Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 16;25:e41939. doi: 10.2196/41939

Table 3.

Participant engagement and retention strategies.

Intervention type, reference Participants, n Intervention Dropouta, n (%) Reported reasons to drop out Financial or material support Access to the technology


Duration Follow-up



Smartphone

Thompson et al [42], 2020 60 28 days N/Ab 20 (33) 16 discharged; 1 incarcerated; 1 hospitalized; 1 self-withdrew; 1 relocated US $25 to US $50 gift cards+smartphone or US $100 gift card Researchers provided the smartphones

Schueller et al [19], 2019 35 1 month N/A 15 (43) Unclearc Phone service and data Researchers provided the smartphones

Glover et al [40], 2019 100 6 months N/A 81 (81) Unclear Smartphone+US $5 gift card Researchers provided the smartphones

Sheoran et al [41], 2016 6 One time N/A N/A N/A US $100 gift card Researchers provided the smartphones. A total of 83% (5/6) participants already owned a smartphone

Chao et al [36], 2017 24 1 month N/A Unclear Unclear Unclear Researchers provided the smartphones

Karnik et al [46], 2017 20 Unclear Unclear N/A N/A Unclear Researchers provided the smartphones

Leonard et al [43], 2018 49 Variable (6-8 months) N/A 9 (18) 4 discharged; 4 technology problem; 1 did not use the ICTd US $90 stipend Researchers provided the smartphones

Linnemayr et al [38], 2021e 77 6 weeks 3 months 11 (14) Unclear US $65 Participants’ phone

Tucker et al [39], 2020e 28f 1 week N/A 2 (20)f Unclear Unclear Participants’ phone
Other ICTs

Medalia et al [45], 2017 91 26 weeks 1 month 69 (76) Baseline to week 26: 25 loss of interest; 14 moved; 17 scheduling conflict; 7 discharged; 4 withdrawn; 2 legal issues Reimbursed for public transportation cost Researchers provided the computers

Chavez et al [44], 2020 30 One time 1-3 days 1 (3) 1 did not return US $50 Researchers provided the headset

Archie et al [47], 2018 55 Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear

aPercentage of dropouts: participants who were assessed at baseline and were lost to follow-up.

bN/A: not applicable.

cUnclear: authors did not provide sufficient or any information.

dICT: information and communication technology.

eLinnemayr et al [38] and Tucker et al [39] reported the same population.

fThe sample that was analyzed in Tucker et al [39] was included and analyzed in Linnemayr et al [38]. Dropout percentage was calculated from the 10 participants who were included in the intervention, the rest (18 participants) participated in focus groups and were not counted for dropout proportions.