Table 4.
Patient characteristics and outcome summary of clinical studies.
Reference | Year | Study location | Age | Gender (F:M) | Sample characteristics | Patient characteristics | Treatment | Sample number | Sample type | Expression analysed | Method | Outcome measure | P<0.05 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[75] | 1995 | Italy | 47% ≤14, 53% 15-39 | 1.04: 1 | Stage IIA-IIB, High grade | ND, NM, Op, EOS | hdMAP | 92 | PRE | ↑PGP, ATP-dependent efflux protein | IHC | Necrosis | No |
[83] | 1999 | Italy | 54% ≤14, 46% >14 | 1: 1.18 | Grade III-IV, Mixed subtype | ND, NM, Op, EOS | Post-op DOX | 37 | PRE | ↑PGP, ATP-dependent efflux protein | IHC | Relapse | Yes |
[84] | 2020 | China | 53% <18, 47% ≥18 | 1: 1.4 | Stage IIA-IIB, Mixed subtype | ND, NM, Op, EOS | hdMAP | 72 | PRE | ↓Circ-LARP4, gene regulation, miR-424 sponge | qPCR | Necrosis | Yes |
[76] | 2003 | Israel | 15-67 | Mixed | Matched | EOS | hdMAP | 6 | PRE vs R | ↑MRP1, ATP-dependent efflux protein | WB | Relapse | No |
↑RFC, MTX entry | No | ||||||||||||
11-81 | 1: 2.1 | Mixed subtype | 20 | ↑MRP1, ATP-dependent efflux protein | No | ||||||||
↑RFC, MTX entry | Yes | ||||||||||||
1: 2 | 9 | PRE | ↓RFC1, MTX entry | Necrosis | Yes | ||||||||
[74] | 2021 | Japan | <21 | 1: 2.83 | High grade, Mixed subtype | EOS | MAPi | 24 | PRE | ↑CDK4, Cell cycle regulator | qRT-PCR | Necrosis | Yes |
[85] | 2016 | Japan | Mean 15, 10-25 | 1: 1 | Osteoblastic | EOS | MAP | 8 | PRE | ↑miR-100, Post-transcriptional gene regulation | qRT-PCR | Necrosis | Yes |
↑miR-125b, Post-transcriptional gene regulation | Yes | ||||||||||||
↑miR-483-3p, Post-transcriptional gene regulation | No | ||||||||||||
↑miR-124, Post-transcriptional gene regulation | No | ||||||||||||
↑miR-127-3p, Post-transcriptional gene regulation | No | ||||||||||||
↓miR-887, Post-transcriptional gene regulation | No | ||||||||||||
Mean 14, 9-22 | 1: 1.22 | Mixed subtype | 20 | ↑miR-125b, Post-transcriptional gene regulation | Yes | ||||||||
↑miR-100, Post-transcriptional gene regulation | Yes | ||||||||||||
[28] | 2001 | China | Mean 18, 4-16 | – | Stage II-B | – | hdMAP | 45 | PRE | ↑PGP, ATP-dependent efflux protein | IHC | Necrosis | No |
POST | Yes | ||||||||||||
[86] | 2018 | China | Matched | 1: 1 | Stage matched | – | MAP | 42 | POST | ↓miR-377, Post-transcriptional gene regulation, Targets apoptosis regulator XIAP | RT-PCR | Necrosis | Yes |
[77] | 2009 | Iran | 20% ≤12, 80% 13-39 | 1: 2.33 | Stage IIB, High grade, Mixed subtype | ND, NM, Op, EOS | hdMAPi | 30 | PRE | ↑PGP, ATP-dependent efflux protein | IHC | Relapse | Yes |
15 | Necrosis | No | |||||||||||
[36] | 2008 | Italy | <40 | – | High grade | ND, NM, EOS, COS | hdMAPi | 61 | PRE | ↑DHFR, Folate metabolism | IHC | Relapse | No |
Yes | |||||||||||||
↑c-MYC, Transcription factor | Yes | ||||||||||||
Necrosis | No | ||||||||||||
↑PGP, ATP-dependent efflux protein | No | ||||||||||||
No | |||||||||||||
[78] | 1995 | Italy | – | – | Grade III-IV, Mixed subtype | NM, Op, EOS | hdMAPi | 36 | – | ↑PGP, ATP-dependent efflux protein | SQ-IF | Necrosis | No |
[79] | 2003 | Italy | 24% ≤12, 76% 13-39 | 1: 1 | High grade, Mixed subtype | ND, NM, Op, EOS | hdMAP | 149 | PRE | ↑PGP, ATP-dependent efflux protein | IHC | Relapse | Yes |
Necrosis | No | ||||||||||||
[80] | 2006 | Italy | 19% ≤12, 81% 13-39 | 1 : 1.56 | High grade, Mixed subtype | ND, NM, Op, EOS, COS | hdMAPi | 94 | PRE | ↑PGP, ATP-dependent efflux protein | IHC | Necrosis | No |
Relapse | Yes | ||||||||||||
[48] | 2021 | China | 50% ≤20, 50% >20 | 1.13: 1 | Grade I-III, Mixed subtype | – | MAP | 68 | POST | ↑ABCG2, ATP-dependent efflux protein | IHC | Necrosis | Yes |
[26] | 1997 | Japan | Mean 16.2, 5-30 | 1: 1.5 | Stage IIA-III, Grade III-IV, Mixed subtype | EOS | hdMAPi | 54 | PRE | ↑MT, Zinc binding protein | IHC | Necrosis | No |
↑GST, Glutathione transferase | No | ||||||||||||
↑HSP27, Chaperone protein | No | ||||||||||||
↑LRP, Co-receptor for Wnt pathway | No | ||||||||||||
60 | POST | ↑MT, Zinc binding protein | Yes | ||||||||||
↑GST, Glutathione transferase | Yes | ||||||||||||
↑HSP27, Chaperone protein | Yes | ||||||||||||
↑LRP, Co-receptor for Wnt pathway | Yes | ||||||||||||
[81] | 2017 | China | 66% ≤20, 44% >20 | 1: 1.71 | Stage I-IV | Op, EOS | hdMAPi | 133 | – | ↑PTN, Growth factor, Regulates PGP expression via ALK/GSK3β/β-catenin pathway | IHC | Local relapse | Yes |
Necrosis | Yes | ||||||||||||
Lung metastasis | No | ||||||||||||
[82] | 2014 | China | Mean 9.6, 7-14, Matched | 1: 1 | Stage IIA-III, Matched | Op, EOS | hdMAP | 12 | POST | ↓TWIST-1, Transcription factor | WB | Necrosis | Yes |
6-16 | 1: 1.7 | Stage IIA-III | 70 | ↑miR-33a, Post-transcriptional gene regulation, Downregulates TWIST1 | qRT-PCR | Yes | |||||||
↓TWIST-1, Transcription factor | WB | Yes | |||||||||||
[87] | 2018 | China | 70% <25, 30% ≥ 25 | 1: 1.43 | Stage I-III | Op | MAPi | 80 | – | ↑circPVT1, Gene regulation, Regulator of PGP expression | qRT-PCR | Necrosis | Yes |
Lung metastasis | Yes |
Data was extracted from clinical studies included in this review. Treatment is shown for neoadjuvant regimen unless otherwise stated. Doses of each drug and number of cycles may vary and were not recorded. Due to variability in reporting patient age is recorded as mean with range, % in each age group, matched or < or >. The common function of each resistance factor is indicated in italics with any proposed functions as listed in each study recorded after. (Pro) Prospective, (Ret) Retrospective, (ND) Newly diagnosed, (NM) Non-metastatic, (Op) Operable, (EOS) extremity OS, (COS) central OS, (PRE) Pre-treatment, (R) Relapsed, (POST) Post-treatment, (IHC) Immunohistochemistry, (SQ-IF) Semi-quantitative immunofluorescence, (WB) Western blot, (–) Not clearly stated.