Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 1;130:108–125. doi: 10.1016/j.ijid.2023.01.036

Table 1.

Systematic review.

Author, year
Country
Study design Herpesvirus Specimen (detection method) for herpesvirus COVID-19 Cases
Non-COVID-19 Controls
n n Herpesvirus +Casesc Age
Gendera
Characteristics SARS-CoV-2 infection
(Outcomeb)
Clinical manifestation of herpesvirus infection Durationc Anti-herpesvirus therapy n n Herpesvirus +
Controls
Age
Gendera
Characteristics
Lehner, 2020
Austria
Case-control EBV
CMV
Blood
(RT-PCR)
18 14/18
3/18
60.5 (52.0-64.5)
med (25th-75th percentiles)
NR
COVID-19 patients treated in ICU due to respiratory failure and
required invasive ventilation
Active
(NR)
Biochemical abnormalities that resemble hepatitis and pancreatitis
typically caused by herpesviruses like EBV or CMV. A subgroup
of COVID-19 patients exhibit a hyperinflammatory
pattern similar to sHLH
NR NR 18 8/18
1/18
58.8 (47.8-72.3)
med (25th-75th percentiles)
NR
Consecutive invasively ventilated ICU patients
without COVID-19
Majtanova, 2021
Slovakia
Case-control HSV1 NR
(RT-PCR)
18 18/18 18-29 years - 3 (17%)
30-39 years - 4 (22%)
40-49 years - 4 (22%)
≥ 50 years - 7 (39%)
11 (61%) vs. 7 (39%)
Herpes simplex keratitis COVID-19 patients Active
(NR)
Keratitis NR NR 26 26/26 18-29 years - 4 (15.4%)
30-39 years - 5 (19.2%)
40-49 years - 7 (26.9%)
≥ 50 years - 10 (38.5%)
16 (61.5%) vs. 10 (38.5%)
Herpes simplex keratitis patients without COVID-19
Naendrup, 2021
Germany
Case-control EBV
CMV
Whole blood
(RT-PCR)
*reactivation defined as
DNA levels higher than 1000IU/mL
117
(reactivation was performed in 55 cases)
19/55
10/55
60 (16-80) EBV reactivation
51 (16-80) CMV reactivation
median (min-max)
17 (89.5%) vs. 2 (10.5%) EBV reactivation
9 (90%) vs. 1 (10%) CMV reactivation
Severe COVID-19 patients treated in ICU without clinical improvement,
having persisting fever >2 days and/or persisting laboratory signs
of hyperinflammation in the absence of alternative explanations
such as pathogens in bronchoalveolar lavages, blood, or urine cultures.
Active
(37% with vs. 50% without EBV reactivation survived ICU, 29% with vs. 42% without rituximab treatment with EBV reactivation survived ICU;
55% with vs. 46% without CMV reactivation survived ICU, 86% with vs. 0% without Ganciclovir treatment with CMV reactivation survived ICU)
NR NR Rituximab for EBV reactivation and Ganciclovir for CMV reactivation 126 18/126
16/126
NR
NR
Respondents without COVID-19
Abadias-Granado, 2021
Spain
Case-control HHV6 Blood
(Serology)
16 6/16 NR
NR
COVID-19 patients Active
(NR)
Skin rash 4 weeks NR 8 0/8 NR
NR
Randomly selected hospitalized patients, of a similar median
age, with COVID-19 but without cutaneous manifestations
Vigon, 2021
Spain
Case-control EBV
CMV
Blood
(RT-PCR)
61 Total
21 mild
17 severe
23 critical COVID-19
Total
EBV: 10/61
CMV: 12/61
Severe COVID-19
EBV: 2/17 CMV: 4/17
Critical COVID-19
EBV: 8/23
CMV: 8/23
42.2 (26-64) mild COVID-19
74.2 (50-90) severe COVID-19
64.1 (42-88) critical COVID-19
med (IQR)
10 (47.6%(vs. 11 (52.4%) mild COVID-19
12 (70.6%) vs. 5 (29.4%) severe COVID-19
14 (60.9%) vs. 9 (39.1%) critical COVID-19
SARS-CoV-2 positive patients (performed with RT-qPCR assay in nasopharyngeal smear) older than 18 year with different clinical
presentations of COVID-19: mild, severe or critical
Active
(Specific herpesvirus IgG Ab increased progressively in accordance to COVID-19 severity;
Relative risk ratio between reactivation of EBV and/or
CMV and death during hospitalization due to COVID-19 was
0.8556, although it was not statistically significant)
NR NR NR 21 0/21
0/21
NR
NR
Healthy donors (over 18 years and who have
never been in contact with SARS-CoV-2 at the time of sampling)
with similar age and gender distribution to mild
COVID-19 patients.
Singh, 2021 USA Cross-sectional EBV
CMV
HSV
nasopharyngeal, oropharyngeal, and sputum swabs
(RT-PCR)
4259 91/4259
3/4259
5/4259
45.21±20.43
mean±sd
(20-49)
min-max
1891(44.4%) vs. 2364 (55.5%)
COVID-19 patients Active
(NR)
NR NR NR 46160 2627/46160
42/46160
37/46160
NR
NR
Respondents without COVID-19
Brinkmann, 2022
Morocco
Cross-sectional EBV
CMV
HSV1
NR
(RT-PCR,
rapid multiplex approach (Sequencing)
84 3/84
0/84
2/84
NR
NR
Critically ill COVID-19 patients Active
(NR)
NR NR NR 66 6/66
4/66
2/66
NR
NR
Respondents without COVID-19
Kahwagi, 2022
Senegal
Case-control EBV
VZV
HSV
HHV7
CSF, blood
(RT-PCR)
8 8/8
7/8
8/8
8/8
NR
NR
COVID-19 patients presenting clinical signs of encephalitis
assessed by clinicians and requiring hospitalization.
Patients presenting with an identified cause (e.g., Malaria) were excluded from the study.
Active
(NR)
Encephalitis NR NR 114 0/114
0/114
0/114
0/114
NR
NR
Patients presenting clinical signs of encephalitis
assessed by clinicians and requiring hospitalization without COVID-19
Aragon-Nogales, 2022
UK
Prospective cohort study EBV Blood
(PCR)
181
(27 moderate, 16 severe, 17 critically ill)
1/17 For 17 critically ill
4.1 (6 months -15 years) med (min-max)
12 (70.6) vs. 5 (29.4)
COVID-19 pediatric population with mild, moderate, severe, or critical (critical, if acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), multiorgan failure (MOF), septic shock, or
coma occurs) severity of the disease
Active
(NR)
NR NR NR 516 NR 1 day-5years – 207 (40%),
6-12 years – 170 (33%)
>12 years - 76 (27%)
NR
COVID-19 negative pediatric population with other viral respiratory diseases
Katz, 2022
USA
Cross-sectional HSV1
VZV
Blood
(Serology)
889 25/889
16/889
0-9 years - 17 (1.9%)
10-17 years - 22 (2.5%)
18-34 years - 355 (39.9)
35-44 years - 99 (11.1%)
45-54 years - 11 (1.2%)
55-64 years - 100 (11.2%)
65-74 years - 109 (12.3%)
75-85 years - 57 (6.5%)
>85 years - 57 (6.5%)
380 (42.7%) vs. 509 (57.3%)
COVID19 out- and in-patients Active
(NR)
NR NR NR 987849 7625/987849
4228/987849
0-9 years - 90881 (9.2%)
10-17 years – 66186 (6.7%)
18-34 years - 212388 (21.5%)
35-44 years - 94834 (9.6%)
45-54 years – 106688 (10.8%)
55-64 years - 154104 (15.62%)
65-74 years - 144226 (14.6%)
75-85 years - 83967 (8.5%)
>85 years – 34575 (3.5%)
455458 (46.11%) vs. 532391 (53.89%)
Hospital non-COVID-19 population from the Integrated Data repository (IDR)
Romani, 2022
Italy
Case-control HHV6 NR
(RT-PCR)
68 1/68 6.5 years (0.9-11.5)
Med (IQR)
38 (56%) vs. 30 (44%)
COVID19 pediatric population with mild, moderate or severe disease Active
(NR)
NR NR NR 16 3/16 4.4 years (1.7-6.3)
10 (53%) vs. 6 (47%)
Age matched non-COVID-19 pediatric patients
Zhu, 2020
China
Cross-sectional HSV
CMV
EBV
Nasopharyngeal/ throat swab
(RT-PCR)
257 249/257
254/257
205/257
51 (2-99)
med (min-max)
138 (53.7) vs. 119 (46.3)
COVID-19 patients Active
(NR)
NR From -4 to 0 days from COVID-19 onset NR / / / /
Wenzel, 2020
Germany
Case series EBV
HHV6
Endomyocardial biopsies
(RT-PCR)
2 2/2
1/2
Case 1: 39
Case 2:36
2 males
Patients with myocarditis who recently suffered from COVID-19 Past
(NR)
NR 4 weeks NR / / / /
Zhao, 2020
China
Cross-sectional HSV
CMV
EBV
Blood
(Serology)
417 18/417
0/417
12/417
45.2±17.6
mean±sd
198 (47.5) vs. 219 (52.5)
COVID-19 patients with severe (including severe type implied one of the following conditions: (a) respiratory distress, respiratory rate ≥30 per min; (b) oxygen saturation on quiescent condition ≤ 93%; (c) partial pressure of oxygen in arterial blood/fraction of inspired oxygen (PaO2/FiO2)≤300 mmHg (1 mmHg=0.133 kPa); (iv) and critical type implied one of the following conditions: (a) respiratory failure occurred and mechanical ventilation was required; (b) shock occurred; (c) patients had other organ dysfunction needing intensive care unit monitoring and treatment) and non-severe (including mild type implied the mild clinical symptoms with no abnormal radiological findings, and common type implied fever and respiratory symptoms and pneumonia detected on chest computed tomography) disease Active
(NR)
NR NR NR / / / /
Wu, 2020
China
Case series CMV
EBV
nasopharyngeal/ throat swab
(RT-PCR)
74 3/74
3/74
6.0 (0.10-15.08)
med (min-max)
44 (59.5) vs. 30 (40.5)
Children without comorbidities Active
(NR)
NR NR NR / / / /
Busani, 2020
Italy
Case series HSV1
CMV
EBV
Cell free plasma
(RT-PCR)
107 2/107
0/107
0/107
Case 1 - 66
Case 2 – 49
2 males
Case 1 - history of hypertension, hypercholesterolemia and depression
Case 2 - body-mass index of 32 and no significant medical history
Active
(Complete recovery)
Ocular manifestations NR NR / / / /
Meyer, 2021
France
Propsective cohort HSV blood and lower respiratory tract samples
(RT-PCR)
153 40/153
36/146 in blood
(19/61 respiratory sample, HSV reactivation in 15/153 in blood and respiratory samples
HSV-1 reactivation first in blood in 7/15, in respiratory
tract in 6/15 and simultaneously in 2/15 patients)
60.8 (50-70)
med (IQR)
115 (75.2%) vs. 38 (24.8%)
COVID-19 patients in the ICU with HSV reactivation defined as
a HSV-positive PCR in blood or respiratory samples
Active
(After adjustment for mortality risk factors (age, oxygenation and ventilation characteristics, extra-respiratory components of SOFA score and corticosteroid therapy), multivariable Cox regression model showed an increased risk of mortality for HSV1 reactivation)
NR The median time from ICU admission to the first HSVpositive
sample was 14 days (IQR 9.5–18).
NR / / / /
Halawi, 2021
Saudi Arabia
Cross-sectional CMV
HSV1
NR
(Serology)
417 2/417
123/417
< 30 years - 153 (37%)
30-50 years - 234 (56%)
> 50 years - 30 (7%)
150 (36%) vs. 267 (64%)
COVID-19 patients with diarrhea Active
(NR)
NR NR NR / / / /
Paolucci, 2021
Italy
Cross-sectional CMV
EBV
HHV6
Serum
(Serology)
104 Total
42 ICU
62 SICU
0/104
91/104 (40/42 ICU and 51/62 SICU)
0/104
ICU patients - 61.5 (55-71.25)
SICU patients - 73.5 (57.8-80)
med (IQR)
36 (85.7%) vs. 6 (14.3) in ICU
41 (66.1%) vs. 21 (33.9%) in SICU
COVID-19 patients treated in ICU and SICU Active
(NR)
NR NR NR / / / /
Saade, 2021
France
Cross-sectional HSV
EBV
CMV
HSV, EBV, CMV=blood; HSV=blood, BAL, skin swabs
(RT-PCR)
100 12/100
58/100
19/100
59 (53–67)
median (min-max)
73 (73%) vs. 23 (23%)
Severe COVID-19 patients with malignancies and organ recipients Active
(NR)
Cutaneous-mucous manifestations NR Valganciclovir for CMV reactivation, No treatment for EBV reactivation, Acyclovir and Valacyclovir for HSV reactivation / / / /
Xie, 2021
China
Cross-sectional EBV NR
(RT-PCR)
128 17/128 62 (52-68)
med (IQR)
66 (51.6%) vs. 62 (48.4%)
COVID-19 patients treated in ICU Active
(EBV
group had significantly higher 28-day and 14-day mortality
than Non-EBV group (p=0.005))
NR NR NR / / / /
Bašić-Jukić⁎⁎, 2021
Croatia
Prospective cohort study VZV
EBV
CMV
Serum
(RT-PCR)
104 1/104
9/104
27/104
56 (45-65)
med (IQR)
56 (24-80)
med (min-max)
69 (66.3%) vs. 35 (33.7)
Renal transplant recipients after COVID-19 Past
(NR)
Herpes Zoster and CMV colitis in one patient each At the initial evaluation and 6 months after COVID-19 Foscarnet, Letermovir, Hyperimmune anti-CMV globulins / / / /
Seeßle, 2021
USA
Case-series HSV1 Serum, tracheal secretion, and bronchial lavage
(RT-PCR)
18 available specimens out of 103 COVID-19 patients 15/18
9/18 in tracheal secretion
6/18 in bronchial lavage
data for 15 HSV1 positive COVID-19 patients
71 (16)
med (IQR)
12 (80%) vs. 3 (20%)
Patients with laboratory confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection with an age of 18 years or over invasively ventilated because of
severe or critical pneumonia
Active
(Complete recovery)
NR 19.5 days mean
18 (12-28) days
med (min-max)
Acyclovir / / / /
Simonnet, 2021
France
Cross-sectional EBV
CMV
HHV6
Blood
(RT-PCR)
34 28/34
5/34
7/32
58 (26–81)
med (min-max)
25 (73%) vs. 9 (27%)
Critically ill COVID-19 patients treated in ICU Active
(No association between ICU
mortality and EBV, CMV and HHV-6 reactivation)
NR Median delay between ICU admission and initial virus DNA detection:
EBV - 4 days (range 0–20)
CMV 12 days (range 1–16)
HHV6 12 days (range 8–19)
Ganciclovir or Valganciclovir for CMV reactivation cases / / / /
Chen, 2021
China
Cross-sectional EBV
CMV
Blood
(Serology)
67 37/67
0/67
37 years (IQR 30–52; range 23–81 years)
32 (47.8%) vs. 35 (52.2%)
COVID-19 hospitalized patients The inclusion criteria in our study were as follows: (1) At least one positive result by real-time quantitative reverse-transcriptase-polymerase-chain reaction (RT-PCR) assay for SARS-CoV-2 when in hospital; (2) Measuring the antibodies against EBV VCA (IgM, IgG), EBV early antigen (EA, IgM) and EBV nuclear antigen (EBNA, IgG); (3) Time of the onset of symptoms to hospital admission less than 2 weeks. Exclusion criteria: (1) In hospital time later than February 29, 2020; (2) Most clinical information were missing. Active
(NR)
NR NR NR / / / /
Gold⁎⁎, 2021
USA
Cross-sectional EBV Blood
(Serology, and for seronegative cases RT-PCR also)
68d
39 LC
29 non-LC
29/68 Total
26/39 LC patients
3/29 non-LC patients
21-74
NR
COVID-19 patients between 21 and 74 years who weren`t pregnant and not vaccinated and/or without symptoms similar to long COVID prior to testing positive for COVID-19. Past
(Long COVID)
Long-COVID symptoms At least 4 weeks NR / / / /
Blumenthal, 2022
South Africa
Cross-sectional EBV
HHV8
Blood
(RT-PCR)
104 81/104
21/104
53.0 (21.2-85.7)
med (min-max)
63 (60.6%) vs. 41 (39.4%)
Hospitalized COVID-19 patients Active
(NR)
NR NR NR / / / /
Brooks, 2022
USA
Prospective cohort study EBV
HHV6
Plasma
(qPCR)
67 15/67
3/67
60 (48-66)
med (IQR)
39 (58%) vs. 28 (42%)
COVID-19 adult patients aged ≥18 years Active NR NR NR / / / /
Huang, 2022
Taiwan
Cross-sectional CMV
EBV
Blood
(PCR)
75 5/75
12/75
NR
NR
COVID-19 patients Active NR NR NR / / / /
Lino, 2022
Brazil
Cross-sectional HHV6 Nasopharyngeal/ throat swab
(RT-PCR)
60 13/60 60.1±18.7
mean±sd
37 (61.6%) vs. 23 (38.4%)
Hospitalized COVID-19 patients with moderate to severe disease Active
(NR)
NR NR NR / / / /
Su, 2022
USA
Cohort study EBV
CMV
Blood
(RT-PCR)
209 29/209
0/209
56±18
mean±sd
18-89
min-max
104 (48.8%) vs. 105 (50.2%)
Patients with spectrum of acute COVID-19 severities Active
(NR)
NR At the clinical diagnosis of COVID-19 NR / / / /
Carneiro, 2022
Brazil
Cross-sectional HSV1
HSV2
VZV
CMV
HHV6
HHV7
EBV
HHV8
nasopharyngeal swab
(RT-PCR)
53 25/53
23/53
21/53
9/53
9/53
1/53
15/53
4/53
63.51±15.68
mean±sd
17-95
min-max
27 (50.9%) vs. 26 (49.1%)
Patients with COVID-19 diagnosis confirmed
by RT-PCR treated in ICUs and with available consent forms signed by the patient or guardian/legal representative.
Pregnant women were excluded from the study.
Active
(A statistically significant association was observed between neurological
changes and HHV-6 detection (p = 0.034))
Central nervous system symptoms NR NR / / / /
Gatto⁎⁎, 2022
Italy
Cross sectional CMV whole blood
bronchoalveolar lavage
(RT-PCR)
431 88/431 in blood
30/88 in bronchoalveolar lavage
65 (56-72)
med (IQR)
323 (74.9%) vs. 108 (25.1%)
Patients admitted to ICUs with laboratory-confirmed
SARS-CoV-2 infection and moderate to severe acute distress respiratory syndrome (ARDS), while Patients with age < 18 years, ICU length of stay (LOS) < 24 h, limitation of care or do not resuscitate order were excluded from the study
Active
(Hospital mortality was higher in patients with (67.0%) than in patients without (24.5%) CMV reactivation but the adjusted analysis did not confirm this association (HR 1141, 95% CI 0.757–1721, p = 0.528))
CMV-related pneumonia described as new
worsening of pulmonary gas exchange, modification of
chest X-ray or computed tomography compatible with
new interstitial pneumonia, CMV blood reactivation and
no other causes of pneumonia/worsening of pulmonary
gas exchange.
17 (5-26) days in blood
med (IQR)
Ganciclovir for 10 days / / / /
Im, 2022
South Korea
Cross-sectional and
Retrospective cohort study
EBV Blood
(RT-PCR)
269f
Gr 1 - 212
Gr 2 - 44
Gr 3 - 10
Gr 4 - 2
Gr 5 - 1
Gr 6 - 0
45/269
15-29 years - 2/18
30-39 years - 0/36
40-49 years - 2/28
50-59 years - 7/36
60-69 years - 5/45
70-79 years - 15/46
≥ 80 years - 14/60
Gradus 1 - 30/212
Gradus 2 - 8/44
Gradus 3 - 4/10
Gradus 4 - 2/2
Gradus 5 - 1/1
Gradus 6 - 0/0
61.6 mean
15-29 years - 18 (6.7%)
30-39 years - 36 (13.4%)
40-49 years - 28 (10.4%)
50-59 years - 36 (13.4%)
60-69 years - 45 (16.7%)
70-79 years - 46 (17.1%)
≥ 80 years - 60 (22.3%)
109 (40.5%) vs. 160 (59.5%)
Adult COVID-19 patients (>15 years) classified according to the 6-
grade systemf. Patients admitted
directly to the intensive care unit (n=29) were not tested
and were excluded from the analysis. Also, patients not designated for EBV PCR testing (n=53), as well as, patients who were not tested within 5 days after hospitalization (n=8) were excluded.
Active
(EBV viremia was not associated with COVID-19 progression)
NR 2.3 days
median
NR / / / /
Meng, 2022
China
Cross-sectional EBV
CMV
Blood
(Serology)
217 55/217
Not reported
NR
NR
COVID‐19 patients defined as the presence of symptoms and positive reverse transcriptase (RT)‐PCR assays were in accordance with Chinese guidelines (sixth version) Active
(Patients with EBV reactivation have statistically nonsignificant higher mortality rate (12 [22%] vs. 18 [11%], p=0.080); As compared to patients with COVID‐19 who did not receive ganciclovir therapy, ganciclovir‐treated patients had improved survival rate (0.98, 95% CI [0.95, 1.00] vs. 0.88, 95% CI [0.81, 0.95], p = .010)
NR NR NR / / / /
Zubchenko⁎⁎, 2022
Ukraine
Case-control EBV
HHV6
CMV
saliva, blood, and mucous membrane
of the posterior pharyngeal wall
(Serology
RT-PCR)
88 68/88
(51/68 reactivation)
68/88 (39/68 reactivation)
0/88
NR
NR
COVID-19 patients (88) were divided into: 1) post-COVID syndrome and reactivation of herpesviruses (main group) (68) and 2) post-COVID syndrome without detectable DNA of herpesviruses (control group) (20) Past
(NR)
NR 1-4 months NR / / / /
a

Gender is reported as n (%) males vs. n (%) females, bOutcomes regarding active herpesvirus infection that refer to death, recovery, complications, etc, as reported in the original article, cDuration between SARS-CoV-2 positive result and herpesvirus clinical manifestation cNumber of Herpesvirus positive cases is reported as number of positive cases out of the total number of cases dThe “long-term long COVID group” was defined as tested positive for COVID-19 at least 90 days prior to being enrolled, and all reported one or more of the long COVID symptoms utilized for this study. The “long-term control group” was defined as tested positive for COVID-19 at least 90 days prior to enrollment, and none reported any of the long COVID symptoms we were assessing. The “short-term long COVID group” was defined as tested positive for COVID-19 21–90 days prior to enrollment, and all reported one or more of the long COVID symptoms utilized for this study. The “short-term control group” was defined as tested positive for COVID-19 21–90 days prior to enrollment, and none reported any of the long COVID symptoms we were assessing. eLong COVID subjects were those that reported one or more of the following un-abating symptoms after recovering from initial SARS-CoV-2 infection: fatigue, insomnia, headaches, myalgia, confusion/brain fog, weakness, rash, pharyngitis, abdominal pain, tinnitus, fever over 101° F, neck lymphadenopathy, or mild-to-moderate hearing loss, fGr 1, Gr 2, Gr 3, Gr 4, and Gr 5 are Gradus 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 defines as Grade 1, symptomatic but no oxygen therapy required; Grade 2, low-flow nasal cannula oxygenation; Grade 3, high-flow nasal cannula/non-invasive ventilation; Grade 4, mechanical ventilation; Grade 5, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; Grade 6, death.

Abbreviations: ICU – intensive care unit, SICU – sub-intensive care unit, EBV – Epstein-Barr virus, CMV – cytomegalovirus, sHLH - secondary hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis, NR – not reported, CSF – cerebral-spinal fluid, LC patients- Long COVID-19 patients, non-LC – patients without Long COVID-19, USA – United States of America, Ab – antibody, SOFA - Sequential Organ Failure Assessment score.

⁎⁎

Long-COVID or post-COVID symptoms reported