Table 1.
Authors | Year | Location | Study design | Sample size | Ages | Outcome | Radiation exposure | Timing of exposure | Measure of association | Study quality assessment* |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Andreassi et al | 2020 | Italy | Case–control | 357 | 37.2 ± 5.2 |
LBW Miscarriage Stillbirth |
Medical occupation | Paternal only exposure | Odds ratios | Moderate |
Chen et al | 2018 | China | Retrospective cohort | 192,492 | 25.1 ± 3.9 | LBW | Medical diagnostic | Paternal only exposure | Odds ratio | Good |
Chiarelli et al | 2000 | Canada | Cohort | 668 | > 18 |
LBW Miscarriage |
Medical therapeutic | Prior to pregnancy | Odds ratios | Good |
Choi et al | 2013 | South Korea | Age-matched cohort study | 642 | 31.7 ± 3.8 |
Birth weight Gestational age |
Medical diagnostic | During pregnancy | Odds ratio (excluded from meta-analysis) | Moderate |
Doyle et al | 2000 | England | Retrospective cohort | 27,261 | 39.8 ± 4.1 |
Miscarriage Stillbirth |
Nuclear occupation | Prior to pregnancy | Odds ratio | Moderate |
Fucic et al | 2008 | Croatia |
Case–control cohort |
462 | 12–51 | Miscarriage | Medical occupation | Prior to pregnancy | Odds ratio | Good |
Goldberg et al | 1997 | Canada | Retrospective cohort | 2426 | > 15 |
LBW Miscarriage Stillbirth |
Medical diagnostic | Prior to pregnancy | Odds ratio | Good |
Gong et al | 2017 | Texas, USA | Case–control | 3,481,077 | > 11 | LBW | Residential proximity | Prior to and during pregnancy | Odds ratio (excluded from meta-analysis) | Good |
Grajewski et al | 2015 | USA | Case–control | 844 | 26–49 | Miscarriage | Flight occupation | During pregnancy | Odds ratio | Good |
Green et al | 2002 |
Canada USA |
Retrospective cohort | 4029 | > 15 |
LBW Miscarriage Stillbirth |
Medical therapeutic | Prior to pregnancy | Relative Risk | Good |
Green et al | 2010 | Canada | Case–control | 1856 | > 15 | LBW | Medical therapeutic | Prior to pregnancy | Odds ratios derived from frequencies | Good |
Guilbaud et al | 2019 | France | Prospective cohort | 638 | 30.4 ± 0.7 |
Miscarriage Gestational age |
Medical diagnostic | During pregnancy | Odds ratio | Good |
Ha et al | 2015 | Florida, USA | Prospective cohort | 423,719 | 26.7 ± 7.1 | LBW | Residential proximity | During pregnancy | Odds ratio (excluded from meta-analysis) | Good |
Hatch et al | 2017 | Chernobyl | Retrospective cohort | 2582 |
Birth weight Gestational age |
Nuclear disaster | During pregnancy | Parameter estimate (excluded from meta-analysis) | Good | |
Hujoel et al | 2004 | USA | Case–control | 5585 | 12–45 | LBW | Medical diagnostic | During pregnancy | Odds ratio | Good |
Igumnov & Drozdovitch | 2000 | Chernobyl | Case–control | 500 | Birth weight | Nuclear disaster | During pregnancy | Slope (excluded from meta-analysis) | Moderate | |
Kallen et al | 1998 | Sweden | Cohort | 19,494 |
LBW Stillbirth Gestational age |
Medical therapeutic | Prior to pregnancy | Relative risk | Moderate | |
Lawson et al | 2012 | USA | Retrospective cohort | 7482 | 25–42 | Miscarriage | Medical occupation | During pregnancy | Odds ratio | Good |
Mortazavi et al | 2013 | Iran | Cohort | 1200 | 20–40 | LBW | Medical diagnostic | During pregnancy | Mean + SD (excluded from meta-analysis) | Moderate |
Parker et al | 1999 | Cumbria, UK | Cohort | 251,812 | Any | Stillbirth | Nuclear occupation | Paternal only exposure | Odds ratio | Moderate |
Reulen et al | 2009 | Britain, UK | Retrospective cohort | 7300 | > 16 |
LBW Miscarriage Stillbirth |
Medical therapeutic | Prior to pregnancy | Odds ratio | Good |
Signorello et al | 2006 |
Canada USA |
Retrospective cohort | 3376 | Any | LBW | Medical therapeutic | Prior to pregnancy | Odds ratio | Good |
Tsou et al | 2020 |
Taiwan, China |
Case–control | 853 | 27.1 ± 3.8 |
LBW Birth weight |
Residential proximity | During pregnancy | Odds ratio (excluded from meta-analysis) | Moderate |
van de Loo | 2019 | Nether lands | Nested cohort | 275 | > 18 |
LBW Miscarriage |
Medical therapeutic | Prior to pregnancy | Odds ratio (excluded from meta-analysis) | Moderate |
Winther et al | 2008 | Denmark | Cohort | 34,922 | 12–48 |
Miscarriage Stillbirth |
Medical therapeutic | Prior to pregnancy | Proportion ratio | Moderate |
Zhang et al | 2020 | Wuhan, China | Prospective cohort | 8500 | 28.6 ± 3.7 | Birth weight | Residential proximity | During pregnancy | Odds ratio (excluded from meta-analysis) | Good |
*The quality of the study was assessed by the criteria described by (Moola et al. 2020)