Table 3.
Dimension | Feedback (Identified Issue) |
Adaptation |
---|---|---|
STRUCTURE
& DESIGN |
Information presented in long paragraphs. |
|
Difficult to distinguish between sections |
|
|
Difficult to identify important information within a section |
|
|
Difficult to follow the information included in Module 3 (Lesson 2) which describes several relaxation exercises |
|
|
CONTEXT | The way that the role of young carers is presented needs to be ‘normalised’ |
|
Young carers need to be ‘protected’ from heavy caring loads and inappropriate caring responsibilities and this needs to be reflected in the text |
|
|
A context of support: the programmed needs to present all possible and expected sources of support (across all modules) |
|
|
CONTENT
(Illustrations) |
Patronizing (e.g., balloon images) |
|
Meaning hard to understand |
|
|
Threatening (e.g., warning symbol in ‘Tip’ and ‘Remember’ text boxes) |
|
|
Cover image not appropriate for young people |
|
|
CONTENT
(Narratives) |
Characters in case scenarios primarily older adults, often spouses | Case scenarios across five modules edited and new ones created:
|
Case scenarios describing activities or situations unlikely (or inappropriate) for a young person | ||
No mention of schools and the role they might play |
|
|
Lack of information regarding transition to care home (and the impact it might have on young carers) |
|
|
LANGUAGE | Too technical (complex) | Example: ‘Transmitters’ replaced by ‘chemicals’; ‘Visual hallucinations’ explained as ‘seeing things that are not there’; ‘Delusions/Unreal thoughts’ replaced by ‘strong belief not shared by others (unreal beliefs)’; ‘Distressing self-protected behaviours’ replaced by ‘difficult behaviours’ |
Too formal or threatening | Example: ‘Brain tumour’ deleted; ‘How to plan pleasant activities’ replaced by ‘Making time for yourself’; ‘Unmet needs’ replaced by ‘things you or the person living with dementia needs but you are struggling to achieve’; ‘Promote good sleep’ replaced by ‘help the person with dementia sleep better’; ‘Changes in judgement’ replaced by ‘saying the wrong thing at the wrong time’ | |
Old fashioned | Example:‘Making a phone call’ replaced by ‘on your phone (mobile)’ | |
Use of language that can sound ‘judgemental’ in the multiple-choice case scenario exercises |
|
|
Use of language that implies that everybody’s experience of living with dementia and their symptoms are the same |
Example: ‘People with dementia experience…’ replaced by ‘Sometimes people with dementia may experience…’
‘Remember’ text box added: ‘Just because a person has one or two of the symptoms listed in Activity 1 doesn’t mean they have dementia’ (Module 1) |
|
In Module 3 (Lesson 3) there is only reference to pleasant activities |
|
|
Language that sounds ‘too much like school’ |
|