Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 12;35:100811. doi: 10.1016/j.srhc.2023.100811

Table 3.

Guideline’s AGREE II scores.

Guidelines Domain 1. Scope and purposes Domain 2. Stakeholder involvement Domain 3. Rigor of development Domain 4. Clarity of the presentation Domain 5. Applicability Domain 6. Editorial independence Overall Use of the Guidelines Comments for the recommendation potential implementation in primary care in LMICs
Afshar, Silverman et al. [29] 72 64 29 47 44 92 42 Yes, with modification Recommendations in this guideline are aimed primarily for maternal foetal medicine specialists at the hospital, and not primarily in primary care. Only some of the recommendations from this paper can be adopted to primary care practice, such as on the triage, and maintaining routine ANC. Other recommendation needs further considerations due to lack of facilities and patients’ literacy level for telemedicine, and level of competence compared to specialists, such as prescription for ill pregnant women.
CDC [20] Maternal, neonatal and child service 72 47 48 97 58 50 67 Yes This guideline is succinct, and clear, most of the recommendations potentially be adopted to Indonesian context.
CDC [18] Care for Breastfeeding people interim guidance 86 58 50 89 56 58 75 Yes Most of the recommendations in the guideline can be implemented in Indonesian primary care.
CDC [19] Considerations for Inpatient Obstetric - Healthcare Settings 86 69 35 89 63 67 67 Yes, with modification The guidelines aimed for patient management in inpatient obstetric settings (hospital). There are inpatient services for women in primary care in Indonesia, however, with obvious limited facilities compared to hospitals.
Chawla, Chirla et al. [27] 92 86 76 89 71 85 92 Yes This article covers consensus recommendations from Federation of Obstetric and Gynaecological Societies of India (FOGSI), National Neonatology Forum of India (NNF), and Indian Academy of Pediatrics (IAP). However, the recommendations are potential for their adoption in Indonesian primary care due to facility similarities.
España [24] 18 17 10 16 13 8 5 Yes, with modification This guideline provides recommendations for management of pregnant women and newborns with COVID-19 mainly at hospital care level, which obviously has different facilities compared to primary care. However, some can be adopted to Indonesian primary care settings, such as: Isolation at home for eligible women with COVID-19 and maintaining routine ANC service for women during the pandemic.
Okunade, Makweet al. [30] 84 81 51 81 56 83 67 Yes The article covers recommendations on maternal care under COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria, however, most of the recommendations, that are not hospital based, are able to be adopted to the context of primary care in Indonesia.
UNFPA [22] 92 81 48 89 60 67 83 Yes Recommendations covered in this guideline can be implemented in Indonesia.
Vogel, Tendal et al. [28] 92 89 85 92 94 92 92 Yes, with modification This article provides comprehensive living guideline for management of women with COVID-19, that can be accessed through https://COVID19evidence.net.au/. Most of the recommendations can be adopted in Indonesian context, however, recommendations on prescription for severe ill pregnant women may be difficult to adopt as it usually be provided by obstetricians.
Giusti, Zambriet al. [25] 94 89 71 94 75 92 83 Yes This guidance provides a clear and practical set of recommendations that could be applied to Indonesian settings.
Vivanti, Deruelle et al. [32] 94 94 90 94 79 92 83 Yes Recommendations covered in this guideline can be implemented in Indonesia, eventhough there may be challenges on the use of telemedicine.
Vivanti, Deruelle et al. [54] 94 94 90 94 79 92 83 Yes Recommendations covered in this guideline can be implemented in Indonesia.
Homer, Roach et al. [33] 94 94 94 100 79 92 100 Yes, with modification The guideline is well developed guidance made by The National COVID-19 Clinical Evidence Taskforce (Australia), covering a clear and succinct set of recommendations that can be adopted to Indonesian setting, except for some antiviral drugs that are not readily available in the country. There is also a living guidelines approach that can be accessed anytime.
Maxwell, McGeeret al. [31] 94 78 94 94 83 83 83 Yes, with modification This guideline provides recommendations for management of pregnant women during the Coronavirus (SARS-COV) 1 outbreak at hospital care level, however the some of the recommendations, such as isolation requirement and triage could be adopted in the Indonesian primary care settings during this COVID-19 pandemic.