Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 8;10:rbac099. doi: 10.1093/rb/rbac099

Table 1.

Comparison of different types of devices that deliver drugs to the lungs

Advantages Limitations Characteristic Examples References
Pressurized metered dose inhaler (pMDI)
  • Portable

  • Small

  • Cost-effective

  • Rapid administration times

  • Sterility and prevention of backflow

  • Protection of the drug from light, oxygen and water

  • Patient familiarity

  • Requiring coordination between actuation of the device and inhalation of the dose by the patient

Drug suspended or dissolved in propellant (with surfactant and cosolvent)
  • Easibreathe® (beclomethasone dipropionate, salbutamol)

[20–22]
Dry powder inhaler (DPI)
  • Small

  • Portable

  • Not require coordination of inhaler actuation with inhalation

  • Deliver a relatively high dose

  • Sufficient inspiratory flow needed

  • Require a pre-inhalation dose-loading step

Drug blend in lactose, drug alone, drug/excipient particles
  • Tobi® Podhaler (tobramycin)

  • Colobreathe® (colistin)

[10, 20, 23]
Soft Mist Inhaler (SMI)
  • Portable

  • Compact

  • Multidose

  • The relatively long generation time of the aerosol cloud facilitates coordination of inhalation and actuation.

  • No propellants

  • The metered volume of 15 μl limits the dose-delivery capacity of the marketed design to drugs with the adequate solubility with respect to the required dose.

  • The administration of tiotropium via Respimat® may not be used in patients with pre-existing cardiovascular comorbidities

Aqueous solution or suspension
  • Respimat® (ipratropium bromide, olodaterol, salbutamol, tiotropium bromide)

[20]
Air jet nebulizer
  • High amount of drug wastage

  • Not all drug formulations may be appropriate

Generate aerosols from the liquid medicament using a source of compressed gas
  • Medix®

  • Pari LC Plus®

[22, 24, 25]
Ultrasonic nebulizer
  • Large volume of solution can be aerosolized in a relatively short period of time

  • Oscillation of the piezoelectric crystal results in the production of heat

Aerosol creation is based on the vibrations of a piezoelectric crystal that generate high frequency sound waves
  • Aerosonic®

  • Sonix 2000 systems®

[22, 25, 26]
Vibrating mesh nebulizer
  • Quiet

  • Portable

  • Easy to use

  • Self-contained power source

  • Particle size optimized for specific medications

  • More efficient when compared to other nebulizers

  • Expensive

  • Hard to clean

  • Medication dosage requires adjustment

  • Incompatible with viscous liquids or liquids that crystallize on drying

Use oscillation and a mesh membrane to induce droplet production through cavitation and wave formation in the liquid below the mesh
  • Pari eFlow®

[22, 27–29]