Skip to main content
Elsevier - PMC COVID-19 Collection logoLink to Elsevier - PMC COVID-19 Collection
. 2023 Jan 9;232:109972. doi: 10.1016/j.buildenv.2022.109972

An international survey on residential lighting: Analysis of summer-term results

Rengin Aslanoğlu a,∗, Jan K Kazak a, Sepideh Yekanialibeiglou b, Piotr Pracki c, Begüm Ulusoy d
PMCID: PMC9827736  PMID: 36644492

Abstract

Obtaining visual comfort, satisfaction and well-being in residential interiors are now becoming more important, especially in times of extreme events such as the COVID-19 pandemic. It also became important to collect users' evaluations and their own solutions for residential lighting in order to improve the current lighting conditions. For this aim, with a group of international and inter-disciplinary researchers, a comprehensive study was conducted. This study is the last part of a three-stage investigation aimed at increasing our knowledge of the current lighting conditions in residential areas during and after the COVID-19 pandemic. For the current study, an online survey and in-depth interviews were conducted between June and August 2022 in Poland, Turkey, Sweden, and the U.K., with 520 participants. As results of this study show, a correlation was found between daylight satisfaction and its sufficiency. Similar correlations were found between artificial lighting satisfaction, its sufficiency, and its uniformity. The differences between seasons were detected for being very satisfied with daylight quality. Also, the correlation between satisfaction with daylighting and the ratio of windows showed difference among seasons. Stronger correlations between satisfaction with artificial lighting, its sufficiency and uniformity were found in summerterm according to winter-term results. Correlations between artificial lighting brightness – CRI and uniformity weakened in summer-term. Results from open-ended questions and in-depth interviews showed, removing the shading device and augmenting the characteristics of artificial lighting were the mostly done adjustments during the COVID- 19 pandemic. The most prominent theme is visual comfort according to the in-depth interview responses.'

Keywords: Residential buildings, Residential lighting, Summer-term, Survey, In-depth interview

1. Introduction

Since people spend around 90% of their time in interiors, built environment is one of the most critical drivers of health [1,2]. This notion has been proven true with the outbreak of COVID-19. Many authorities, including the World Health Organization (WHO), give advice such as staying at home, publish technical guidance like “Critical preparedness, readiness and response” and many scientific briefs about COVID-19 (https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019). Extreme events such as COVID-19 can change the usual course of life by disrupting the routines of everyone around the world and forcing them to find novel ways to carry on studying, working and socializing from home. The importance of the quality of the built environment should be emphasized as this extreme event persists over a long period of time and is likely to be repeated. As [1] (p.1) highlighted “A built environment should continue to maintain optimal occupant physical, mental, and social well-being conditions during extreme events and over extended periods of time”. A broad survey conducted by the Royal Institute of British Architects in the U.K. by the outbreak of COVID-19 showed that staying in the residences for too long made people more stressed, anxious and depressed [3]. In the same survey, the majority (70%) of the participants stated that the inappropriate design of their residential areas affected their well-being, which turn negatively impacted their productivity. This means that residential area users need environmental support for their activities, and this state of environmental support is what is meant by comfort [4]. According to the environmental comfort model developed by Ref. [4] (See Fig. 1 ), comfort links the physical comfort, functional comfort, and psychological comfort for obtaining an overall satisfaction and well-being. When physical, functional or psychological comfort is not present in a built area, discomfort results and the area become uninhabitable. One of the most fundamental environmental factors in obtaining comfort is the physical comfort. It is mostly achieved through the ambient qualities of a built area such as temperature, air quality, lighting, noise. Physical comfort is followed by the functional comfort, which helps users perform their tasks, does not focus on how satisfied they are [4]. Physical and functional comforts overlap since they are two closely related concepts about generic human requirements to perform specific tasks. The last and most deterministic comfort in obtaining satisfaction and well-being is the psychological comfort. It is obtained through the attributes such as personal space, privacy, preference, personalization, and personal control over the environment [5].

Fig. 1.

Fig. 1

Environmental Comfort Model (Figure drawn by the first author which is adapted from [4].

It is important to highlight that the “environments that fail to respond to users' needs at one or more level of comfort risk creating a stressful situation that may have long-term negative consequences” [4] (p. 27). Thus, it is possible to create supportive, comfortable, and high-quality environments that meet users’ needs.

The relocation of workplaces, schools, and social spaces to residential areas [3] complicates the acquisition of comfort by blurring the boundaries of personal space, preferences, privacy, personalization, and personal control. Considering the novel functions of the residential areas and the wide range of visual tasks that can be held there (work, study, leisure and rest in general), the concept of comfort including physical, functional and psychological comfort, becomes increasingly important. In order to fulfill a wide range of visual tasks, which have become more complex due to the extreme situations caused by COVID-19, the quality of both daylight and artificial lighting in the residential areas should be reconsidered since our knowledge of the world around us is mainly based on vision, which requires the presence of light [6,7] (p. 71). Thus, visual comfort is closely related to all comfort attributes and plays an important role. For obtaining an overall comfort in interiors, occupants perform various actions to satisfy their physical and non-physical needs, such as adjusting temperature, opening windows for natural ventilation, drawing shading devices and turning on artificial lights [8]. According to the European standard on lighting terminology [27], visual comfort is defined as the conditions under which a person feels comfortable, and the factors affecting it are light sources (natural or artificial), illuminance, color temperature, luminance and uniformity of light [9]. They are directly related to the quality of vision, comfort, health, performance, productivity, and satisfaction [10, 11]. For instance, although it is less considered in international standards, recent studies have shown that correlated color temperature plays a vital role in human physiological and psychological functions [9]. Thus, choosing the light proper color temperature can improve visual comfort subjectively, reduce sleepiness [12], and increase productivity and motivation. Moreover, there is a strong preference for daylight in the workplaces, particularly related to the belief that daylight promotes health. It is possible to achieve better visual comfort, satisfaction and well-being in residential areas. But at the same time, energy efficiency is as important as quality of the luminous environment and user satisfaction. According to a public opinion survey conducted by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) in Great Britain in September 2022 by the participation of 5,000 households, it was found that 44% of adults who were responsible for energy bills were finding it “very or somewhat” difficult to make the payments [28]. The COVID-19 pandemic and colder winters are one of the variables causing the cost-of-living crisis [28]. Also, the increase in the time spend in the residential area is directly reflected in increase in the energy consumption [13]. As the previous study conducted by this paper authors [14] showed, 53% of participants spend 3–8 h, and 39% spend more than 8 h in their residential areas and mostly performing screen-related tasks, which in turn increases energy consumption. However, it is also known that the difference in electricity consumption is primarily due to differences in user activities and behavior [13,15] and willingness to act more sustainably. According to the study by Ref. [14]; 46.20% of the participants considered sustainability and aim to reduce their energy consumption by replacing their lamps with more energy efficient alternatives.

Briefly, an up-to-date and comprehensive perspective is needed to achieve better visual comfort and well-being in residential areas, especially in times of extreme events which persist over a long period of time and is likely to be repeated in the near future. As highlighted by Ref. [16]; well-being is related to wellness, happiness, and quality of life, comfort and health. Therefore, it is possible to create supportive and visually comfortable environments according to the needs of the users. At this point, it became important to collect users' evaluations and their own solutions for residential lighting in order to improve the current lighting conditions. Thus, this paper compares and contrasts residential lighting conditions in four different countries' winter-term results from Ref. [14] with the recently collected data for the summer-term using multiple-choice questions. Accordingly, the research question and the hypotheses of the study are presented below.

  • R.Q.: How do the factors of residential lighting effect visual comfort, satisfaction and well-being?

H1a

The quality of daylight in residential areas increases as its sufficiency increase.

H2a

The quality of artificial lighting in residential areas increases as its sufficiency increase.

H3a

The quality of artificial lighting in residential areas increases as its uniformity increase.

To answer research question, in-depth interviews were conducted and open-ended questions were asked in the survey. To test the hypotheses, survey questions were formed and distributed. Since daylight and artificial lighting is an intricate and broad concept that needs to be examined from various perspectives using more than one scientific methodology, mixed methods perspective was adopted in this study for gathering valuable knowledge about day and artificial lighting which cannot be obtained by a single methodology [14]. Hence, more detailed answers were collected through in-depth interviews, and open-ended questions.

Our previous studies [14], [17] and the current study gathered subjective assessments and identified the needs and problematic issues regarding lighting in residential areas. Besides highlighting the factors influencing high-quality day and artificial residential lighting living areas for all, our winter-term study [14] also showed important outcomes about policies and standards. Briefly, our studies highlighted the potential factors that affect visual comfort in residences which is worth elaborating and need detailed examination. Thus, the current study collected data for pointing out the factors influencing visual comfort and enhance the results with in-depth interviews, and open-ended questions. Since our studies included self-assessments from residential users, our results can be used as reliable recommendations for residential lighting conditions in early planning stages including policymaking, architectural and lighting design as well as future research.

2. Method

This current study is the final part of a three-step research aiming to gather information on residential lighting focusing on end-users’ evaluations and real-life applications. The first research step was to check the understandability and validity of the survey questions in which 60 participants were involved in our pilot survey in July–August 2020 [17]. The second step was about the winter-term which was conducted between November 2020 and January 2021 in which 500 participants (who were different from the pilot survey) were contributed [14]. For the current study, another 500 participants contributed in our summer-term survey between June–July 2022. Thus, a total of 1060 participants from Poland, Turkey, Sweden, and the United Kingdom assessed the lighting conditions in their residential areas via an online survey. Participation was voluntary at all stages of the study.

As our previous results have shown [14], the use of mixed methods helped us to collect diverse and rich data. By using mixed methods in this holistic study on residential lighting, new and valuable insights about day and artificial lighting were collected through the survey which was created by the authors that expanded quantitative results with qualitative data. In order to achieve a comprehensive understanding and generalization of residential lighting and to identify the possible causes and effects, quantitative methods with their large sample size and qualitative methods with their small but informative sample size were used to get more detailed and in-depth answers [18]. For this aim, the current survey with 48 multiple-choice and open-ended questions was distributed online in 4 countries. After completion of the surveys, in-depth semi-structured interviews were held online in July and August 2022.

Collected data were analyzed using IBM SPSS 27.0 (descriptive statistics and correlation coefficient functions indicating the direction of association with statistical significance) [19,20] and NVivo 20- QSR International for qualitative analysis (for open-ended questions and interviews).

2.1. Survey

For the current survey, some of the questions have been updated taking into account the results of our previous pilot [17] and winter-term studies [14]. The survey starts with participant information and a brief consent form. Unlike our previous surveys, a new question about working/studying remotely was added to the demographic questions section (age, gender, education level, place of residence, and approximate monthly household income). The same questions as in our previous surveys were used for gathering information about the characteristics of residential buildings including typology, number of rooms, and exact floor area. Two new questions on electricity expenditures were added to represent both economic and consumption factors by country. Similar questions were asked about the characteristics of the living areas (floor area, height, color lightness of surfaces, direction of the world that windows face, number of windows and their locations, and the view-out from the windows) where participants spend most of their time. Information was also collected on the number of hours spent and the type of activities the participants mainly performed in this living area. Questions about daylight conditions in their living areas (daylight quantity and its distribution, number of hours of direct sunlight penetration, shading device's type, and its position and purpose, the factors related to their satisfaction and dissatisfaction with daylight) were followed by the questions about artificial lighting conditions (artificial lighting usage time, its type, system, quantity, uniformity, lamp brightness, perceived color of light, color rendering quality, and the factors related to their satisfaction and dissatisfaction with artificial lighting). Previous surveys provided notable information on the adoption of sustainable lighting solutions and current national lighting policies. They also collected detailed responses on light-related adjustments that participants have made and generally intend to improve [14]. Hence, those questions were replaced with the two new open-ended questions about the light-related adjustments with daylighting and artificial lighting that participants had done and still effectively using in their living areas during COVID-19 pandemic. The survey was distributed online via e-mail invitations and/or cross-platform messaging (through a web-based survey tool offered by Google) in the primary languages of these four countries.

2.2. Interview

For online interviews pre-determined questions have been prepared with the entire research team. Also, a brief instruction sheet was prepared and one week before each interview, all of the interviewees were asked to take two or three photographs of their living areas by following the aforementioned instructions. The use of semi-structured interview questions and photographs of the living area gave opportunity to ask more to-the-point and flexible questions specific to each interviewee's lighting condition. With those questions, detailed answers about lighting preferences and shading device usage according to seasons were sought. Also, more questions were asked about light-related changes during the COVID-19 pandemic. Follow-up questions were asked about well-being and comfort. Each interviewee was carefully selected (who were more willing to provide information, were interested enough to provide insight into certain aspects of residential lighting, could express the topic by using some of the technical terminologies and mostly working/studying from home) by the research team using purposive sampling method. Each member of the research team searched for people who could be reached from their own country and communicated with those people (conducted a pre-conversation and provided briefings). As a result of these preliminary briefings, researchers evaluated and decided whether that person was suitable for interviews. All interviews were conducted using Zoom (Video Communications, Inc.). In July and August 2022, the first author conducted 20 online interviews (5 respondents from each country) in English (duration between 10 and 30 min). All participants gave consent for their interviews to be recorded.

3. Results and discussion

Demographic data of our summer-term survey indicate that 46.2% (231) of the participants were female, 53.2% (266) were male and 0.6% (3) did not wish to specify their gender. 38.4% were between 25 and 34 years old, 30.8% between 35 and 44 years old and 14.8% were between 18 and 24 years old; and 49.8% had a monthly income approximately equal to the national average. 38.8% the participants currently work/study from home 5 days per week. 25.2% work/study 3–4 days, 11.8% work/study 1–2 days per week, and 24.2% do not work/study from home. 75.8% of the participants work/study from home at least 1 day per week. This ratio, which is too high to be underestimated, once again emphasizes the importance of research on residential lighting. 62.4% of participants live in an apartment flat and the average floor area of the houses were 287 m2. 50% of the participants indicated their living rooms as the living area in which they spent most of their time in a day. 22.2% indicated their bedrooms as living areas, 21.8% specified office/study like rooms and 6% specified kitchens. More than half of the participants (58.4%) spent 3–8 h and 33% spent more than 8 h per day in their living areas. The most common activity performed in the living spaces is working on the computer (49%), followed by leisure/resting on the computer/TV (36.2%). 7.6% of the participants worked without a computer and 7.2% leisure/rest without computer.

32.9% of the living areas had 2 windows, 32% had 1 window only and 16.3% had 3 windows facing various directions of the world (26.6% of the windows face south and the rest of them face different directions). 32.6% of the living areas had a 10%–20% window to floor area ratio, 31.8% had 20%–40% and 12.2% had less than 10% window to floor area ratio (See Fig. 2 ), which affects visual comfort, view-out, daylight and sunlight penetration and energy efficiency. As [21] have pointed out large window areas allow more daylight into a space, but they can also allow excessive heat gains or loss which increases the cooling or heating load of the air-conditioning system and consequently the energy consumption.

Fig. 2.

Fig. 2

Bar chart showing the window to floor area ratio (Figure drawn by the authors).

55.1% of the participants monthly consumed 100–200 kWh of electricity (including all domestic appliances) in their living areas which was followed by 200–400 kWh of electricity at 24.8%. 15.85% of the participants consume less than 100 kWh and 4.2% consumed more than 400 kWh of electricity. These electricity expenditures were equal to the family's monthly household income: 5%–10% for 34.9% of the participants, 10%–15% for 28.1% of the participants, less than 5% for 27.1%, 15%–20% for 7.4%, and more than 20% for 2.6% of the participants regardless of country.

3.1. Comparison of residential lighting conditions in summer and winter terms

According to the participants’ answers, in summer, direct sun penetrates their living areas more than 4 h in 76.8% of cases in Poland, 69.6% of cases in Turkey, 77.6% of cases in Sweden and 76.8% of cases in the U.K. In winter, direct sunlight penetrates their living areas more than 4 h in 60.8% of cases in Poland, 74.4% of cases in Turkey, and only 40.8% of cases in Sweden and 44.8% of cases in the U.K. Except Turkey, the percentage of direct sunlight penetration increased in the summer-term. Most of the participants from 4 countries indicated that the amount of daylight in their living areas is sufficient (41.6%) (Turkey has the lowest rate for sufficient in the amount of daylight among all countries with 36.8%) and very sufficient (30%) (Poland has the lowest rate for very sufficient in the amount of daylight among all countries with 24%). Daylighting uniformity in the summer-term was reported as very uniform in Sweden by the 23.2% of the participants which is followed by Turkey (19.2%), Poland (12.8%) and the U.K. (10.4%). Nearly half of all the participants stated that their daylighting is uniform in their living areas in summer (Poland; 48.8%, U.K.; 44%, Turkey 42.4% and Sweden 38.4%). Overall, 29.6% of the participants indicated that they were very satisfied with daylight quality in their living areas during summer. This percentage was found to be 19.0% in winter-term [14]. Differences among countries according to seasons were also detected. For instance, owing to day length and sunshine duration differences, 36% of the participants in Sweden rated themselves very satisfied with daylighting (it was 8% for the winter-term) (See Fig. 3 ). For summer-term Sweden is followed by Turkey with 31.2% for daylight satisfaction (this percentage was 32% during winter). 28% of the participants from the U.K. indicated that they were very satisfied with daylighting during summer (it was 20% for winter-term). The percentage of being very satisfied increased from 16% (winter-term) to 23.2% (summer-term) for the case of Poland (See Fig. 3).

Fig. 3.

Fig. 3

Bar chart showing the satisfaction with daylight in summer-term (Figure drawn by the authors).

As our previous studies have shown [14], [17] there are factors affecting satisfaction with daylighting such as daylight sufficiency, daylight uniformity, number of hours of direct sunlight penetration, view-out and ratio of windows to the whole floor area of the living area. Similar to previous correlations which were found from the winter-term results [14], correlations found from the summer-term indicated no difference between seasons except the ratio of windows (See Fig. 4 and Appendix A). For the winter-term a very low and negative correlation was found (r = −0.136, p = 0.000) for satisfaction with daylighting and ratio of windows. However, for the summer-term a significant correlation could not be detected (See Fig. 4 and Appendix A). Daylight satisfaction had a moderately positive correlation with daylight sufficiency (r = 0.581, p = 0.000). As daylight sufficiency increased, so did daylight satisfaction. A low positive correlation between daylight satisfaction and daylight uniformity (r = 0.469, p = 0.000) and a very low positive correlation between view-out and satisfaction with daylighting (r = 0.235, p = 0.000) were found. Daylight satisfaction had a very low and negative correlation with the number of hours of direct sunlight in summer (r = −0.127, p = 0.000). Among all factors, daylight sufficiency had the strongest effect on daylight satisfaction. Also, a low positive correlation was found between daylight sufficiency and daylight uniformity (r = 0.464, p = 0.000); as uniformity of daylight increases its sufficiency increases as well.

Fig. 4.

Fig. 4

Diagram showing correlations from summer-term results about satisfaction with daylight, regardless of country (all of the correlation coefficient values shown in the figure are statistically significant for * p < 0.01 and **p < 0.001) [19,20] (Figure drawn by the authors).

Consistent with the winter-term results [14], a very low positive correlation was found between view-out and daylight uniformity and (r = 0.205, p = 0.000) and daylight sufficiency (r = 0.245, p = 0.000) (See Fig. 5 and Appendix A) indicating that the lower the window obstruction the more uniform and sufficient daylight became in the living area [14].

Fig. 5.

Fig. 5

Diagram showing correlations from summer-term results about view-out, regardless of country (all of the correlation coefficient values shown in the figure are statistically significant for **p < 0.001) [19,20] (Figure drawn by the authors).

A very low positive correlation was found between ratio of windows and number of hours of direct sunlight entering in the living areas (r = 0.239, p = 0.000) (See Fig. 6 and Appendix A) as it was found in the winter-term results [14]. The number of hours of direct sunlight increases during summer as the transparency of the living areas’ surfaces increases with larger window ratios [14].

Fig. 6.

Fig. 6

Diagram showing correlations from summer-term results about ratio of windows, regardless of country (all of the correlation coefficient values shown in the figure are statistically significant for **p < 0.001) [19,20] (Figure drawn by the authors).

In comparison with the winter-term, more occupants tend to draw their shading devices in summer. Across all countries, 25.4% of shading devices were not drawn (it was 45.0% during winter) (See Appendix B) and were mostly used to prevent direct sunlight penetration. Obtaining privacy was the leading purpose of the shading device during winter. Occupants in the U.K. and Poland mostly do not draw their shading devices both in summer and winter, however occupants in Turkey tend to draw their shading devices more than a half whereas occupants in Sweden draw less than a half during summer. The probable reason for drawing shading devices more than a half in Turkey can be the longer sunshine duration during summer and drawing less than a half in Sweden can be longer day length (average day length in Warsaw 15.8 h; Ankara 14.5 h; Gothenburg 16.8 h and London 15.7 h; sunshine duration in Warsaw 7.7 h; Ankara 11 h; Gothenburg 7.4 h and London 6.9 h https://www.weather-atlas.com/). Besides, having colder summers in Sweden than Turkey can be the other reason. So, occupants in Sweden may want to catch as much daylight and sunlight as possible. As the study conducted by Ref. [22] showed, short periods of sunshine had little effect on the shading device movement; however, long periods of sunshine of over 1 h generally triggered the shading devices to be more closed. The difference in shading device usage noted between seasons, may also be due to the hot summer season. Fear of overheating may cause some occupants to draw their shading devices more in summer [22].

Due to the longer day length and sunshine duration in summer, the use of artificial light per day decreased significantly compared to the winter-term. Nearly half (43%) of the participants turned on the artificial lightings in their living areas between 1 and 3 h on a summer day (it was 4 and 6 h in Turkey and the U.K., 7 and 9 h in Poland and Sweden on a winter day). However, a significant number of participants (31.7%) used their artificial lightings for 4–6 h on a summer day. Compared to the other countries, Sweden is the country that uses artificial lighting the most, for 4–6 h in summer with 45.6%. The Swedish Time Use Survey showed that people in Sweden are most likely spend the time in their residential areas the during afternoon hours [23], when daylight from the sun and sky is still available [24]. Most of the participants rated their artificial lighting as very sufficient (16.9%), sufficient (44%), non-disturbingly bright (41.4%), very uniform (15.2%) and uniform (43.2%). Depending on all those artificial lighting qualities, 48.4% of the participants were very satisfied and satisfied (20.8%) with their artificial lighting conditions. According to the summer-term results, moderately positive correlations were found between artificial lighting satisfaction and sufficiency (r = 0.517, p = 0.000) and uniformity (r = 0.532, p = 0.000) (See Fig. 7 and Appendix C). Those correlations were low positive correlations for winter-term results indicating a change in occupants' evaluations [14]. Occupants’ satisfaction with the artificial lighting increases as its sufficiency and uniformity increases. Also, artificial lighting sufficiency and uniformity are related (r = 0.379, p = 0.000). Further correlation was found between CRI and brightness (r = 0.152, p = 0.000), uniformity (r = 0.195, p = 0.000) and sufficiency (r = 0.129, p = 0.000). However, these correlations are very low only showing weak tendencies. Similarly, very low correlations were found between satisfaction with the artificial lighting and CRI (r = 0.200, p = 0.000) and brightness (r = 0.252, p = 0.000).

Fig. 7.

Fig. 7

Diagram showing correlations from summer-term results about satisfaction with artificial lighting regardless of country (all of the correlation coefficient values shown in the figure are statistically significant for **p < 0.001) [19,20] (Figure drawn by the authors).

Brightness level of the artificial lighting was found correlated with the number of hours for using artificial lighting, its sufficiency and uniformity. Thus, as the brightness of the artificial lighting increases, the number of hours it is turned on decreases (r = −0.121, p = 0.000) (See Fig. 8 and Appendix C). Though the high percentage of the participants evaluated their artificial lightings as non-disturbingly bright (41.4%), 11.7% of the participants perceived their lighting disturbingly bright which might lead them to not turn on their artificial lightings. Very low and positive correlations were found between brightness and sufficiency (r = 0.322, p = 0.000) and uniformity (r = 0.288, p = 0.000).

Fig. 8.

Fig. 8

Diagram showing correlations from summer-term results about brightness of the artificial lighting regardless of country (all of the correlation coefficient values shown in the figure are statistically significant for **p < 0.001) [19,20] (Figure drawn by the authors).

Comparative Factor Analysis were conducted to verify the factor structure of the set of measured variables (See Appendix D and Appendix E). Confirmatory factor analysis of daylighting (Model fit indices of the Comparative Fit Index (CFI) = 0.985) and artificial lighting (CFI = 0.968) showed that these hierarchical models fit the data. Since larger values of CFI indicating better fit (CFI values range from 0 to 1) and p < 0.001, it is possible to reject the null hypotheses (See tables at Appendix D and Appendix E).

As a summary of the survey results, it can be said that satisfaction with daylight correlates with daylight sufficiency, both in summer and winter. As daylight sufficiency increases, daylight satisfaction increases as well. Moreover, occupants’ satisfaction with the artificial lighting increases as its sufficiency and uniformity increase.

3.2. Analyses from open-ended questions and interviews

Responses to open-ended questions were optional, so 77 responses were received from the 500 participants regarding light-related adjustments with daylight, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. According to the results, four main themes on light-related adjustments with daylight were identified. Regardless of country, on average, the topmost theme is removing the shading device (33.8%). It is followed by keeping the shading device drawn more than before (22.1%), changing working area allocation (moving closer to natural light) (22.1%) and purchasing new (thinner) shading device (13%). Changing the division of the workspace (closer to natural light) was the most common adaptation in Poland (54.5%) and Turkey (60%). Of the 60% of participants who changed their working area allocation (moving closer to natural light) in Turkey, 44.4% of them changed their residential areas during and/or after COVID-19 pandemic. Most of the participants living in the U.K. adjusted their living areas by removing the shading device (43.7%). It has been found that when 40% of the shading devices used in an office building are drawn, a reduction up to 70% in the daylight was detected [25]. So, the participants in the U.K. may have completely removed their shading devices in order to get more daylight into their living areas. Removing the shading device (36.8%) and keeping the shading device drawn more than before (36.8%) are the two most commonly done adjustments made in Sweden. According to the open-ended questions, participants living in Sweden made adjustments mostly about their shading devices. However, they either remove their shading devices or tend to use them more often during and/or after COVID-19 pandemic. According to responses of five interviewees living in Sweden, two of the interviewees have no shading device in their living areas, two of them drawing their shading devices all throughout the summer for avoiding excessive heat gain and one of the interviewees using it in case of too much daylight and to obtain privacy. In summary, the use of shading devices in Sweden shows personal differences and no correlation between the use of shading devices and geographical differences could be found, as four out of five respondents live in the same city, Gothenburg.

Of 500 participants, 150 responses were received on artificial light-related adjustments. About the light-related adjustments with artificial lighting especially done during COVID-19 pandemic, three themes were identified; augmenting the characteristics of artificial lighting (35.3%) (i.e., changing the artificial light characteristics such as brightness level, uniformity, and color rendering index), adding artificial lighting (30%) and purchasing smart lighting systems (23.3%). The topmost theme in Poland (54.5%) and in the U.K. (40.7%) is augmenting the characteristics of artificial lighting, participants chose to change their old lamps with LED ones. In Turkey mostly done adjustment is adding artificial lighting (54.2%) such as desk lamps, and in Sweden is purchasing smart lighting systems (32.3%) for customizing artificial lightings intensity, CCT and color according to their needs.

For the in-depth interviews, 20 interviewees (five from each country), most of whom work/study from home, were selected based on their willingness to provide accurate information about the lighting conditions in their residential area. There were 11 female and 9 male interviewees (from Poland there were three males and two females, from Turkey two males and three females, from Sweden one male and four females and from the U.K. three males and two females). The average age of the interviewees is 36.3 years. 85% of the interviewees work on screen, while the rest work on paper.

Most qualitative data in many research projects are coded by a single coder [26], so the first author coded all the responses after all the interviews were fully transcribed by using NVivo Transcription - QSR International. From the responses of the in-depth interview, four main themes were derived. The top theme is visual comfort (46.7%) which is followed by seasonal conditions (23%), well-being (18.8%), and changes due to COVID-19 outbreak (11.5%) (See Fig. 9 and Table 1 ).

Fig. 9.

Fig. 9

Diagram the percentages of the themes and subthemes extracted from the in-depth interview answers (Figure drawn by the authors).

Table 1.

Identified themes from the in-depth interview responses (“+” indicates supporting features and “-” indicates hindering features of lighting).

Identified themes
Subthemes N (%)
Visual Comfort 57 (46.7%)
Artificial Lighting Conditions 27 (47.4%)
 +Controlling lighting with smart systems
 +Additional lighting for online meetings
 - Glare
 - Non-uniformity
Shading Device Conditions 17 (29.8%)
 +Privacy
 +Using shading device to prevent glare
 + Decoration
Daylight Conditions 13 (22.8%)
 - Non-uniformity
Seasonal Conditions 28 (23%)
 +Adjusting shading device
 + Enough daylight
 - Glare
 - Excessive sunlight exposure
Well-being 23 (18.8%)
 Daylight Conditions 15 (65.2%)
 +View-out from windows
 + Creating sense of comfort
 + Enhancing attention
 Artificial Lighting Conditions 5 (21.7%)
 + Creating cozy atmosphere
 No Effect on Well-being 3 (13.1%)
Changes due to COVID-19 14 (11.5%)
 +Changing desk location
 - Glare
 - Non-uniform daylight
Total 122 (100%)

Under the theme of visual comfort (46.7%), artificial lighting conditions (47.4%) are the mostly weighted subtheme. This is followed by shading device conditions (29.8%) and daylight conditions (22.8%). Thus, artificial lighting conditions have a greater impact on visual comfort than shading device conditions and daylight conditions. For instance, an interviewee from Sweden explained the conditions of the artificial lighting in his living area to achieve visual comfort:

You can point out in different directions, but I personally prefer more uniform of lighting than a directional lighting, so I typically just set them in three different angles, so they make basically a uniform lighting overall in the room, but you have the opportunity to basically have more directional lighting if you want to direct these lamps towards particular point.

This interviewee especially mentioned the uniformity of artificial lighting in obtaining visual comfort and highlighted that by changing the direction of the lights, the interviewee not only provides visual comfort but also directs the lights for different functions.

Shading device conditions and daylight conditions are as important as artificial lighting conditions for obtaining visual comfort. As an interviewee from Poland indicated that her visual comfort was deteriorated because of the excessive sunlight penetration in her living area and she highlighted the importance of using the shading device to restore her visual comfort again:

Because this morning was really very sunny. There is too much light. And it's not easy to use your laptop. You cannot see the screen properly. So, the shutter is very useful when on a sunny day you have to work in front of your laptop. You cannot see everything, so I use it.

The second topmost theme extracted from the in-depth interviews was the seasonal conditions (23%). Since these studies [14] [17], including present work, focus on lighting conditions in different seasons, the responses from the in-depth interviews are very useful for having detailed information. The interviewees from Poland and Turkey stated that there is generally not much difference between summer and winter and that they only use an additional lamp, such as a desk lamp in winter. Interviewees from the U.K. also indicated that there is not much difference between seasons. However, one of the interviewees from Sweden mentioned that there is a significant difference between the lighting conditions in summer and winter:

Basically, I would definitely need much more of an artificial lighting in the winter because we are living in Sweden, so it's getting dark. It can get dark as soon as the 3 PM, so you will need more artificial lighting, but in summer it's completely other way around. I basically need no artificial lighting during the work hours. Because it's up until 10 PM is bright.

The third most frequently mentioned theme was well-being (18.8%). Its subthemes were daylight conditions (65.2%), artificial lighting conditions (21.7%) and no effect on well-being (13.1%). As the percentages show, daylight conditions have a greater impact on well-being among the other subtopics. For example, one interviewee from Sweden stated that poor daylight conditions in her living area affected her well-being:

(…) because in my previous apartment I was in the same kind of poor manner again, facing wall because my desk was in a corner with two walls and then the window was like the other side and I was feeling a bit like, I don't know how to say, (…) I felt very bad for a while (…) I had the sleeping problem and I've got some sleep therapy. I explain how is the situation of my working place. And she told me that, make sure that you leave your apartment for 30 minutes in the morning, go out and get some light. It was very essential. It was very poor daylight. But here is the higher floor, so I have better access to daylight now.

As [4] highlighted, it is worth noting that when physical, functional or psychological comfort is not present in a built area, discomfort results and the area become uninhabitable. For the case of this interviewee, having poor visual conditions caused serious health problems such as sleeping disorder.

An interviewee from Turkey highlighted the importance of having a visual connection through large windows and how this connection enhances her productivity and well-being:

Definitely I could say light is everything and I love to have a large window where I can like whatever is outside, I can see in and is reflected into my office. And I mean as I said, whether it's rainy cloudy or sunny, I love to have this relation. I love to feel and be related to the outside whatever is going on. I love to see that, and I think the truth is really, really affects my productivity.

The second topmost mentioned subtheme under well-being was artificial lighting conditions. The ambient qualities of a built area such as lighting helps users to obtain visual comfort hence satisfaction and well-being [4]. The role of artificial lighting in achieving well-being is evident in this statement of an interviewee from Turkey:

In the evening time the cove lighting relaxes me.

The last extracted subtheme was no effect on well-being. Only 3 interviewees out of 20 mentioned that the lighting conditions in their living area had no effect on their well-being.

The purpose of this study was also to gather information about changes in residential lighting conditions during the COVID -19 pandemic. Changes due to the COVID-19 (11.5%) were the other themes extracted from the interviews. Three interviewees (two from Poland and one from the U.K.) mentioned that they used an additional portable lighting such as a desk lamp and a ring light during and after the COVID-19 pandemic. Moreover, four interviewees from Turkey stated that they changed the location of their desk to get more daylight. This change highlights that interviewees started to realize the importance of residential lighting during the COVID-19 pandemic:

Actually, at first the desk direction was the opposite. I mean I was looking at the piano side, but after all I observed that there is not let's say efficient light as it must be, I changed the direction my setting.

Both the open-ended and in-depth interview responses provided valuable information about residential lighting conditions and how those conditions changed according to the COVID-19 pandemic. Briefly, removing the shading device and augmenting the characteristics of artificial lighting were the most common adjustments made, according to the open-ended questions. As the responses to the in-depth interviews indicate, the most important issue with lighting conditions is visual comfort.

4. Conclusions

Obtaining visual comfort, satisfaction and well-being in residential interiors are now becoming more important, especially in times of extreme events such as the COVID-19 pandemic. It has progressed over a long period of time and is likely to be repeated in near future. Thus, exploring and enhancing the ambient qualities (such as temperature, air quality, lighting, noise) of a residential interior is significant. For this aim, with a group of international and inter-disciplinary researchers, a comprehensive study was designed and conducted [14], [17]. This study is the last part of a three-stage investigation aimed at increasing our knowledge of the current lighting conditions in residential areas during and after the COVID-19 pandemic. The light-related factors for satisfaction and well-being were explored with a comparison among seasons. For the current study, an online survey and in-depth interviews were conducted between June and August 2022 in Poland, Turkey, Sweden, and the U.K., with 520 participants.

The quality of lighting depends on many factors, such as illuminance, uniformity, correlated color temperature, color rendering index as well as perceived brightness, and sufficiency. As the results of this study show (Table 2 ), a correlation was found between daylight satisfaction and its sufficiency. Similar correlations were found between artificial lighting satisfaction, its sufficiency, and its uniformity. The differences between seasons were highlighted in bold in Table 2. For instance, being very satisfied with daylight quality increased during summer-term in all countries except Turkey. Also, a difference was detected in the correlation between satisfaction with daylighting and the ratio of windows among seasons. For summer-term a significant correlation could not be detected, however for winter-term a very low and negative correlation was found. In countries with longer winter seasons, it can be said that window ratios are effective in the satisfaction with daylight. More differences were detected among seasons in terms of artificial lighting (See Table 2). Stronger correlations between satisfaction with artificial lighting, artificial lighting sufficiency and uniformity were found in summer-term according to winter-term results. Thus, artificial lighting sufficiency and uniformity have more effect on satisfaction during summer. The correlations between artificial lighting brightness – CRI and artificial lighting brightness - artificial lighting uniformity weakened in the summer-term. A very low and negative correlation was found between artificial lighting brightness and the number of hours turning on lighting during summer-term. A similar correlation was not found for the winter-term. The differences among seasons in terms of artificial lighting indicate CRI and artificial lighting uniformity have a stronger effect in artificial lighting brightness during winter. The differences among summer and winter-term results emphasize the need to pay attention to the lighting design according to the season.

Table 2.

Summary of the results with comparison among seasons (difference among seasons highlighted in bold).

Summer Winter [14]
Being very satisfied with daylight quality (all countries) 29,6% 19%
Being very satisfied with daylight quality (Sweden) 36% 8%
Being very satisfied with daylight quality (Turkey) 31,2% 32%
Being very satisfied with daylight quality (U.K.) 28% 20%
Being very satisfied with daylight quality (Poland) 23,3% 16%
Correlation between Satisfaction with daylighting - Ratio of windows No correlation Very low and negative correlation (r = -0.136, p = 0.002)
Correlation between Satisfaction with daylighting - View-out Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.235, p = 0.000) Low and positive correlation (r = 0.316, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Satisfaction with daylighting - Uniformity of daylighting Low and positive correlation (r = 0.469, p = 0.000) Low and positive correlation (r = 0.473, p = 0.002)
Correlation between Satisfaction with daylighting - Sunlight exposure Very low and negative correlation (r = −0.127, p = 0.000) Very low and negative correlation (r = −0.280, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Satisfaction with daylighting - Daylight sufficiency Moderately positive correlation (r = 0.581, p = 0.000) Moderately positive correlation (r = 0.548, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Uniformity of daylighting - View-out Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.205, p = 0.000) Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.271, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Sunlight exposure - Ratio of windows Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.239, p = 0.000) Very low and positive correlation (r = 0. 115, p = 0.010)
Correlation between Sufficiency of daylighting - View-out Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.245, p = 0.000) Very low and positive correlation (r = 0. 261, p = 0.010)
Correlation between Sufficiency of daylighting - Uniformity of daylighting Low and positive correlation (r = 0.464, p = 0.000) Low and positive correlation (r = 0.422, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Satisfaction with artificial lighting- CRI Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.200, p = 0.000) Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.279, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Satisfaction with artificial lighting- Artificial lighting brightness Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.252, p = 0.000) Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.124, p = 0.006)
Correlation between Satisfaction with artificial lighting- Artificial lighting sufficiency Moderately positive correlation (r = 0.517, p = 0.000) Low and positive correlation (r = 0.463, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Satisfaction with artificial lighting- Artificial lighting uniformity Moderately positive correlation (r = 0.532, p = 0.000) Low and positive correlation (r = 0.366, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Sufficiency of artificial lighting- CRI Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.129, p = 0.000) Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.280, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Sufficiency of artificial lighting - Artificial lighting brightness Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.322, p = 0.000) Low and positive correlation (r = 0.300, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Sufficiency of artificial lighting - Artificial lighting uniformity Low and positive correlation (r = 0.379, p = 0.000) Low and positive correlation (r = 0.309, p = 0.000)
Correlation between Artificial lighting brightness - CRI Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.152, p = 0.000) Low and positive correlation (r = 0.269, p = 0.002)
Correlation between Artificial lighting uniformity - CRI Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.195, p = 0.000) Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.137, p = 0.002)
Correlation between Artificial lighting brightness - Number of hours turning on lighting Very low and negative correlation (r = -0.121, p = 0.000) No correlation
Correlation between Artificial lighting brightness - Artificial lighting uniformity Very low and positive correlation (r = 0.288, p = 0.000) Low and positive correlation (r = 0.292, p = 0.000)

Also, detailed answers were gathered from open-ended questions and in-depth interviews about residential lighting conditions such as removing the shading device and augmenting the characteristics of artificial lighting were the mostly done adjustments during the COVID-19 pandemic. Also, the most prominent theme among the lighting conditions is visual comfort according to the in-depth interview responses. A limitation of this study is that all in-depth interviews in Poland, Turkey, Sweden and the U.K. were conducted in English. All the participants have a good command of the English language but yet there may be some limitations during the interviews.

With our three-step research, we focused on end-user evaluations and self-solutions regrading residential lighting. We hope that this can be informative both for interior architects, lighting designers, environmental psychologists as well as residents who need support. Undoubtedly, the time of COVID-19 pandemic has brought different perspectives to all of us, and we hope that we have gained new perspectives for our audience through our study.

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Rengin Aslanoğlu: Writing – original draft, Visualization, Validation, Methodology, Investigation, Formal analysis, Data curation, Conceptualization. Jan K. Kazak: Writing – review & editing, Resources, Methodology, Investigation, Conceptualization. Sepideh Yekanialibeiglou: Writing – review & editing, Methodology, Conceptualization. Piotr Pracki: Writing – review & editing, Methodology, Conceptualization. Begüm Ulusoy: Writing – review & editing, Methodology, Investigation, Conceptualization.

Declaration of competing interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgement

Ethical approvals received from institutional review board of İhsan Doğramacı Bilkent University (No: 2022_04_29_02) and University of Lincoln (No: UoL2022_3521).

Appendix A. Correlation table for the summer-term results related with daylighting (the level of significance was defined as for * p < 0.01 and **p < 0.001)

Variable Number of hours of direct sunlight Daylight sufficiency Daylight uniformity Daylight satisfaction View-out Ratio of windows
Number of hours of direct sunlight Pearson's r –
p-value –
Daylight sufficiency Pearson's r −0.105 –
p-value 0.019 –
Daylight uniformity Pearson's r −0.077 0.464** –
p-value 0.084 <.001 –
Daylight satisfaction Pearson's r −0.127* 0.581** 0.469** –
p-value 0.005 <.001 <.001 –
View-out Pearson's r −0.009 0.245** 0.205** 0.235** –
p-value 0.838 <.001 <.001 <.001 –
Ratio of windows Pearson's r 0.239** −0.007 0.089 −0.023 0.057 –
p-value <.001 0.884 0.046 0.611 0.202 –

*p < 0.01, **p < 0.001.

Appendix B. Summative table for the results in comparison with winter-term related with the usage of shading devices in percentages

Poland
Turkey
Sweden
U.K.
Overall (All four countries)
Winter/Summer Winter/Summer Winter/Summer Winter/Summer Winter/Summer
All drawn 5.6%/8.8% 17.6%/25.6% 12.8%/14.4% 11.2%/12.8% 11.8%/15.4%
Usually drawn more than a half 4.8%/11.2% 23.2%/28.8% 5.6%/20% 18.4%/23.3% 13%/20.8%
Usually drawn a half 8%/16% 12%/3.2% 11.2%/20.8% 16.8%/22.4% 12%/15.6%
Usually drawn less than a half 9.6%/17.6% 10.4%/11.2% 14.4%/21.6% 13.6%/8% 12%/14.6%
Usually not drawn 69.6%/32.8% 35.2%/28% 40.8%/14.4% 34.4%/26.4% 45%/25.4%
Not applicable- No shading device 2.4%/13.6% 1.6%/3.2% 15.2%/8.8% 5.6%/7.2% 6.2%/8.2%

Appendix C. Correlation table for the summer-term results related with artificial lighting (the level of significance was defined as for * p < 0.01 and **p < 0.001)

Variable Hours in a summer day you turn on the artificial lighting Brightness Artificial lighting sufficiency Artificial lighting uniformity Artificial lighting satisfaction CRI
Hours in a summer day you turn on the artificial lighting Pearson's r –
p-value –
Brightness Pearson's r −0.121* –
p-value 0.007 –
Artificial lighting sufficiency Pearson's r −0.060 0.322** –
p-value 0.177 <.001 –
Artificial lighting uniformity Pearson's r −0.034 0.288** 0.379** –
p-value 0.451 <.001 <.001 –
Artificial lighting satisfaction Pearson's r 0.023 0.252** 0.517** 0.532** –
p-value 0.611 <.001 <.001 <.001 –
CRI Pearson's r 0.062 0.152** 0.129* 0.195** 0.200** –
p-value 0.166 <.001 0.004 <.001 <.001 –

*p < 0.01, **p < 0.001.

Appendix D. Confirmatory factor analysis-hierarchical model factors of daylight (coefficient is significant at the p < 0.05 level)

Model Fit- Daylight
Model Χ2 df p
Baseline model 2138.864 15
Factor model 41.294 9 <.001
Fit indices
Index Value
Comparative Fit Index (CFI) 0.985

Image 1

Appendix E. Confirmatory factor analysis-hierarchical model factors of artificial light (coefficient is significant at the p < 0.05 level)

Model Fit- Artificial Lighting
Model Χ2 df p
Baseline model 435.736 10
Factor model 14.702 1 <.001
Fit indices
Index Value
Comparative Fit Index (CFI) 0.968

Image 2

Data availability

Data will be made available on request.

References

  • 1.Awada M., Becerik-Gerber B., Hoque S., O'Neill Z., Pedrielli G., Wen J., Wu T. Ten questions concerning occupant health in buildings during normal operations and extreme events including the COVID-19 pandemic. Build. Environ. 2021;188 doi: 10.1016/j.buildenv.2020.107480. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 2.Klepeis N.E., Nelson W.C., Ott W.R., Robinson J.P., Tsang A.M., Switzer P., Behar J.V., Hern S.C., Engelmann W.H. The National Human Activity Pattern Survey (NHAPS): a resource for assessing exposure to environmental pollutants. J. Expo. Sci. Environ. Epidemiol. 2001;11(3):231–252. doi: 10.1038/sj.jea.7500165. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 3.Amorim C.N.D., Vasquez N.G., Matusiak B., Kanno J., Sokol N., Martyniuk-Peczek J., Sibilio S., Koga Y., Ciampi G., Waczynska M. Lighting conditions in home office and occupant's perception: an international study. Energy Build. 2022;261 [Google Scholar]
  • 4.Vischer J.C. The effects of the physical environment on job performance: towards a theoretical model of workspace stress. Stress Health: J. Int. Soc. Investig. Stress. 2007;23(3):175–184. [Google Scholar]
  • 5.Elzeyadi I. Proceedings of the Solar Conference. AMERICAN SOLAR ENERGY SOCIETY; AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS; 2002, June. Designing for Indoor Comfort: a systemic model for assessing occupant comfort in sustainable office buildings; pp. 485–498. [Google Scholar]
  • 6.Barrett P., Davies F., Zhang Y., Barrett L. The holistic impact of classroom spaces on learning in specific subjects. Environ. Behav. 2017;49(4):425–451. doi: 10.1177/0013916516648735. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 7.Soltaninejad M., Babaei-Pouya A., Poursadeqiyan M., Feiz Arefi M. Ergonomics factors influencing school education during the COVID-19 pandemic: a literature review. Work. 2021;68(1):69–75. doi: 10.3233/WOR-203355. https://www.forbes.com/uk/advisor/energy/cost-of-living-crisis/ URL. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 8.Deme Belafi Z., Hong T., Reith A. A critical review on questionnaire surveys in the field of energy-related occupant behaviour. Energy Effic. 2018;11(8):2157–2177. [Google Scholar]
  • 9.Kahaki Z.R., Jahangri H., Smith A.P., Kazemi R. Subjective and objective survey of office lighting: effects on alertness, comfort, satisfaction, and safety. Med. Lav. 2022;113(3) doi: 10.23749/mdl.v113i3.12371. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 10.Durak A., Olguntürk N.C., Yener C., Güvenç D., Gürçınar Y. Impact of lighting arrangements and illuminances on different impressions of a room. Build. Environ. 2007;42(10):3476–3482. [Google Scholar]
  • 11.Vimalanathan K., Ramesh Babu T. The effect of indoor office environment on the work performance, health and well-being of office workers. J. environ. health sci.eng. 2014;12(1):1–8. doi: 10.1186/s40201-014-0113-7. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 12.Motamedzadeh M., Golmohammadi R., Kazemi R., Heidarimoghadam R. The effect of blue-enriched white light on cognitive performances and sleepiness of night-shift workers: a field study. Physiol. Behav. 2017;177:208–214. doi: 10.1016/j.physbeh.2017.05.008. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 13.Cvetković D., Nešović A., Terzić I. Impact of people's behavior on the energy sustainability of the residential sector in emergency situations caused by COVID-19. Energy Build. 2021;230 doi: 10.1016/j.enbuild.2020.110532. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 14.Aslanoğlu R., Kazak J.K., Yekanialibeiglou S., Pracki P., Ulusoy B. An international survey on residential lighting: analysis of winter-term results. Build. Environ. 2021;206 doi: 10.1016/j.buildenv.2022.109972. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 15.Moadab N.H., Olsson T., Fischl G., Aries M. Smart versus conventional lighting in apartments-Electric lighting energy consumption simulation for three different households. Energy Build. 2021;244 [Google Scholar]
  • 16.Altomonte S., Allen J., Bluyssen P.M., Brager G., Heschong L., Loder A., Schiavon S., Veitch J.A., Wang L., Wargocki P. vol. 180. Building and Environment; 2020. (Ten Questions Concerning Well-Being in the Built Environment). [Google Scholar]
  • 17.Aslanoğlu R., Pracki P., Kazak J.K., Ulusoy B., Yekanialibeiglou S. Short-term analysis of residential lighting: a pilot study. Build. Environ. 2021;196 doi: 10.1016/j.buildenv.2022.109972. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 18.Patton M.Q. SAGE Publications, inc; 1990. Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods. [Google Scholar]
  • 19.Fisher R.A. Breakthroughs in Statistics. Springer; New York, NY: 1992. Statistical methods for research workers; pp. 66–70. [Google Scholar]
  • 20.Kwon M., Remøy H., van den Dobbelsteen A., Knaack U. Personal control and environmental user satisfaction in office buildings: results of case studies in The Netherlands. Build. Environ. 2019;149:428–435. [Google Scholar]
  • 21.Ghisi E., Tinker J.A. An ideal window area concept for energy efficient integration of daylight and artificial light in buildings. Build. Environ. 2005;40(1):51–61. [Google Scholar]
  • 22.Lindsay C.T.R., Littlefair P.J. BRE Garston Library; Watford, UK: 1992. Occupant Use of Venetian Blinds in Offices, (Building Research Establishment, Contract PD233/92. [Google Scholar]
  • 23.SCB . 2019. Completed Dwellings and Number of Rooms Including Kitchen in Newly Constructed Buildings by Region and Type of Building, Year 1975–2018. Örebro (Sweden): Statistics Sweden.https://www.statistikdatabasen.scb.se/pxweb/en/ssd/START__BO__BO0101__BO0101A/LghReHustypAr [Google Scholar]
  • 24.Bournas I. Association between perceived daylit area and self-reported frequency of electric lighting use in multi-dwelling buildings. Leukos. 2022;18(1):83–102. [Google Scholar]
  • 25.Foster M., Oreszczyn T. Occupant control of passive systems: the use of Venetian blinds. Build. Environ. 2001;36:149–155. [Google Scholar]
  • 26.Yekanialibeiglou S., Demirkan H., Denti L. Enhancing creativity in activity‐based offices: a critical incident study of knowledge workers. Creativ. Innovat. Manag. 2021;30(4):763–782. [Google Scholar]
  • 27.European Standards. CSN EN 12665. Light and lighting - Basic terms and criteria for specifying lighting requirements. (2018). https://www.en-standard.eu/csn-en-12665-light-and-lighting-basic-terms-and-criteria-for-specifying-lighting-requirements/. (Accessed 16 September 2022).
  • 28.URL [accessed 10.10.2022]. https://www.forbes.com/uk/advisor/energy/cost-of-living-crisis/.

Associated Data

This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.

Data Availability Statement

Data will be made available on request.


Articles from Building and Environment are provided here courtesy of Elsevier

RESOURCES