Table 3.
Organisational systems in combination with training.
| Authors | Antecedent-based |
Consequence-based |
||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Assess | Super roles | Response | Others | Mon/feed systems | Others | Effectiveness | Maintenance/generalization | |
| Crates and Spicer 2012 | Second generation trainees: allied health or nursing professionals, individuals with degree qualifications or adult education qualifications working in leadership roles within government and nongovernment service provision organisations |
First generation trainees were asked to train the second-generation trainees | PSR used for the intervention plans (as part of the longitudinal practicum) |
Staff: Quality of Behaviour Assessment and Intervention Plans: positive Fidelity of Plans: negative Residents: Challenging behaviour: positive Others: Referrals: positive Cost effectiveness: anecdotal positive |
Generalization: positive | |||
| Dench 2005 | Supervisors of trainees-staff are attending a supervisors’ workshop | PSR used by supervisors |
Staff: Quality of Behaviour Assessment and Intervention Plans: positive Fidelity of Plans: no information Residents: Challenging behaviour, positive Quality of life: no information (only anecdotal) Others: Organisational cost benefit analysis: positive |
|||||
| Haberlin et al. 2012 | 4 supervisors in one group | Pyramidal training (train the trainer program) for one of the groups | Training supervisors on how to deliver feedback |
Staff Correct teaching procedures: positive for both groups (higher results for pyramidal group) Knowledge: positive for both groups |
Generalization: Positive Maintenance: Positive for pyramidal group only |
|||
| MacDonald et al. 2018 | 72 managers first level managers | Manage and review staff practise was one of the objectives of the course | Training in PSR |
Staff Quality of staff support Fidelity of PBS plans and staff performance: negative Knowledge: positive for the experimental group Residents: Challenging behaviour: positive Quality of life: Negative |
Generalization: Positive Maintenance: Positive for pyramidal group only |
|||
| McGill et al. 2018 | Assessing provider’s score on defined social care standards | Managers and direct care staff were trained together by the researchers. | 3 h briefing session | Using traffic light system to evaluate performance (researchers faded their support and managers carried on the responsibility) |
Staff: Quality of support: Positive (ASM scores) Negative (Mean percentage of engagement) Residents: Challenging behaviour: positive Quality of life: negative Others: Provider’s quality of support: positive |
Maintenance: positive for reduction in challenging behaviour |
||
| McKenzie et al. 2002 |
Staff: Staff practice: positive Knowledge: positive Others: Staff challenging behaviour attribution: negative |
Maintenance: positive for staff practice and staff knowledge |
||||||
| O’Dwyer et al. 2017 | Staff at a team leader level | Staff responsible to create an implementation plan for the team, after the training. | Training for using BSP QE-II |
Staff: Behaviour Support Plan quality: positive but the quality of the BSPs of the trained group remained below optimal levels Residents: Challenging behaviour: negative Mental health: positive Others: frequency of restraint: negative |
Generalization: positive Change (quality of BSPs Remained below optimal Levels) |
|||
| Reid et al. 2003 | All trainees were supervisors | Through teaching supervisors feedback skills | Supervisors were taught feedback skills |
Staff: Performance based training skills: positive |
Generalization: the Impact on the trainees of The supervisors was not Measured |
|||
| Wardale et al. 2014 | 25.9% of the sample were allied health professionals (psychologists, occupational therapists), 24.6% direct support workers, 22.4% service managers, 20.6% service coordinators or team leaders 6.6% ‘other’ (such as educational staff). |
Staff: PSP quality: positive Knowledge: positive Others: Causal attributions: positive Evidence-based practises: negative |
||||||