Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 14;481(2):239–250. doi: 10.1097/CORR.0000000000002394

Table 1.

Studies included in final analysis

Article Study design Country Data source Deprivation metric Procedure Sample size, n Gender,
women
MINORS scorea
Clement et al. [11] Prospective United Kingdom Hospital-specific Carstairs Score THA 1312 N/A 14
Clement et al. [10] Prospective United Kingdom Hospital-specific Scottish Index of Multiple
Deprivation
TKA 996 56.40% 14
Diaz et al. [14] Retrospective United States Medicare provider analysis and review and CDC Social Vulnerability Index dataset CDC/ATSDR Social
Vulnerability Index
Both 70,840 61.60% 12
Dixon et al. [15] Retrospective United Kingdom Hospital Episode Statistics of England Townsend Index of Deprivation Both N/A 12
Dixon et al. [16] Retrospective United Kingdom Hospital Episode Statistics of England English Index of Multiple Deprivation Both 83,871 N/A 12
Edwards et al. [19] Retrospective United Kingdom National Joint Registry for England, Wales, Northern Ireland, and the Isle of Man; National Health Service England Patient Reported Outcome Measures; and Hospital Episode Statistics of England English Index of Multiple Deprivation TKA 66,769 56.50% 14
Harcombe et al. [24] Retrospective New Zealand New Zealand Ministry of Health’s National Minimum Dataset New Zealand Deprivation Index TKA 62,907 54.17% 12
Hartnett et al. [25] Retrospective United States New York Statewide Planning and Research Cooperative System (SPARCS) database Social Deprivation Index THA 142,681 58.60% 12
Holbert el al. [27] Retrospective United States Administrative database of 16 surgeons CDC/ATSDR Social
Vulnerability Index
Both 11,451 57.60% 12
Jenkins et al. [29] Retrospective United Kingdom Regional arthroplasty database Scottish Index of Multiple
Deprivation
THA 1620 36.7% 12
Judge et al. [31] Retrospective United Kingdom Hospital Episode Statistics of England English Index of Multiple Deprivation Both N/A 12
Judge et al. [32] Cross-sectional United Kingdom Hospital Episode Statistics of England English Index of Multiple Deprivation Both N/A 14
Khlopas et al. [36] Retrospective United States Hospital-specific Area Deprivation Index TKA 3928 60.50% 14
Mehta et al. [44] Retrospective United States Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council Area Deprivation Index THA 84,931 55% 12
Michel et al. [46] Cross-sectional France French hospital national database French Version of the European Deprivation Index TKA 77,597 62.80% 12
Murray et al. [49] Retrospective United Kingdom Hospital-specific (multicenter) Townsend Index of Deprivation TKA 2506 N/A 14
Neuburger et al. [50] Retrospective United Kingdom Patient-reported outcome measures program of England English Index of Multiple Deprivation Both 121,983 57.90% 12
Rahman et al. [53] Cross-sectional United States Maryland Health Services Cost Review Commission datasets Area Deprivation Index THA 21,475 N/A 12
Shaw et al. [56] Retrospective United States Michigan Arthroplasty Registry Collaborative Quality Initiative (MARCQ) Area Deprivation Index TKA 2655 N/A 12
a

MINORS scores range from 0 to 24 for comparative studies and 0 to 16 for noncomparative studies, with higher scores corresponding to lower bias.