Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 23;25:e37487. doi: 10.2196/37487

Table 2.

Characteristics of interventions and their effect.

Study Description of the study group Intervention effect

Intervention group Control group
Dong et al [28], 2016
  • Lifestyle counseling for diet and physical activity by 2 professional physicians

  • Phone visit by doctors (10 min) every 3 months, providing health guidance on diet and exercise

  • Lifestyle counseling for diet and physical activity by 2 professional physicians

Weight: +a (IGb), BMI: + (IG, CGc), ACd: + (IG), ALTe: + (IG), ASTf: −g, NAFLD-FSh: + (IG, CG), liver steatosis grade: + (IG, CG)
Fard et al [29], 2016
  • Counseling, dietary advice from a nutritionist performing physical activities, face-to-face consultation

  • Telephone call follow-up the recommended diet and physical activities

  • Counseling, dietary advice from a nutritionist performing physical activities, face-to-face consultation

Weight: + (IG), BMI: + (IG), ALT: + (IG), AST: + (IG)
Axley et al [27], 2017
  • SMS text messages provided information and education including individual goal, nutrition, exercise, stress management, behavior change, and overcoming barriers every 9 AM

  • Standard of care for liver disease with detailed instruction in clinic on a healthy diet and daily exercise for weight loss

Weight: + (IG), BMI: + (IG), ALT: + (IG), AST: + (IG), HDLi: −, TGj: + (IG)
Lim et al [30], 2020
  • Advice on dietary and physical activity modification by a dietician

  • Food diary

  • Self-monitoring of physical activity

  • Real-time feedback and encouragement by a dietitian

  • Peer support chat channel

  • Weekly educational clips

  • Usual standard care: a single face-to-face session in the clinic

Weight: + (IG), BMI: + (IG), Waist circumference: + (IG, CG), ALT: + (IG), AST: + (IG)
Mazzotti et al [31], 2018
  • Web-based intervention: group program similar to GBI, divided 4 sessions using a Cloud/SaaS e-learning platform: role-game measuring adherence, motivation to change, and competence by online questionnaires; channel to interact with the clinical center offline

  • Group-based intervention: group counseling on diet, and habitual physical activity physicians and dietitians

Weight: + (IG), 10% weight loss: −, Waist circumference: + (IG), GGTk: + (IG), ALT: + (IG)
Pfirrmann et al [25], 2019
  • Web-based platform: Individualized training support (moderate-intensity exercise of 3 sessions per week for 4 weeks, and intensified exercise of 5 sessions per week for the remaining 4 weeks)

  • Regular individual patient feedback

  • Frequent interaction with a counselor and peer support using a discussion board and a chatroom

  • Biweekly group training at the sports center

  • None

Weight: +, body fat: +
Tincopa et al [32]
  • Mobile technology-based lifestyle intervention: step count and personalized feedback on physical activity with tailored weekly step count goals using Fitbit, and motivational messages via email

  • Nutrition assessment at baseline and month 3 by phone

  • Overall feedback on physical activity and nutrition over the first 3 months with nutrition assessment at month 3 using phone

  • None

Weight: −, BMI: −, Liver fat: −, Waist circumference: +, HDL: +, LDL: +, TG: +, HbA1cl: +

a+: yes.

bIG: intervention group.

cCG: control group.

dAC: abdominal circumference.

eALT: alanine aminotransferase.

fAST: aspartate aminotransferase.

g–: no.

hNAFLD-FS: nonalcoholic fatty liver disease fibrosis score.

iHDL: high-density lipoprotein.

jTG: triglyceride.

lHbA1c: hemoglobin A1c.