Unadjusted |
Unbiased in all settings. |
Typically reduced power compared to adjusted approaches. |
ANCOVA/Adjusted |
Typically leads to increases in power. |
Retains good properties if many covariates adjusted for. |
No issues with estimation of standard errors in small samples. |
Bias in non-linear interaction setting. |
Marginal odds ratio cannot be targeted. |
Convergence issues if risk ratio is of interest. |
G-computation |
Undercoverage and high type I error in small sample sizes. |
Bias in non-linear interaction setting; alleviated by allowing for interaction. |
IPTW |
Covariate–outcome relationship need not be specified. |
Undercoverage and high type I error in small sample sizes and adjusting for a few covariates. |
Overcoverage if adjusting for many covariates. |
Convergence issues if there are many covariates. |
Slight bias in non-linear interaction setting. |
AIPTW |
Either covariate–treatment or covariate–outcome relationship needs to be correct. |
Undercoverage and high type I error in small sample sizes. |
Convergence issues if there are many covariates. |
Slight bias in non-linear interaction setting. |
TMLE |
Either covariate–treatment or covariate–outcome relationship needs to be correct. |
Standard errors can be underestimated if efficient influence function based estimators are used. |
Slight bias in non-linear interaction setting. |