Table 2.
General characteristics of included studies
| References | Country | Studies’ specificities | Type of economic evaluation | Outcome measure | Study design | Time horizon | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gender | Age | Early ACLR | CTa/delayed ACLR | Group | ||||||
| Gottlob et al. [12] | USA | M, F | 21–27 | 363 | 307 | Athletes and young people | CUA | QALYs, cost | Model-based | 7 years |
| Farshad et al. [10] | CH | M, F | 27.5 | 229 | 155 | Young people | CUA | QALYs, cost | Model-based | 7.5 years |
| Mather et al. [18] | USA | M, F | 26 ± 11 | 988* + 62** | 59 | Young people | CUA | QALYs, cost | Model-based | 6 years & lifetime |
| Mather et al. [17] | USA | M, F | 26 ± 11 | 807* + 62** | 59 | Young people | CUA | QALYs, cost | Model-based | 6 years |
| Kiadaliri et al. [15] | SE | M, F | 18–35 | 61 | 59 | Young people | CUA& CBA | QALYs, cost | Trial based | 5 years |
| Stewart et al. [38] | USA | M, F | Not reported | 2719 | 147 | Athletes | CUA | QALYs, cost | Model-based | 6 years |
| Eggerding et al. [8] | NL | M, F | 18–65 | 85 | 82 | young to middle-aged people | CUA | QALYs, cost | Trial based | 2 years |
CH Switzerland, SE Sweden, NL The Netherlands, QALY quality-adjusted life-year, CUA cost-utility analysis, CBA cost–benefit analysis, early ACLR early anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery, CTa conservative treatment alone, delayed ACLR conservative treatment with optional delayed anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction
*MOON database, **KANON study