Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 26;18(1):e0280954. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0280954

Table 6. Association between CV and other conditions (n = 8 studies).

Publication Location Number of women Study type Exposure/outcome Selection bias Information bias Confounder bias Results
Pregnancy
Akgun 2012 [15] (abstract) Turkey 4672 retrospective cohort CV/infertility Low High High In women with CV, 32.9% women were infertile; in women without CV, 5.58% were infertile (P < .05).
Rocchetti 2011 [55] Brazil 405 cross-sectional analytical vaginal flora/group B strep colonization Low Moderate Low In women with group B strep colonization compared to not having group B strep colonization, the odds of CV was 2.717 (95% CI, 1.075–6.866).
Zidovsky 1963 [74] Czech Republic 953 retrospective cohort CV /fetal impairment Moderate Moderate High In women with CV, 18.0% (95% CI, 12.1%-33.9%) of infants were impaired/died; in women without CV 3.9% (95% CI, 2.7%-5.9%) of infants were impaired or died.
Dysplasia
Nasiell 1972 [49] Sweden 440 cross-sectional analytical CV/cervical dysplasia and cervical cancer Low Moderate High In women with invasive carcinoma, 4% had CV compared to 12% in women with carcinoma in situ; 9% in women with dysplasia; and 19% in controls. (No statistical tests were done on these figures.)
Silva 2014 [61] Brazil 3390 retrospective cohort CV/HPV and cervical intraepithelial lesions Low Moderate Moderate Prevalence of CV among women with low-grade intraepithelial lesions (LSIL) or lesions of undetermined significance that evolved to high-grade intra-epithelial lesion (HSIL) was 3.7% (15/409), compared to a prevalence of 5.8% (175/2981) in women with lesions that did not evolve into HSIL. The study indicates that statistical testing was done but did not provide this information.
Vieira-Baptista 2017 [65] (abstract) Portugal 1022 cross-sectional analytical CV/HPV infection and cervical dysplasia Low Low High In women with an abnormal Pap result compared to women with a normal Pap result, the prevalence of CV was 3.5% vs 2.6%, P = .4. In women with HR-HPV positive compared to women HR-HPV negative, the prevalence of CV was 2.7% vs 3.5%, P = 0.5. In women with a cervical biopsy with high-grade lesions compared to low-grade lesions, the prevalence of CV was 4.2% vs 1.8%, P = .3.
Other
Moghaddam 2009 [47] Iran 415 case control lactobacillus flora/vaginal candidiasis High High High In women with candidiasis, 9% had findings of CV compared to 25% in women without candidiasis (chi-squared test appears to have been used to analyze the results between the three types of flora and P reported as < .0001. However, we recalculated and P should be < .001).
Vieira-Baptista 2017 [64] (abstract) Portugal 291 case control vaginal flora/vulvodynia Low Low Moderate In women with vulvodynia compared to women without vulvodynia, the odds of CV are 4.593 (95% CI, 1.890–11.160).