Table 2. Comparison of methods for delivering crystals into the X-ray beam for room-temperature crystallography, based on their current state of development.
Background-scatter evaluation assumes, for fixed-target approaches, that excess liquid around crystals has been minimized by blotting or suction. For alternative comparisons of these methods, see Table 1 in Cheng (2020 ▸) and Table 1 in Martiel et al. (2019 ▸).
Sample-delivery method | No. of crystals | Crystal size range | Crystal targeting | Data-collection modes | Total volume of crystals probed by X-rays (%) | Background scatter | T = 100 K and multi-T data collection? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fixed targets | |||||||
Glass capillary | 1–∼10 | <2 mm | Center on each crystal; raster | Full (360°) oscillation; helical scanning | ∼100% | High | Maybe |
Loop/mesh + polymer capillary | 1–∼102 | <1 mm | Center on each crystal; raster | Full oscillation; helical scanning | ∼100% | Moderate | Yes |
Loop/mesh + humidified gas stream | 1–∼102 | <1 mm | Center on each crystal; raster | Full oscillation; helical scanning | ∼100% | Low | Yes |
Solid support with array of holes/wells/windows | |||||||
Small area/HT MX compatible | 1–∼104 | <hole size (∼10–20 µm) | Step and repeat | Partial oscillation (∼10–90°) | 0.1–10% | Low | Yes |
Large area | 1–∼106 | <hole size (∼10–20 µm) | Step and repeat | Fixed orientation | 0.1–10% | Low | No |
X-ray transparent support (polymer, SiN) | |||||||
Small area/HT MX compatible | 1–∼104 | <2 mm | Center on each crystal; raster | Nearly full oscillation; helical scanning | ∼100% | Low | Yes |
Large area | 1–∼106 | <2 mm | Center on each crystal; raster | Fixed orientation | ∼100% | Low | No |
Jets, streams, tape | |||||||
Liquid jets | >109 | <jet diameter (<10 µm) | Jet moves through beam at ∼30 m s−1 | Fixed orientation | <0.01% | Low | No |
LCP and LVE injector streams | >106 | <gel diameter (<30 µm) | Gel moves through beam at mm s−1 | Fixed orientation | <1% | Moderate | No |
Drop-on-tape | >106 | <drop diameter (<200 µm) | Drops move through beam at mm s−1 | Fixed orientation | <0.1% | Moderate | Maybe |