Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 8;39(11):e14945. doi: 10.1111/dme.14945

TABLE 5.

Confidence in synthesised qualitative findings for ‘high’ importance TDF domains

COM‐B TDF domain, definition (component constructs) Finding Number of studies (N) (participants) Confidence and explanation
Capability (Psychological) Knowledge

(Lack of) knowledge of specific health behaviour recommendations to prevent future T2DM risk

(Lack of) knowledge of link between GDM and future T2DM risk

19 (444) Bandyopadhyay 2015; Gaudreau; Hjelm 2007; Hjelm 2012; Hjelm 2018; Ingol; Jones 2015; Kilgour; Mohd Suan; Nielsen 2015; Oza Frank; Pace; Pinidiyapathirage; Rafii; Razee; Stotz; Sunny; Tang; Whitty Rogers

6 (149) Bernstein & Gunn; Krompa; Mohd Suan; Pace; Rafii; Pace

High confidence: Finding is supported by 19 studies with moderate methodological concerns, and no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

High confidence: Finding is supported by six studies with minor methodological concerns and no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

Behavioural regulation

Planning and engaging with postpartum health behaviour recommendations

Sustaining lifestyle changes made during pregnancy

16 (354) Bandyopadhyay 2015; Campbell; Gaudreau; Hjelm Hjelm 2012; 2018; Jones 2012; Kilgour; Krompa; Muhwava; Oza Frank; Pace; Pinidiyapathirage; Rafii; Razee; Tang; Whitty Rogers 2016

6(93) Bandyopadhyay 2011; Hjelm 2007; Hjelm 2012; Hjelm 2018; Pinidiyapatharige; Whitty Rogers

Moderate confidence: Finding is supported by 16 studies with moderate methodological concerns, no or minor coherence concerns, minor adequacy concerns and no or very minor relevance concerns

High confidence: Finding is supported by six studies with minor methodological concerns and no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

Opportunity (Physical) Environmental Context and Resources

Competing demands

Education and resources

Environment and accessibility of facilities

16 (529) Bandyopadhyay 2015; Bernstein & Gunn; Campbell; Ingol; Jones 2015; Mathew; Mohd Suan 2015; Oza Frank; Pace; Pinidiyapathirage; Rafii; Razee; Sunny; Tang; Tewari

14(319) Bandyopadhyay 2011; Bandyopadhyay 2015; Campbell; Doran; Gaudreau; Ingol; Jones 2015; Krompa; Nielsen 2015; Pace; Pinidiyapathirage; Razee; Tewari; Zulfiqar

15(473) Bernstein & Gunn; Campbell; Ingol; Jones 2015; Mathew; Mohd Suan; Muhwava; Oza Frank; Pace; Pinidiyapathirage; Rafii; Sakeena; Sunny; Tewari; Whitty Rogers

High confidence: Finding is supported by 16 studies with moderate methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

High confidence: Finding is supported by 14 studies with minor methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

Moderate confidence: Finding is supported by 15 studies with moderate methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence and adequacy concerns and minor relevance concerns

Opportunity (Social) Social Influences

Finding value in the health advice of HCPs

Seeking social/emotional, pragmatic and peer support from family and friends to enable postpartum health behaviours

Respecting social norms of a women's cultural group

23(518) Campbell 2017; Bandyopadhyay 2015; Bernstein & Gunn; Doran; Gaudreau; Hjelm 2007; Hjelm 2012; Hjelm 2018; Ingol; Kandasamy; Kilgour; Krompa; Mathew; Muhwava; Nielsen 2015; Oza Frank; Parsons; Pinidiyapathirage; Rafii; Sakeena; Sunny; Tewari; Zulfiqar

19 (543) Campbell; Bandyopadhyay 2011; Bandyopadhyay 2015; Gaudreau; Ingol; Jones 2015; Krompa; Mathew; Mohd Suan; Oza Frank; Pace; Pinidiyapathirage; Rafii; Razee; Sakeena; Sunny; Tewari; Whitty Rogers; Zulfiqar

5(160) Ingol; Jones; Neufeld; Pinidiyapathirage; Zulfiqar

High confidence: Finding is supported by 23 studies with minor methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

High confidence: Finding is supported by 19 studies with minor methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

High confidence: Finding is supported by five studies with minor methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

Motivation (Automatic) Emotion

Fear screening procedure or T2DM diagnosis, or that T2DM management will be the same as GDM management

Impact of early parenthood and migrant experience on emotions including postpartum abandonment

9(162) Bernstein&Gunn; Campbell; Doran; Hjelm 2007; Neufeld; Pinidiyapathirage; Rafii; Sakeena; Sunny

6(148) Campbell; Hjelm 2012; Muhwava; Parsons; Razee; Zulfiqar

High confidence: Finding is supported by nine studies with minor methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

Moderate confidence: Finding is supported by six studies with moderate methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence and adequacy concerns and minor relevance concerns

Motivation (Reflective) Beliefs about Consequences

Beliefs about the impact of postpartum health behaviours on women's daily lives

Beliefs about importance of postpartum health behaviours and future T2DM risk

Cultural beliefs, norms and myths about diet and exercise in the postpartum period

20(509) Bandyopadhyay 2011; Bandyopadhyay 2015; Campbell; Doran; Gaudreau; Hjelm 2018; Ingol; Jones 2012; Jones 2015; Krompa; Muhwava; Neufeld; Oza Frank; Pinidiyapathirage; Razee; Sakeena; Sundarapperuma; Sunny; Tewari; Zulfiqar

17 (300) Bandyopadhyay 2011; Bandyopadhyay 2015; Bernstein&Gunn; Doran; Ingol; Jones 2015; Krompa; Mathew; Muhwava; Neufeld; Pinidiyapathirage; Rafii; Sakeena; Sundarapperuma; Sunny; Tang; Zulfiqar

4(82) Krompa; Pinidiyapathirage; Sundarapperuma; Zulfiqar

High confidence: Finding is supported by 20 studies with moderate methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

Moderate confidence: Findings is supported by 17 studies with moderate methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

Moderate confidence: Finding is supported by four studies with moderate methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence and concerns, minor adequacy concerns and moderate relevance concerns

Social/Professional Role and Identity Placing one's healthcare needs secondary to those of the newborn and secondary to family and cultural norms and needs 19(376) Bandyopadhyay 2011; Bandyopadhyay 2015; Boyd; Campbell; Jones 2012; Jones 2015; Mathew; Muhwava; Pinidiyapathirage; Razee; Sakeena; Sundarapperuma; Sunny; Tang; Tewari; Zulfiqar

High confidence: Finding is supported by 19 studies with moderate methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence, adequacy and relevance concerns

Beliefs about Capabilities

Perceived (in)ability to manage T2DM risk, perceived inevitability of T2DM

Lack of confidence in capability to adhere to postpartum health behaviour recommendations

7(151) Bandyopadhyay 2015; Bernstein&Gunn; Campbell; Hjelm 2018; Jones 2012; Jones 2015; Razee;

6(103) Bandyopadhyay 2011; Doran; Hjelm 2007; Jones 2012; Pinidiyapathirage; Whitty Rogers

High confidence: Finding is supported by seven studies with minor methodological concerns, no or very minor coherence and adequacy concerns and minor relevance concerns

Moderate confidence: Finding is supported by six studies with minor methodological concerns, minor coherence concerns, moderate adequacy concerns and no or very minor relevance concerns