Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 27. Online ahead of print. doi: 10.1016/j.imed.2023.01.001

Table 3.

Different algorithms in terms of performance, accuracy, true positive rate, positive predictive rate and true negative rate (%)

Healthy
COVID-19
Symptomatic
Algorithms Performance ACC TPR PPV TNR ACC TPR PPV TNR ACC TPR PPV TNR
STFT Rnd 63.31 67.56 63.36 91.96 81.55 80.19 62.86 22.54 81.66 78.86 63.27 38.34 81.67
STFT Opt. 66.85 70.67 66.85 93.07 83.42 82.13 67.24 25.59 83.40 80.89 66.65 42.04 83.45
P-value 2.35e-3 2.8e-4 8.1e-3 2.8e-4 4.0e-3 7.8e-4 4.9e-4 1.5e-5 8.1e-3 1.5e-4 6.1e-3 8.2e-5 1.3e-4
Wavelet Rnd 59.41 64.06 59.28 90.80 79.99 77.99 59.55 19.83 79.55 76.75 59.93 34.80 79.78
Wavelet Opt. 61.89 66.24 61.86 91.50 80.85 79.50 61.63 21.61 81.01 78.04 62.18 36.95 80.90
P-value 3.42e-2 8.3e-3 1.4e-4 7.4e-5 2.2e-3 9.1e-4 3.6e-5 1.2e-3 6.0e-3 5.0e-5 6.7e-4 1.1e-5 3.7e-4
HHT Rnd 59.57 64.21 59.52 90.77 79.84 78.19 60.22 20.13 79.72 76.71 59.42 34.66 79.83
HHT Opt. 61.54 65.94 61.53 91.37 80.64 79.28 61.72 21.41 80.77 77.85 61.46 36.56 80.80
P-value 2.21e-3 2.5e-4 1.3e-3 3.4e-5 2.2e-3 1.2e-4 2.8e-4 1.1e-4 3.9e-5 1.3e-5 2.0e-3 4.0e-4 4.3e-5
MFCC Rnd 58.83 63.55 58.71 90.58 79.66 77.80 59.14 19.59 79.38 76.30 59.21 34.08 79.37
MFCC Opt. 60.53 65.12 60.53 91.14 80.39 78.63 60.07 20.48 80.21 77.29 60.70 35.67 80.28
P-value 4.21e-2 7.6e-4 2.8e-4 4.2e-2 2.2e-2 1.1e-5 1.3e-1 1.0e-4 4.0e-4 3.6e-4 1.0e-2 1.2e-4 8.0e-5