Summary of operando techniques applied to continuous-flow CO2 electrolyzers.
| Operando technique | Information content/main advantages | Main limitations | Time resolution | Spatial resolution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| XASa 18,113,115,117,119–123 | • Catalyst structure (oxidation state, coordination environment) | • Bulk sensitive | • Typically 20–30 minutes | N/A |
| • Only minor cell modification needed | • Synchrotron irradiation | • Subseconds for QXAFS | ||
| Raman spectroscopy51,52,124,125 | • Catalyst structure (oxidation state) | • SERS effect only on certain metal nanostructures | • Few tenths of seconds | • μm-scale (xb) |
| • Adsorbed intermediates/products | • Less suitable for zero-gap design | |||
| • Local pH with spatial resolution | ||||
| • Widely available at lab-scale | ||||
| Fluorescent microscopy50 | • Local pH measurement with spatial resolution in the x, y, z direction | • Fluorescent probe added to the electrolyte might change the local reaction environment | N/A | • μm- scale (x, y, zb) |
| • pH measurement within catalyst trenches | ||||
| UV-Vis spectroscopy30 | • pH measurement at the catalyst/membrane interface (MEA-design) | • Significantly different cell design compared to the real device (in situ) | N/A | • nm-scale (z) |
| SECMa | • Local reactivity and local pH | • Low achievable current densities | N/A | • μm-scale (x, y) |
| • Spatially resolved activity maps | ||||
| AFM126 a | • High resolution topography and mechanical property maps | • Small scan size | • Few minutes | • Few tenths/hundreds of nm |
| • Rapid flooding at high currents | ||||
| MS81,127 a | • Real-time detection of products/intermediates with low detection limit | • Deconvolution of signals (e.g., CO, CO2) can be challenging | • Seconds/tenths of seconds | N/A |
| • Mechanistic information | ||||
| • Isotopic information | ||||
| Neutron/X-ray radiography78,91,100,128,129 | • Water management | • Neutron/synchrotron facility | • Few seconds for X-ray few tenths of seconds for neutron | • μm – scale (x, y) |
| • Gas evolution | • Limited elemental information | |||
| • Precipitate formation | ||||
| • Operando cell failure diagnostics | ||||
| • Only minor cell modification needed | ||||
| Thermography130 | • Local activity mapping | • One-to-one correlation between temperature change and activity has to be proved | • Depends on catalyst substrate, layer thickness, etc. | |
| • Noninvasive probing to assess activity distribution | ||||
XAS: X-ray absorption spectroscopy, SECM: scanning electrochemical microscopy, AFM: atomic force microscopy, MS: mass spectrometry.
x and y are directions in the plane of the GDE, while z is perpendicular to that.