Table 2.
Modality | Strengths | Weaknesses | Current status | Leading developer(s) | Best applications |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gene/Base/Prime Editing |
High specificity Durable/permanent changes Can eliminate pathogenic gene expression and restore/augment expression |
Off-target effects (incl DSBs) Limited options for delivery Redosability not possible at this time |
1st gen approaches in POC clinical trials 2nd gen approaches in preclinical or early clinical dev |
Editas Medicines CRISPR Therapeutics Intellia Therapeutics Beam Therapeutics Prime Medicines |
Monogenic diseases with LOF mutations Oncology (ex vivo) |
siRNA |
Targeted (rational) design Redosable |
Only reduces gene Expression Effect is short-lived Knockdown may be incomplete Off-target effects |
5 Approved products (US) Many additional efficacy studies in progress |
Alnylam Dicerna (Novo Nordisk) Arrowhead Pharmaceuticals |
Liver/metabolic disease Infectious disease Rare disease with pathogenic overexpression |
ASOs | Multiple MOAs |
Less stable than siRNA Durability challenges Low potency Off-target effects |
Multiple approved products (US) |
lonis Pharmaceuticals Sarepta Therapeutics |
Diseases caused by proteins with repeats Liver/metabolic disease Rare disease with pathogenic overexpression |
Gene (replacement) therapy | Direct, precise upregulation |
Limited options for delivery Redosability not possible at this time |
2 approved products (US) Many additional pivotal studies in progress |
Spark Therapeutics (Roche) AveXis (Novartis) BioMarin Pharmaceuticals Sangamo Therapeutics |
Monogenic loss of function |
Cell therapy | Clear connection to disease (known cell type, known modification) | Need appropriate cell type | Multiple approved products but limited to oncology |
Novartis Gilead Sciences |
Oncology (CAR-expressing cells) |
Protein degraders |
High tissue selectivity Multiple routes of delivery Well-understood chemistry and manufacturing |
Only downregulation/protein reduction Potential for off-target effects |
Early to mid-stage clinical development POC is emerging |
Arvinas Monte Rosa Therapeutics |
Oncology Neuroscience Immunology |
Condensates |
Differentiated MOA Novel targets |
Emerging | Preclinical |
Dewpoint Therapeutics Faze Medicines |
Oncology Neuroscience/neuro-degeneration |