Table 2.
Comparison of various conventional cooperative control.
Control algorithms | Advantages | Challenges | References |
---|---|---|---|
1. HIC | Tremendous force tracking features and high position flexibility. | Improper adjustments can create system instability. | Li K. et al., 2020 |
2. Navel AVIC | Dynamic contact force detection in an uncertain environment, unknown environmental stiffness, and dynamic environmental location evaluation can also be applied to slope surfaces or other complex areas. It can yield a hugely convincing solution to the contact operation. | Complex. | Duan et al., 2018 |
3. PD-based position control | Feasible, and it can provide outstanding flexibility and positional accuracy. | It only works well for linear systems, and a large time delay process is required for parameter adjustments. | Zeng et al., 2019 |
4. Radial basis function (RBF) neural network compensation control | The uncertainty part of computed torque, as well as the disturbance of rehabilitation, can be eliminated, which will optimize tracking ability. | Only the nonlinear system can be effectively trained without a time-consuming training process and dynamical model evaluation. | Yu et al., 2011; Yin et al., 2015; Tao et al., 2016 |
5. Compensation methods and reaction torque observer (ROB) | The technique can satisfy and meet the requirements of patient-cooperative control, it is easy to design, and has good accuracy. | - | Van Tran et al., 2015a,b |
6. Adaptive impedance monitoring with BP neural network | The patient can effectively participate in rehabilitation training. | - | Chen et al., 2020 |
7. Under actuated energy shaping technique | The approach can overcome this issue and yield task-invariant, trajectory-free control laws that can be suitable for the various DLAs. | Complex. | Lv and Gregg, 2017; Lv et al., 2018 |
8. Fuzzy PD position controller | It is stable and smooth, minimizes deviation, and optimizes the system's dynamic performance. | Rarely are fuzzy inference systems used directly in the control loop and sometimes low control. | Bai et al., 2017 |
9. Trajectory deformation algorithm (TDA) | TDA can promote the trajectory of rehabilitation training more naturally and smoother, enhance robot compliance, and protect the user from secondary injury. | The tracking trajectory's smoothness is significantly worse than that of the desired trajectory. | Zhou et al., 2021 |
10. Fuzzy NN | Excellent at handling uncertain information. | It cannot handle the vague the message, slow processing speed, low accuracy, and massive linear and angular velocities that lead to oscillation problems. | Bai et al., 2017 |