Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 20;6(1):e2251856. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.51856

Table 2. Circumstances Surrounding and Scene Evidence Identified in Overdose Deaths by Buprenorphine and Other Opioid Involvement in 42 Jurisdictions From July 2019 to June 2021a.

Circumstances Overdose deaths, No. (%) [95% CI]
Buprenorphine-involved (n = 1901) Other opioid–involved (n = 75 882)b
Evidence of overdose circumstancesc
Overdosed at home 1259 (72.0) [69.8-74.1] 45 719 (65.2) [64.9-65.6]
Fatal drug use witnessed 134 (7.0) [5.9-8.3] 6632 (8.7) [8.5-8.9]
Potential bystander presentd 858 (45.1) [42.9-47.4] 35 301 (46.5) [46.2-46.9]
Naloxone administered 436 (23.1) [21.2-25.0] 16 139 (21.4) [21.1-21.7]
Documentation of no pulse at first responder arrival 1158 (62.2) [60.0-64.4] 42 005 (56.3) [55.9-56.7]
Seen in emergency department 338 (18.0) [16.3-19.8] 15 408 (20.5) [20.2-20.8]
Scene evidence
Route of drug usee,f
Injection 517 (27.2) [25.2-29.3] 18 511 (24.4) [24.1-24.7]
Smoking 186 (9.8) [8.5-11.2] 10 733 (14.1) [13.9-14.4]
Snorting 181 (9.5) [8.2-10.9] 11 521 (15.2) [14.9-15.4]
Ingestion 271 (14.3) [12.7-15.9] 11 304 (14.9) [14.6-15.2]
Otherg 53 (2.8) [2.1-3.6] 369 (0.5) [0.4-0.5]
No reported route of drug use 978 (51.4) [49.2-53.7] 36 198 (47.7) [47.4-48.1]
Evidence of drugs on scenef
Prescription drugs 560 (29.5) [27.4-31.6] 18 184 (24.0) [23.7-24.3]
Illicit drugs 540 (28.4) [26.4-30.5] 29 234 (38.5) [38.2-38.9]
Evidence of history of drug use and treatment
History of opioid use 882 (46.4) [44.1-48.7] 32 088 (42.3) [41.9-42.6]
Recent return to use of opioidsc 180 (9.5) [8.2-10.9] 5894 (7.8) [7.6-8.0]
Prior overdose in the past yearc 107 (5.6) [4.6-6.8] 4782 (6.3) [6.1-6.5]
Current treatment for substance use disordersc,f,h
Any 428 (22.5) [20.7-24.5] 4482 (5.9) [5.7-6.1]
Rehabilitation 32 (1.7) [1.2-2.4] 1488 (2.0) [1.9-2.1]
Medications for opioid use disorder 384 (20.2) [18.4-22.1] 2421 (3.2) [3.1-3.3]
Cognitive/behavioral therapy 24 (1.3) [0.8-1.9] 200 (0.3) [0.2-0.3]
Narcotics anonymous 3 (0.2) [0.03-0.5] 104 (0.1) [0.1-0.2]
Othere 20 (1.1) [0.6-1.6] 610 (0.8) [0.7-0.9]
Current treatment for painc,h 166 (8.7) [7.5-10.1] 6261 (8.3) [8.1-8.5]
Evidence of other circumstancesc
Recent release from institutional setting 131 (7.0) [5.9-8.3] 6795 (9.1) [8.9-9.3]
Experiencing homelessness or housing instabilityi 107 (5.7) [4.7-6.9] 5029 (6.7) [6.5-6.9]
Mental health diagnosis 584 (30.7) [28.7-32.9] 17 395 (22.9) [22.6-23.2]
Current mental health treatmentj 596 (31.4) [29.3-33.5] 10 121 (13.3) [13.1-13.6]
a

A list of jurisdictions is presented in eTable 1 in Supplement 1.

b

Includes opioid-involved overdose deaths that did not involve buprenorphine. Thus, the buprenorphine-involved and other opioid–involved categories are mutually exclusive.

c

Missing values were excluded from calculations of percentages.

d

A potential bystander is defined as a person 11 years or older who was physically nearby either during or shortly preceding a drug overdose and potentially had an opportunity to intervene or respond to the overdose. This includes persons in the same structure (eg, same room or same building but different room) as the decedent during that time. This does not include persons in different self-contained parts of larger buildings (eg, a person in a different apartment in the same apartment building).

e

Route of drug use cannot be directly linked to specific drugs if more than 1 drug was detected and more than 1 route was reported.

f

Categories are not mutually exclusive.

g

Includes transdermal, suppository, sublingual, and buccal.

h

Current treatment is defined as being treated at the time of the fatal overdose.

i

Persons experiencing homelessness were those who resided in places not designed for or ordinarily used as regular sleeping accommodations or in a supervised shelter or drop-in center designated to provide temporary living arrangements. Persons experiencing housing instability were those who lack resources to obtain or retain permanent housing and includes interrelated challenges (eg, trouble paying rent, overcrowding, moving frequently, or staying with relatives).

j

Current mental health treatment includes treatment for both mental health and substance use disorders at the time of the fatal overdose.