Table 2.
Reference | Crop | Soil | Factors | TRL-RLD |
---|---|---|---|---|
(Chen et al., 2020) | cotton | loamy | LEV | DECREASE |
(Anderson, 1987) | maize | silty loam | DEV YEAR | DECREASE |
(Anderson, 1988) | maize | silty loam | DEV YEAR | DECREASE |
(Fang et al., 2022) | maize | loamy | LEV YEAR DEV | DECREASE |
(Hadir et al., 2021) | sugar beet | silty loam | DEV | DECREASE |
(Barraclough et al., 1989) | winter wheat | silty clay loam | IRR DEV | DECREASE |
(Mehrabi et al., 2021) | winter wheat | PLAN IRR LEV | DECREASE | |
(Xue et al., 2014) | winter wheat | DEV LEV | DECREASE | |
(Feng et al., 2016) | maize | loamy clay, clay loam, sandy loam | SOIL YEAR LEV | VARIABLE |
(Mackay and Barber, 1986) | maize | silty loam | GEN DEV | VARIABLE |
(Peng et al., 2012) | maize | silty loam | DEV LEV YEAR | VARIABLE |
(Sharifi et al., 2005) | potato | GEN DEV | VARIABLE | |
(Nakamura et al., 2002) | sorghum | GEN DEV | VARIABLE | |
(Comfort et al., 1988) | spring wheat | silty loam, clay loam | GEN SITE LEV | VARIABLE |
(Eghball and Maranville, 1993) | maize | silty clay loam | LEV | INCREASE |
(NaNagara et al., 1976) | maize | silty loam | TILL DEV | INCREASE |
(Thom and Watkin, 1978) | maize | sandy loam | DEV LEV | INCREASE |
DECREASE (in red): diminished TRL-RLD, VARIABLE (in yellow): diverse, inconclusive or no effects on TRL-RLD, and INCREASE (in green): large TRL-RLD in case of deficient as compared to non-deficient conditions. Factors refer to the variables studied in each manuscript. LEV: several levels of N applied, DEV: several development stages investigated, YEAR: several years investigated, IRR: water treatments applied (such as irrigation and drought), PLAN: several planting methods tested, SOIL: several soil types tested, GEN: diverse genotype tested, SITE: different sites tested, TILL: several tillage practices tested. For more details refer to SI Table 1 .