Table 1.
Patient 1 Ghezzi et al. (11) |
Patient 2 Ghezzi et al. (11) |
Patient 3 Yoo et al. (10) |
Patient 4 Wei et al. (12) |
Patient 5 Wei et al. (12) |
Patient 6 Wei et al. (12) |
Patient 7 Astner-Rohracher et al. (19) |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
FASTKD2 mutation | Homozygous non-sense mutation in the KIAA0971 gene p.R416X + p.R416X | Homozygous non-sense mutation in the KIAA0971 gene p.R416X+ p.R416X |
Compound heterozygous mutations p.R205X (c.613C>T) + p.L255P (c.764T>C) | Homozygous mutation at p.L270fs*11 (c.808_809insTTTCAG TTTTG) |
Homozygous mutation p.R290 (c.868C>T) | Two compound heterozygous mutations at c.1859delT/c.868C>T and p.S621Lfs*14/p.R290 |
Homozygous mutation p.[Arg358Ter]; [Arg358Ter] (c.[1072C>T]; [1072C>T]) |
Ethnics/nationality | Bedouin (Israel) sister | Bedouin (Israel) Brother | Korean | Chinese | Chinese | Chinese | Austrian |
Consanguinity | Yes (first degree cousins) | Yes (first degree cousins) | No | No | Yes | No | No |
Sex | Female | Male | Male | Female | Female | Female | Male |
Age at disease onset | 7 months | 1 year | 15 years | 6 months | 22 months | 1 year | 14 years |
First symptom | Fever associated seizure | Fever associated subacute neurological deterioration (Muscle hypotonia, extrapyramidal movements left>right) | Generalized tonic clonic seizure | Axial hypotonia + dyskinesia | Seizure | Seizure | Focal to bilateral tonic clonic seizure -> refractory SE (NORSE) |
Developmental delay | Delayed development from age 7 months, at age 14 y: follows simple commands, 20 words vocabulary, can sit, is not able to walk | Deterioration of neurological development from age 1 year, at 4 years bed-ridden with neither communication nor any voluntary activity. |
No | Delayed motor development, able to sit at the age of 9 months, walks at the age of 3 | Yes, no further information given | Delayed development from the beginning, unable to sit until 7 months and walk until 22 months of age | No |
Status epilepticus (SE) | No | Repeated SE | 1st SE at age 18 y, 2nd SE at age 26 y | No | No epilepsy | No | Refractory SE at age 14 y and age 21 y |
Clinical manifestations | Developmental delay, Myoclonic and gelastic seizures, optic atrophy, spastic left-sided hemiparesis | Developmental delay, refractory seizures with repeated SE, optic atrophy, muscle hypotonia, extrapyramidal symptoms | Stroke-like episode with visual field deficit left, epilepsy, Bilateral optic atrophy | Developmental delay, axial hypotonia, dyskinesia | Dyskinesia, unconscious shaking of hands, occasional convulsions at 3 years | Nystagmus, hypotonia, slurred speech, diminished deep tendon reflexes in the lower limbs. | Refractory status epilepticus twice, drug-resistent focal epilepsy, mild psychomotor slowing, myopathy, spastic atactic gait |
Brain MRI | MRI at age 7 months: Generalized Symmetric atrophy CT at age 5y: Right hemispheric atrophy | MRI at age 1 y: Hyperintensity left nucleus caudatus, globus pallidus, and crus cerebri CT at age 2.5 y: Generalized atrophy, more pronounced on the left basal ganglia, bilateral dilatation of ventricles + basal cysternae |
Right occipital lobe infarction | MRI at age 14 months:high T2 signal intensity in bilateral globus pallidus, medulla oblongata, and mesencephalon | MRI at age 9 years:bilateral symmetrical hyperintensity in globus pallidus | MRI at age 1 year 8 months:Brain atrophy, bilateral symmetrical hyperintensity signals in globus pallidus, putamen, and caudate nucleus MRI at age 2.5 years: T2 hyperintensity bilateral basal ganglia and cerebral atrophy |
MRI at age 14 years: Diffusion restriction and FLAIR hyperintensity right temporo-occipital MRI at age 22 years: atrophy right temporo-parietal |
EEG | Bilateral epileptiform discharge left > right | Right hemispheric attenuation + triphasic waves over left hemisphere |
Slowing right hemisphere, sharp transients right parieto-occipital region | Not performed | Abnormal (not specified) | Not reported | Bilateral synchronous spike and wave with right posterior maximum |
Lactate level | Serum 2.4–3.2 mM (normal < 1.8 mM) | CSF 3.8 mM (normal < 1.8 mM), | Serum 2.2 mM (normal < 1.6 mM) | Serum 3.4 mM (normal < 2.1 mM) | Normal: 1.9 mM (normal < 2.1 mM) | Serum 6.3 (normal < 2.1 mM) | Serum 2.2 mmol/l CSF 2.2 mmol/l (normal 1.1–2.2 mmol/l) |
Abdominal sonography | Normal | Normal | Normal | Not performed, laboratory testing normal | Not reported | Not reported | Normal |
Renal function | Normal | Normal | Normal | Normal | Not reported | Not reported | Normal |
Specific therapy | Not reported | Not reported | Coenzyme Q10 | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported | Coenzyme Q10 |
Echocardiography | Normal | Normal | Normal | Not reported | Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, sinus tachycardia | Not reported | Normal |
Optic nerve | Bilateral opticatrophy | Bilateral opticatrophy | Bilateral opticatrophy | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported | Bilateral mild atrophy of temporal fibers |
Muscle biopsy | COX activity reduced to 21% of controls, other respiratory chain complexes: normal | Not performed | SDH, COX, mGT stain: normal | Not performed | Not performed | Not performed | COX, citrate synthase, respiratory chain complexes I, II, III, V: normal |
Skin fibroblasts | Normal activity of MRC | Normal activity of MRC | OCR: no decrease of basal or maximal respiration | ||||
Immortalizedlym phozytes |
Not performed | Decreased COX activity | 16s-rRNA 30% lower compared to controls; 8.5-fold higher extracellular lactate generation |
16s- rRNA 54% lower compared to controls; 4.3-fold higher extracellular lactate generation | Not performed | Not performed | |
Visual evoked potentials | Not performed | Not performed | Delayed | Not performed | Not performed | Not performed | Not performed |
COX, cytochrome C oxidase; mGT, modified Gomori trichrome; MRC, mitochondrial respiratory chain complex; NORSE, new-onset refractory status epilepticus; OCR, oxygen consumption rate; SE, status epilepticus; SDH, succinate dehydrogenase.