Date | Event | Description |
---|---|---|
27 January 2023 | New citation required but conclusions have not changed | Our conclusions remain unchanged. |
27 January 2023 | New search has been performed | Searches updated. We included 11 new trials (Abaluck 2022; Alfelali 2020; Almanza‐Reyes 2021; Ashraf 2020; Bundgaard 2021; Fretheim 2022a; Gutiérrez‐García 2022; Helsingen 2021; Swarthout 2020; Teesing 2021; Young 2021), and excluded 20 new trials (Ahmadian 2022; Chen 2022; Costa 2021; Cyril Vitug 2021; Dalakoti 2022; Egger 2022; Ferrer 2021; Gharebaghi 2020; Giuliano 2021; Karakaya 2021; Kawyannejad 2020; Lim 2022; Malaczek 2022; Meister 2022; Mo 2022; Montero‐Vilchez 2022; Munoz‐Basagoiti 2022; Sanchez Barrueco 2022; Seneviratne 2021; Sevinc Gul 2022). We identified two new ongoing trials (Brass 2021; NCT04471766), and five trials awaiting classification (Contreras 2022; Croke 2022; Delaguerre 2022; Loeb 2022; Varela 2022). |
1 April 2020 | New search has been performed | Searches updated. In this 2020 update we only searched for RCTs and cluster‐RCTs. We included 44 new trials (Aelami 2015; Aiello 2012; Alzaher 2018; Arbogast 2016; Azor‐Martinez 2016; Azor‐Martinez 2018; Ban 2015; Barasheed 2014; Biswas 2019; Canini 2010; Chard 2019; Correa 2012; DiVita 2011; Feldman 2016; Goodall 2014; Hartinger 2016; Hubner 2010; Huda 2012; Ibfelt 2015; Ide 2014; Ide 2016; Little 2015; MacIntyre 2011; MacIntyre 2013; MacIntyre 2015; MacIntyre 2016; McConeghy 2017; Millar 2016; Miyaki 2011; Najnin 2019; Nicholson 2014; Pandejpong 2012; Priest 2014; Radonovich 2019; Ram 2015; Savolainen‐Kopra 2012; Simmerman 2011; Stebbins 2011; Suess 2012; Talaat 2011; Temime 2018; Turner 2012; Yeung 2011; Zomer 2015). We excluded 12 new trials (Azor‐Martinez 2014; Bowen 2007; Chami 2012; Denbak 2018; Lennell 2008; Nandrup‐Bus 2009; Patel 2012; Rosen 2006; Slayton 2016; Stedman‐Smith 2015; Uhari 1999; Vessey 2007). We identified 5 new ongoing trials (NCT03454009; NCT04267952; NCT04296643; NCT04337541; Wang 2015) one of which – NCT04337541 ‐ published as this review was going to press. We focused on RCTs and cluster‐RCTs only and removed observational studies from this update. |
1 April 2020 | New citation required and conclusions have changed | There is now sufficient randomised controlled trial (RCT) evidence to show that hand hygiene is likely to provide a modest benefit. Uncertainty remains for the other interventions. Further RCT evidence is needed. |
22 October 2010 | New citation required but conclusions have not changed | We updated the review again at the behest of the World Health Organization (WHO). External sources of support amended. External support from the WHO. The WHO interim guidelines document on 'Infection Prevention and Control of Epidemic and Pandemic Prone Acute Respiratory Diseases in Health Care' was published in 2007 to provide infection control guidance to help prevent the transmission of acute respiratory diseases in health care. The update of these guidelines will be evidence‐based, and an update of this review was requested to assist in informing the evidence base for the revision of the WHO guidelines. Dr John Conly, Dr Mark Jones, and Sarah Thorning joined the review team. |
22 October 2010 | New search has been performed | Searches conducted. We included 7 new trials: 4 randomised controlled trials and 3 non‐randomised comparative studies. We excluded 36 new trials. |
7 May 2009 | New search has been performed | For the 2009 update, we included 3 cluster‐randomised controlled trials, Cowling 2009; MacIntyre 2009; Sandora 2008, and 1 individual randomised controlled trial (Satomura 2005, with its linked publication Kitamura 2007). We also included 1 retrospective cohort study (Foo 2006), 1 case‐control study (Yu 2007), and 2 prospective cohort studies (Wang 2007; Broderick 2008). The content and conclusions of the 2007 review changed little, but the additional 8 studies add more information and certainty. Our meta‐analysis remains unchanged as there were no new studies for pooling. |
30 April 2009 | New citation required but conclusions have not changed | New author joined the review team. |
8 July 2008 | Amended | Converted to new review format. |
20 August 2007 | Amended | Review first published Issue 4, 2007. |