Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 20;23:56. doi: 10.1186/s12888-023-04530-4

Table 2.

Characteristics of included papers

Authors (year) Country Participants Study Design Quality rating Aim of study Key qualitative findings related to the  hospitalization of parents
Blegen et al. [37] Norway Mothers (n = 10) with children aged 0–18 years, admitted to a hospital unit; diagnoses included: depression, anxiety, bipolar, disorder, ADHD Semi-structured interviews, analysis with philosophical hermeneutics 40.5 To understand the experience of being cared for in psychiatric care as a patient and as a parent Parental ambivalence: Mothers’ anxiety about disclosing their inner feelings about themselves as a mother to clinicians despite wanting support in this area; a mask of silence provides protection but also causes distance and reduced opportunity for optimal care; struggle between responsibility and condemnation
Knutsson-Medin et al. [36] Sweden Adult children (n = 36): mean age of 25.8 years, range 19–38 years; 15 men, 21 women; parents had been previous psychiatric inpatients Written survey, manifest content analysis 52.5 To examine adult children’s previous experiences of contact with their parent’s psychiatric inpatient services

Children’s needs: Support and information needed from hospital staff and more contact with clinicians

Pressure: relief that the parent was being looked after

Involvement and guidance: Children were not provided with information about their parent during hospitalization

Kosman et al. [35] USA One 28-year-old mother with postpartum depression and admitted to inpatient psychiatry (not a mother-baby unit) Case study 18.5 To discuss the issues associated with postpartum depression including mother and infant safety, maternal-infant attachment, psychopharmacological options for postpartum depression, and traumatic birth experiences Parental ambivalence: Parental ambivalence about hospitalization, experiences of emotional difficulties being separated from her infant, logistical and physiological issues associated with breastfeeding and challenges of coordinating childcare during hospitalization
Maybery et al. [38] Australia 5 parents with mood disorder, 3 anxiety, 3 personality disorder, 1 psychotic (total n = 10), partners (n = 2); children (aged 6–16 years) (n = 12). Total n = 24

Focus groups, qualitative interpretive analysis

Quantitative questionnaire, between groups analysis of variance

51.5 To examine child, parent and professional perspectives of the needs of children when a parent is an inpatient and how to best meet those needs

Pressure: Older children had to care for themselves while parent was in hospital

Involvement and guidance: Families wanted information about the parent’s mental illness

Children’s needs: Facilitate opportunities to see their parents; to be recognized/identified by professionals during admission and discharge; siblings are an important source of support

O'Brien et al. [25] Australia Parents (n = 5) discharged from an inpatient facility in the last 12 months; with a child aged 0–18 years, partners (n = 2), children (n = 5) aged between 8–15 years; and grandparents (n = 1). Total n = 13 Semi-structured interviews, thematic analysis 47 To examine perspectives of children, parents and carers towards children visiting parents in inpatient units

Pressure: Family stress when making decisions about children visiting their parent in hospital and caring for children during visits

Involvement and guidance: Family involvement in admission interviews was appreciated; wanted guidance on child visitations with parents

Children’s needs: Support during visits, including advice and debrief from staff

Parental ambivalence: Parents wanting children to visit but also wanting to shield them

Skundberg-Kletthagen et al. [39] Norway Partners (n = 6), grandparents (n = 2), siblings (n = 2), children aged over 18 years (n = 12) and participants who had “other relationships” (n = 2). The parent had been admitted to a psychiatric ward with depression. Total n = 24 Semi-structured interviews, interpretive phenomenological analysis 51.5 To describe experiences of encountering a psychiatric service as a relative of an inpatient with severe depression

Pressure: Difficulty getting parents admitted; burden of care after discharge

Involvement and guidance: Families wanted more information about psychiatric services and to be included in decision making, particularly around discharge planning

Wells et al. [40] UK Fathers (n = 8) aged 27–54 years (M = 43 years), admitted in forensic inpatient care with current admissions ranging from 3 months to 9 years; having children aged 2 to 39 years Semi-structured interviews, grounded theory 46.5 To investigate men’s experience of fatherhood in forensic inpatient care Parental ambivalence: Physical absence not necessarily leading to psychological disconnection; influential factors of psychological connection (e.g., geographical location of hospital admission and financial difficulties, the child’s mother, participants’ own parents, professional support); ways and challenges of fulfilling parenting responsibilities during hospitalization
Zeighami et al. [41] Iran Children (n = 10) aged between 17–26 years, daughter in law (n = 1), grandmothers (n = 2). Parents had mood disorder, schizophrenia, obsessive disorder and had been hospitalized for an average of 13 times. Total n = 13 Semi-structured interviews, grounded theory 51 To explore the mental health needs of children at various stages of their parent’s mental illness

Pressure: Burden on children to convince parents to seek support/admission to the psychiatric unit

Children’s needs: People to be with and talk to during parent hospitalization;

Involvement and Guidance: After discharge they need guidance and education about the situation