of therapeutic approaches
most studies on microglia are limited to primary cultures or from postmortem brains, which may not reflect latent reservoirs as in living patients
|
Limitations
SIV and HIV virus are not identical genetically and have differential response in disease progression
Larger differences in MHC genes between humans and macaques
Macaques have different innate immune factors that control SIV replication as compared to humans
High cost and maintenance for any proposed CNS studies
Primate research facility availability is scarce around the world for CNS and reservoir studies
CNS reservoirs get established much earlier (∼3 days) than in other models
SIV viral loads are much higher in brains of macaques as compared to humans so studying latency is a challenge
Vpx protein in SIV have been shown to reduce a myeloid restriction factor leading to higher level of infection in myeloid cells, as compared with other HIV model studies
|
Limitations
‐Collection of lesser volume of samples during intermediate time point of analysis
‐Need sterile environment for HIV‐specific CNS studies on severely immunodeficient mice
‐Graft‐versus‐host disease in some humanized mice models based on transplantation of human hematopoietic stem cells
|