Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 6;18(2):e0277000. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0277000

Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.

First author Publication date Study design Country Multicentre non-COVID ARDS comparator Number of COVID ARDS patients Number of non-COVID ARDS patients All patients on ECMO Longest follow-up available D-dimer data collection time
T. Autschbach [26] 2021 observational, cohort, propensity matched Germany no Influenza A (H1A1) 19 34 yes 90 days before ECMO
A. J. Doyle [15] 2021 retrospective UK no Influenza 51 80 yes - before ECMO
V. Fanelli [17] 2022 retrospective Italy yes H1N1 146 162 yes 90 days before ECMO
G. Hékimian [18] 2021 prospective, cohort France no severe influenza pneumonia, bacterial pneumonia, sepsis 20 10 yes on ECMO before ECMO
J. Helms [19] 2020 prospective and historical prospective cohort France yes bacterial, viral 150 233 no 7 days at ICU admission
D.J. Hoechter [20] 2020 retrospective Germany no any kind 22 14 no - within 48 hours from ICU admission
C. N. Lang [22] 2021 retrospective, observational Germany no any kind 47 116 not all (COVID-ARDS 14/47 vs. non-COVID ARDS 49/116) ICU stay at admission
M. Lemzey [21] 2020 retrospective, observational, case-control France no any kind 44 39 no 28 days at ICU admission
K. A. Northam [24] 2022 retrospective, cohort USA no influenza 31 14 yes in hospital mortality during ECMO
L. A. Raff [12] 2022 retrospective USA no influenza 32 28 yes 60 days before ECMO
B. Seelinger [23] 2022 retrospective Germany yes any kind 142 68 yes - before ECMO
M. W.Sjoding [14] 2021 retrospective, cohort USA no any kind 130 382 no 28 days within 48 hours from intubation
S.Spadaro [25] 2021 prospective Italy no any kind 31 10 no - within 48 hours from start of mechanical ventilation
S. Yin [16] 2021 retrospective China no any kind 449 104 no 28 days at the time the patients met the definition of severe illness
J. Zhang [13] 2021 retrospective China yes non-viral 90 130 no - at ICU admission

ARDS = acute respiratory distress syndrome; ECMO = extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; ICU = intensive care unit.