Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 18;13(1):e9667. doi: 10.1002/ece3.9667

TABLE 3.

Model selection for Cormack–Jolly–Seber models for estimation of apparent survival (ϕ) and probability of encounter (p) for adult Marbled Godwits and Willets at the Kitsim wetland complex near Brooks, Alberta, 1995–2001.

Model structure Model parameters
ϕ p K −2ln(L) AICc ΔAICc w i  ≤
Marbled Godwits
con con 2 327.4 331.5 0.0 0.258
sex con 3 326.5 332.6 1.1 0.148
ponds con 3 326.8 332.9 1.4 0.125
owls con 3 327.0 333.1 1.6 0.116
sex effort 4 325.6 333.7 2.2 0.085
sex + ponds con 4 326.0 334.1 2.6 0.070
sex + owls con 4 326.1 334.2 2.7 0.066
sex × owls con 5 324.9 335.1 3.7 0.042
year con 7 321.4 335.7 4.3 0.031
sex × ponds con 5 325.6 335.8 4.3 0.029
sex + year con 8 320.5 337.0 5.5 0.017
sex year 8 321.1 337.6 6.1 0.012
sex × year sex × year 22 305.5 352.7 21.2 0.000
Willets
sex con 3 622.7 628.8 0.0 0.229
sex + ponds con 4 621.6 629.6 0.8 0.150
sex effort 4 621.6 629.7 0.9 0.149
con con 2 626.4 630.4 1.6 0.103
sex + owls con 4 622.7 630.8 2.0 0.083
ponds con 3 625.0 631.1 2.3 0.073
sex × ponds con 5 621.5 631.7 2.9 0.054
owls con 3 626.4 632.4 3.6 0.037
sex year 8 616.2 632.5 3.7 0.036
sex × owls con 5 622.5 632.6 3.8 0.034
sex + year con 8 616.3 632.6 3.8 0.034
year con 7 619.8 634.1 5.3 0.016
sex × year sex × year 22 598.2 644.6 15.8 0.000

Note: Alternative models included the effects of group (sex), time (year), annual covariates (ponds, owls), and intercept‐only constant model (con). Models that received little support are not shown (ΔAICc > 10 and w i  < 0.005), except for the global starting model ϕ(sex × year), p(sex × year).