Table 2.
Grouping of MeOx ENMs and their bulk analogues based on dissolution results in water and DMEM (48 h of incubation, 100 mg/L initial concentration) using screening criteria from OECD ENV/JM/MONO (2015)44. Results from the current study (MnO2, ZnO, CeO2, Al2O3, Fe2O3) combined with results from Avramescu et al. [2020] (CuO, NiO, TiO2). In blue are the ones that fall in a different category (“negligible”) at 24 h than at 48 h. Red boxes show nano falling in a different category than bulk (nd = not detected; <LOD = below the limit of detection); * 24 h results (48 h not available).
Media | Form (Initial Concentration) | MeOx | High (>70%) | Moderate (10–70%) | Low (1–10%) | Negligible (<1%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Water | Nano (100 ppm) | ZnO | ZnO, 2.83% (2.28 mg/L) | |||
MnO2 | MnO2, 0.03% (0.02 mg/L) | |||||
CeO2 | CeO2, 1.07% (0.87 mg/L) | |||||
Al2O3 | Al2O3, 1.38% (0.73 mg/L) | |||||
Fe2O3 | Fe2O3, <0.01% (<10 ug/L) | |||||
CuO * | CuO, 0.99% (0.79 mg/L) | |||||
NiO | NiO, 1.22% (0.96 mg/L) | |||||
TiO2 * | TiO2, <0.01% (<10 ug/L) | |||||
Bulk (100 ppm) | ZnO | ZnO, 0.87% (0.70 mg/L) | ||||
MnO2 | MnO2, 0.11% (0.08 mg/L) | |||||
CeO2 | CeO2, nd | |||||
Al2O3 | Al2O3, <0.01% (<10 ug/L) | |||||
Fe2O3 | Fe2O3, <LOD | |||||
CuO * | CuO, 0.17% (0.19 mg/L) | |||||
NiO | NiO, 0.05% (0.05 mg/L) | |||||
TiO2 * | TiO2, <0.01% (<1 ug/L) | |||||
DMEM | Nano (100 ppm) | ZnO | ZnO, 19.3% (15.5 mg/L) | |||
MnO2 | MnO2, 3.87% (2.44 mg/L) | |||||
CeO2 | CeO2, 0.42% (0.34 mg/L) | |||||
Al2O3 | Al2O3, 0.73% (0.39 mg/L) | |||||
Fe2O3 | Fe2O3, nd | |||||
CuO | CuO, 51.5% (41.1 mg/L) | |||||
NiO | NiO, 1.81% (1.42 mg/L) | |||||
TiO2 * | TiO2, 0.04% (0.03 mg/L) | |||||
Bulk (100 ppm) | ZnO | ZnO, 11.8% (9.8 mg/L) | ||||
MnO2 | MnO2, 1.37% (0.94 mg/L) | |||||
CeO2 | CeO2, nd | |||||
Al2O3 | Al2O3, 0.02% (0.01 mg/L) | |||||
Fe2O3 | Fe2O3, nd | |||||
CuO | CuO, 1.51% (1.39 mg/L) | |||||
NiO | NiO, 0.07% (0.06 mg/L) | |||||
TiO2 * | TiO2, <0.01% (<1 ug/L) |
* 24 h results (48 h not available).