Table 5.
Study | Key findings | Factors controlled for |
Clement et al. [11] | Lower improvements in Oxford hip scores at 1 year associated with more-deprived areas as measured by the Carstairs Score | Age, comorbidity burden, baseline PROMs, LOS |
Clement et al. [10] | Social deprivation, as measured by the SMID, was not associated with 1-year Oxford knee or SF-12 scores | Age, gender, comorbidity burden, baseline PROMs |
Jenkins et al. [29] | Patients with the most severe levels of social deprivation who underwent THA had lower baseline, 6-month, and 18-month HHS and SF-36 physical and mental scores | Age, gender |
Edwards et al. [19] | Greater area deprivation was associated with lower improvements in Oxford knee scores at 6 months | Age, gender, living arrangements, symptom duration, comorbidity burden, baseline PROMs |
Neuburger et al. [50] | Higher postoperative improvements in the Oxford hip and knee scores were seen for more socially deprived patients. Patients in the most socially deprived cohorts had an increased odds of reporting no improvement after THA and TKA | Age, gender, ethnicity, comorbidity burden, revision rate, primary diagnosis, baseline PROMs |
Murray et al. [49] | No association between deprivation (as measured by the Townsend score) and KSS or QoL scores | None listed |
LOS = length of stay; SMID = Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation; HHS = Harris hip score; KSS = Knee Society score; QoL = quality of life.