Table 3.
Different algorithms in terms of performance, accuracy, true positive rate, positive predictive rate and true negative rate (%)
Healthy |
COVID-19 |
Symptomatic |
|||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Algorithms | Performance | ACC | TPR | PPV | TNR | ACC | TPR | PPV | TNR | ACC | TPR | PPV | TNR |
STFT Rnd | 63.31 | 67.56 | 63.36 | 91.96 | 81.55 | 80.19 | 62.86 | 22.54 | 81.66 | 78.86 | 63.27 | 38.34 | 81.67 |
STFT Opt. | 66.85 | 70.67 | 66.85 | 93.07 | 83.42 | 82.13 | 67.24 | 25.59 | 83.40 | 80.89 | 66.65 | 42.04 | 83.45 |
P-value | 2.35e-3 | 2.8e-4 | 8.1e-3 | 2.8e-4 | 4.0e-3 | 7.8e-4 | 4.9e-4 | 1.5e-5 | 8.1e-3 | 1.5e-4 | 6.1e-3 | 8.2e-5 | 1.3e-4 |
Wavelet Rnd | 59.41 | 64.06 | 59.28 | 90.80 | 79.99 | 77.99 | 59.55 | 19.83 | 79.55 | 76.75 | 59.93 | 34.80 | 79.78 |
Wavelet Opt. | 61.89 | 66.24 | 61.86 | 91.50 | 80.85 | 79.50 | 61.63 | 21.61 | 81.01 | 78.04 | 62.18 | 36.95 | 80.90 |
P-value | 3.42e-2 | 8.3e-3 | 1.4e-4 | 7.4e-5 | 2.2e-3 | 9.1e-4 | 3.6e-5 | 1.2e-3 | 6.0e-3 | 5.0e-5 | 6.7e-4 | 1.1e-5 | 3.7e-4 |
HHT Rnd | 59.57 | 64.21 | 59.52 | 90.77 | 79.84 | 78.19 | 60.22 | 20.13 | 79.72 | 76.71 | 59.42 | 34.66 | 79.83 |
HHT Opt. | 61.54 | 65.94 | 61.53 | 91.37 | 80.64 | 79.28 | 61.72 | 21.41 | 80.77 | 77.85 | 61.46 | 36.56 | 80.80 |
P-value | 2.21e-3 | 2.5e-4 | 1.3e-3 | 3.4e-5 | 2.2e-3 | 1.2e-4 | 2.8e-4 | 1.1e-4 | 3.9e-5 | 1.3e-5 | 2.0e-3 | 4.0e-4 | 4.3e-5 |
MFCC Rnd | 58.83 | 63.55 | 58.71 | 90.58 | 79.66 | 77.80 | 59.14 | 19.59 | 79.38 | 76.30 | 59.21 | 34.08 | 79.37 |
MFCC Opt. | 60.53 | 65.12 | 60.53 | 91.14 | 80.39 | 78.63 | 60.07 | 20.48 | 80.21 | 77.29 | 60.70 | 35.67 | 80.28 |
P-value | 4.21e-2 | 7.6e-4 | 2.8e-4 | 4.2e-2 | 2.2e-2 | 1.1e-5 | 1.3e-1 | 1.0e-4 | 4.0e-4 | 3.6e-4 | 1.0e-2 | 1.2e-4 | 8.0e-5 |