Table 1.
Author and country | Setting | Population (inclusion criteria) | Comparator | N | Type of intervention | Primary outcome(s) | Who delivered the intervention | Intervention format (individual/group/community) | Training and supervision (yes/no) By whom? | Fidelity measured (yes/no) and how? | Intervention duration | Follow up time | Overall ROB |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Weight gain | |||||||||||||
Attux et al. (2013) Brazil |
Outpatients and inpatients | Schizophrenia DSM-IV 18–65 years Motivated or showing concerns about weight |
Standard care | 85 | Lifestyle | Body weight BMI Waist circumference |
Mental health professionals (nurses, occupational therapists, psychologists and dietitians) | Group (Patients and their relatives) | Yes, trained with a manual and a set of DVDs explaining the program Program coordinator supervises and follow up any absence in sessions |
Not stated | 12 weeks, 1 h sessions | 12 weeks | Low |
Baptista et al. (2007) Venezuela |
Outpatients and inpatients | Schizophrenia (DSM-IV) <18 years Free of hormone replacement and any chronic diseases |
Placebo | 72 | Pharmacological (Metformin 5–20 mg a day) | Body weight BMI Waist circumference |
Research psychiatrists and social workers | Individual | Not stated | Not stated | 12 weeks | 12 weeks | Some concerns |
de Silva et al. (2015) Sri Lanka |
Outpatients | schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder (ICD-10) <18 years treated with atypical antipsychotics, who had increased their pre-treatment body weight by more than 10%, | Placebo | 66 | Pharmacological (Metformin 500 mg a day) | Body weight BMI Waist circumference |
Not stated | Individual | Yes, supervision – If there were problems with tolerability of 500 mg dosage, participants were treated with a lower dose of 250 mg, which was then titrated to the standard dose. | Not stated | 24 weeks of treatment | 24 weeks | Low |
Methapatara and Srisurapanont (2011) Thailand |
Outpatients | Schizophrenia (DSM-IV) 18–65 years BMI > 23 kg |
Very brief intervention | 64 | Lifestyle | Body weight BMI Waist circumference |
Therapist | Mixture of individual and group intervention | Yes, training on motivational interview | Not stated | 6 sessions of 1 h each week | 12 weeks | High |
Romo-Nava et al. (2014) Mexico |
Outpatients and inpatient | schizo-Phrenia or Bipolar disorder (DSM-IV) 18–45 years free of DSM-IV current substance abuse or a history of substance dependence in the last six months; | Placebo | 44 | Pharmacological (Melatonin 5 mg a day) | Body weight BMI Waist circumference |
Psychiatrist | Individual | Yes, training of psychiatrists to deliver the intervention. | Not stated | Eight weeks of medication | 8 weeks | Some concerns |
Wu et al. (2008) China |
Outpatients | 18–45 years First psychotic episode of schizo-Phrenia (DSM-IV) |
Placebo | 128 | Pharmacological and/or lifestyle intervention (Metformin 750 mg a day) | Body weight BMI Waist circumference |
Physiologist | Individual for the pharmacological intervention, group for the lifestyle intervention | Not Stated | Not Stated | 12 Weeks of medication or lifestyle interventions (psychoeducational, dietary, and exercise) | 12 weeks | Low |
Sleeping patterns | |||||||||||||
Kumar et al. (2007) India |
Outpatients | paranoid schizophre-nia.DSM-IV <18 years insomnia, defined as sleep-onset latency that was 30 min or greater, that had been present for at least the past 2 weeks | Placebo | 40 | Pharmacological (Melatonin 3–12 mg a day) | Time spent to fall asleep | Medical doctors | Individual | Not stated | Not stated | 2 weeks | 2 weeks | High |
Physical activity | |||||||||||||
Acil et al. (2008) Turkey |
Outpatients | Schizophrenia DSM-IV | Usual care | 30 | Physical activity | World Health Organisation Quality of Life Scale-Turkish Version (WHOQOL-BREF-TR) | Psychiatrist | Group | Not stated | Not stated | 10 week exercise program | 10 weeks | High |
Loh et al. (2015) Malaysia |
Inpatients | schizophrenia between the age of 18 to 65 DSM-IV <18 | Usual care | 104 | Physical activity (Structured walking) | Quality of life | Psychiatrist | Group | Yes, training was provided to therapists, nurses, psychiatrists, nutritionists, and pharmacists involved in the intervention. | Not stated | 12 week exercise program | 12 weeks | High |