System |
Based on |
Classification |
Drawback |
Schatzker’s (1971) et al. [6] |
Fracture position and location in relation to the attachment of the accessory ligaments |
Low fracture either at the level or below the level of the attachment of the accessory ligaments |
1. Diversity of terminologies surrounding the location of the fracture 2. Some lack of internal fracture morphology and type of fracture 3. Discrepancies regarding fracture stability, comminution and displacement which ultimately affect management recommendation 4. Often no distinct anatomic borders defined between fracture types |
High fracture on one or both sides, above the attachment of the accessory ligaments |
Anderson and D’Alonzo’s (1974) et al. [8] |
Fracture position and location |
Type I oblique fracture at the tip of the odontoid process |
Type II at the base of the dens and the junction with the body |
Type III at the junction of the dens with the anterior portion of the axial body extending into the body and lateral masses of C2 |
Althoff’s (1979) et al. [7] |
Fracture position and location |
Type A above the neck |
Type B through the neck including superior C2 body |
Type C includes the medial part of one C2 superior articulating process |
Type D includes fractures through the body of C2, including the medial part of both superior articulating processes |
Hadley’s (1988) et al. [10] |
Subclassification of Anderson and D’Alonzo’s |
Type I and type III the same as Anderson and D’Alonzo’s |
Type IIA additional bone fragment at the dens fracture site |
Grauer’s (2005) et al. [9] |
Subclassification of Anderson and D’Alonzo’s |
Type I and type III same as Anderson and D’Alonzo’s |
Type IIA not displaced from their site of origin |
Type IIB displaced and/or extend transversely from anterior superior to posterior inferior |
Type IIC comminuted and/or extend from anterior inferior to posterior superior |
Roy-Camille’s (1979) et al. [11] |
The direction of the fracture line and the amount of displacement |
Type I obliquely slanted from posterior to anterior displacing the odontoid process anteriorly |
1. Fails to describe fracture location 2. Did not address the relationship of fractures involving the body of C2 |
Type II oblique angle slants anterior to posterior displacing the odontoid process posteriorly |
Type II horizontal fracture with no angulation displacing the odontoid process anteriorly or posteriorly |
Current system |
Embryological development and anatomy of the odontoid process |
Type I involving the upper ¼ of the dens (zone I) |
1. Only fractures involving and related to the anatomical odontoid process |
IA non displaced |
IB displaced and/or angulated odontoid process anteriorly or posteriorly |
Type II involving the lower ¾ of the dens (zone II) |
IIA non displaced |
IIB displaced and/or angulated odontoid process anteriorly or posteriorly |