Table 2.
Year | First Author | Ref. | Patients n. | M/F | ICI | irAEs n. (%) | Thyroid irAEs n. (%) | Hypothyroidism n. (%) | Thyrotoxicosis n. (%) | Previous Thyroid Disease n. (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018 | Guaraldi F | [48] | 52 | 22/30 | 52 (100%) ipilimumab 29 (55.8%) nivolumab for disease progression |
- | 7 (13.4%) | 1 (1.9%, 4 euthyroid HT)) 7 (13.4%) |
3 (5.7%) (1 transient) |
3 (5.7%) |
2019 | Yamauchi I | [53] | 200 | 134/66 | 200 (100%) nivolumab | - | 67 (33.5%) 40 (20%) subclinical 27 (13.5%) overt |
- - 11 (5.5%) post thyrotoxicosis |
- - 17 (8.5%) |
NA |
2021 | Paderi A | [54] | 43 | 35/8 | 33 (76.7%) nivolumab 10 (23.7%) nivolumab plus ipilimumab |
29 (67.4%) | 19 (44.2%) endocrine irAEs 15/19 (78.9%) thyroid irAEs |
15 (43.88%) | 8/19 early thyrotoxicosis | NA |
2022 | Karhapaa H | [55] | 140 | 75/65 | 21 (15%) ipilimumab, 46 (33%) nivolumab, 67 (48%) pembrolizumab, and 6 (4%) ipilimumab + nivolumab | - | 41 (29.2%) endocrine irAEs 36/41 (87.8%) thyroid irAEs |
- 8 (22%) |
- 14 (39%) |
NA |
2021 | Ferreira JL | [58] | 161 | pembrolizumab, nivolumab, and ipilimumab |
- | 29 (18%) | 8.7% primary 4.3% central 2.5% biphasic thyroiditis |
2.5% | NA | |
2021 | Luongo C | [59] | 96 | 66/30 | 67 (69.1%) nivolumab, 18 (18.5%) pembrolizumab, 9 (9.3%) ipilimumab |
- | 36 (38%) | 11 (30.5%) | 25 (69.5%) transient | NA |
2021 | Muir CA | [60] | 1246 | 824/422 | 165 (13%) ipilimumab, 236 (19%) nivolumab, 448 (36%) pembrolizumab 285 (23%) ipilimumab + nivolumab, and 112 (9%) others |
- | 518 (42%) | 100 (8%) | 388 (31%) | NA |
2020 | Basak EA | [61] | 168 | 103/65 | 118 (70%) nivolumab 50 (30%) pembrolizumab |
- | 54 (32%) 34 (20%) subclinical 20 (12%) overt |
- | - | 27 (16%) |
2021 | Rubino R | [63] | 251 | 119/62 | 154 (61.35%) nivolumab 97 (38.65%) pembrolizumab |
70 (27.89) endocrine irAEs 66/70 (94.28%) thyroid irAEs |
34 (51.52%) | 17 (22.72%) | 28 (73.68%) |
HT: Hashimoto’s thyroiditis; NA: not available.