Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 28;24(3):2528. doi: 10.3390/ijms24032528

Table 5.

Summary of the included studies and the effect of combinatory cell therapy for SCI.

Type of Grafted Cells Biomaterial Scaffold Results/Advantages Limitations/Disadvantages
NPCs
  • PLGA scaffold

  • HA scaffold

  • Protein-functionalized chitosan scaffold

  • 3D biomimetic hydroge

  • Collagen microchannel scaffold

  • 3D printed heparin sulfate-collagen scaffold

  • Exosomes-collagen scaffold

  • Multi-channel collagen scaffold

  • Aligned collagen scaffold

  • Polymer scaffold

  • Chitosan channels scaffold

  • Protein-functionalized chitosan scaffold

  • Laminin-coated pHEMA-MOETACl Hydrogel

  • Artificial microfiber scaffold

  • Polycaprolactone electrospun fiber scaffold

  • Fibrin scaffold

  • SAP scaffold

  • Matrigel scaffold

  • Functional recovery

  • Graft cells survival and neuronal cell differentiation

  • Secretion of trophic factors

  • Protection of host neuronal cells

  • Axonal outgrowth through injured lesion

  • Remyelination of host axons

  • Neuronal differentiation

  • Host cells survival

  • Immune rejection

  • Tumorgenesis

BMCSs
  • Chitosan-based thermosensitive scaffold

  • Chitosan conduits scaffold

  • Alginate hydrogel biomaterial

  • PLGA scaffold

  • Collagen scaffold

  • Collagen filaments scaffold

  • Porous collagen scaffold

  • NeuroRegen scaffold

  • PLGA scaffold

  • HA-PLL scaffold

  • SAP hydrogel scaffold

  • Biologic scaffolds derived from fibrin and blood plasma

  • Goldnanoparticles (Au NPs)-loaded Agarose/Poly (N-

  • isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM)

  • Thermosensitive quaternary ammonium chloride

  • chitosan/β-glycerophosphate (HACC/β-GP) hydrogel scaffold

  • Gelatin sponge scaffold

  • Nanofibrous silk scaffold

  • Cylindrical poly(D,L-lactide-co-glycolide)/small intestinal

  • submucosa scaffold

  • PHEMA scaffold

  • Functional recovery

  • Repair of spinal cord injury

  • Secretion of trophic factors

  • Protection of host neuronal cells

  • Axonal outgrowth

  • Remyelination of host axons

  • Host cells survival

  • Low risk of immune rejection

  • Autologous transplants

  • No ethical issues

  • Difficulty of neuronal differentiation

  • Low cell survival rate

Umbilical MSCs/Wharton’s jelly-derived MSCs
  • Collagen scaffold

  • 3D printed collagen/silk fibroin scaffold

  • HA-PH modified with the integrin-binding peptide

  • arginine-glycine-aspartic acid scaffold

Adipose-derived stem/stromal cells
  • Silk fibroin/chitosan scaffold

  • Matrigel scaffold

  • Resorbable poly(α-hydroxyacid) guidance channels scaffold

Schwann cells (SCs)
  • Biodegradable poly-b-hydroxybutyrate scaffold

  • Oligo[poly(ethylene glycol) fumarate] scaffold

  • Axon growth into SCs implants

  • Ensheathment and myelination

  • No tumorigenicity

  • Modest but significant motor and sensory improvement

  • SCs-elicited responses such as survivability post-transplantation,

  • axon growth, and functional recovery can be improved with

  • appropriate combination treatments

  • Remyelination

  • Functional recovery

  • Secretion of trophic factors

  • No differentiation into

  • neurons and astrocytes

OECs
  • PLGA Scaffold

  • Functional recovery

  • Promotion of cell differentiation

  • Inhibition of astrocyte formation

  • Accelerate neuronal regeneration

  • Secrete nerve growth factors

  • Decrease neuronal apoptosis

  • Reduce glial scaring

  • Produce a number of trophic factors such as VEGF

  • Constitute the myelin and the Ranvier nodes of the axons

  • No differentiation into

  • neurons and astrocytes

Spinal cord-derived ependymal progenitor cells
  • HA containing PLA fibers scaffold

  • Preserve the neuronal tissue

  • Diminish astrocytic reactivity surrounding the scar area

  • Axonal outgrowth

  • No functional recovery

Dental pulp stem cells/Dental follicle cells
  • Chitosan scaffolds

  • Aligned electrospun PCL/PLGA material scaffold

  • Increase the levels of BDNF, GDNF, beta-NGF and NT-3

  • Recovery of hind limb locomotor functions

  • No differentiation into

  • neurons and astrocytes

NPCs and Schwann cells
  • 3D bioprinting of NSC-laden HBC/HA/MA scaffold

  • PLGA scaffolds

  • Biodegradable polymer scaffold

  • Poly (L-lactic-co-glycolic acid) scaffold

  • Provision of an ideal microenvironment for the growth

  • and neural differentiation of grafted cells.

  • Restoration of locomotor function

  • Simulation of the parallel linear structure of spinal cord

  • for optimal neuron regeneration and connection.

  • Immune rejection

  • Tumorgenesis

BMSCs and Schwann cells
  • Multichannel polymer scaffold

  • Functional recovery

  • Secretion of trophic factors

  • Protection of host neuronal cells

  • Axonal outgrowth through injured lesion

  • Remyelination of host axons

  • No differentiation into

  • neurons and astrocytes

Endometrial stem cells and Schwann cells
  • Degradable polymer implant

  • PCL/gelatin nanofibrous scaffold

  • Functional recovery

  • Secretion of trophic factors

  • Protection of host neuronal cells

  • Axonal outgrowth through injured lesion

  • Remyelination of host axons

  • Host cells survival

  • No differentiation into

  • neurons and astrocytes

Dermal fibroblast-reprogrammed neurons
  • 3D silk fibrous material

  • Functional recovery

  • Axonal outgrowth through injured lesion

  • Remyelination of host axons

  • No differentiation into

  • neurons and astrocytes

Adipose-derived stem cells and OECs
  • Serum-derived albumin scaffold

  • Functional recovery

  • Secretion of trophic factors

  • Protection of host neuronal cells

  • Axonal outgrowth through injured lesion

  • Remyelination of host axons

  • No differentiation into

  • neurons and astrocytes

NPCs and MSCs
  • 3D longitudinal scaffold

  • Functional recovery

  • Graft cells survival and neuronal cell differentiation

  • Secretion of trophic factors

  • Protection of host neuronal cells

  • Axonal outgrowth through injured lesion

  • Remyelination of host axons

  • Neuronal differentiation

  • Host cells survival

  • Immune rejection

  • Tumorgenesis