Table 2.
Species | Plant Material | Metal(loid) Concentration |
Duration of Exposure |
PC Structure | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Amaranthaceae | |||||
Amaranthus hypochondriacus | Leaves | 100 mg/kg Cd | 3 months | PC2–4 | [40] |
Pfaffia glomerata | Roots | 25, 50, 100 µM As | 28 days | PC2–4 | [41] |
Spinacia oleraceae | Roots, leaves | 1, 3, 5, 9 mg/L Cd | 1, 3, 5, 7, 9, 14 days | PC2–4 | [42] |
Apiaceae | |||||
Datura innoxia | Cell culture | 250 µM Cd | up to 2 h | PC2–5 | [43] |
Apocynaceae | |||||
Rauvolfia serpentina | Cell culture | 200 µM Cd | 1–9 h | PC2–5 | [44] |
Asteraceae | |||||
Dittrichia viscosa | Roots, shoots | 5, 10, 15 mg/L Cd | 10 days | PC2–4, iso-PC2–3(Cys), des-γGlu-iso-PC2–3(Gly), des-Gly-PC2–3 |
[45] |
Eupatorium cannabinum | Roots | 11 mg/L As | 20 days | PC2–4, des-Gly-PC2–4, γGlu-iso-PC3(Gly) |
[46] |
Leaves | PC3–4, des-Gly-PC2, des-γGlu-iso-PC2(Gly) |
||||
Helianthus annuus | Roots, stems, leaves | 66 µmol/L As | 1–96 h | PC2–3 | [47] |
Brassicaceae | |||||
Arabidopsis halleri | Roots | 25 µM Cd 100 µM Cd |
7 days | PC2–4 PC2–5 |
[48] |
Shoots | 25 µM Cd 100 µM Cd |
n.d. * PC2–4 |
|||
Arabidopsis thaliana | Seedlings | 30 µM Cd | 1 day | PC2–4 | [49] |
30, 90 µM Cd | 3, 9 days | PC2–4 | [50] | ||
20 µM Cd | 3 days | PC2–4 | [51] | ||
10 µM Cd | 5 days | PC2–4 | [52] | ||
Roots, leaves | 5 µM Cd | 1, 3, 7, 14, 21 days | PC2–5 | [53] | |
Roots, shoots | 10, 25 µM Cd | 7 days | PC2–5 | [48] | |
Leaves | 7.5 mg/kg Cd 970 mg/kg Zn |
24 days | PC2–3 | [54] | |
Roots, shoots | 10 µM Cd 5 µM Cu 150 µM Zn |
12 days | PC2–5 | [55] | |
Roots, shoots | 20 µM Cd | 72 h | PC2–4 | [56] | |
Roots, shoots | 1 µM Hg, 0.1 µM phenylmercury |
4 days | PC2 | [57] | |
Cell culture | 200 µM Cd | 1, 4, 8, 11, 24, 48 h |
PC2–4(5), iso-PC3–4(Ser), iso- PC3(Glu), iso-PC3–4(βAla), iso-PC3–4(Gln) |
[58] | |
50 µM Cd | 1 day | PC2–5, iso-PC3–4(βAla) | |||
400 µM Cd | 1 day | PC2–5, iso-PC3–4(Ser), iso- PC3(Glu), iso-PC3–4(βAla), iso-PC3–4(Gln) |
|||
Armoracia rusticana | Roots | 1000 µM Cd | 3 days | PC3–4 | [59] |
Brassica chinensis | Roots | 200 µM Hg | 3 days | PC2–4 | [60] |
Brassica juncea | Roots, shoots | 50, 200 µM Cd | 7 days | PC2–4 | [61] |
Roots, leaves | 500, 1000, 2000 mg/kg Pb | 45 days | PC2–3 | [62] | |
Brassica oleracea | Seedlings | 90 µM Cd | 21 days | PC2–6 | [44] |
Noccaea caerulescens
(Thlaspi caerulescens) |
Roots, shoots | 1–50 µM Cd | 4 days | PC2–3 | [63] |
Roots shoots |
25, 100 µM Cd 25, 100 µM Cd |
7 days 7 days |
PC2–4 n.d. |
[48] | |
Roots, shoots | 5–500 µM Cd | 14 days | PC2–4 | [64] | |
Sinapis alba | Leaves | 0.5, 1 mg/L Pd | 2 weeks | PC2–4 | [65] |
Thlaspi arvense | Roots, shoots | 1–50 µM Cd | 4 days | PC2–3 | [63] |
Caryophyllaceae | |||||
Silene vulgaris | Cell culture | 20 µM Cd | 3 days | PC2–4 | [44] |
Roots | 0.3, 1, 45, 135, 180 µM Cd |
3 days | PC2–4 | [66] | |
40 mmol m−3 Cd | 21 days | PC2–3 | [67] | ||
Crassulaceae | |||||
Sedum alfredii | Shoots | 500 µM Cd | 8 days | PC2–4 | [68] |
Cucurbitaceae | |||||
Cucumis sativus | Roots | 10–250 µM Sb | 28 days | PC2, 3 | [69] |
Fabaceae | |||||
Arachis hypogaea | Roots | 10 µM Cd | 30 days | PC2–4 | [70] |
Glycine max | Roots | 20 µM Cd | 4 days | iso-PC2–7(βAla) | [71] |
Pisum sativum | Roots | 20 µM Cd | 3 days | PC2–3, iso-PC3(βAla) | [72] |
1–120 µM Cd | 1–9 days | PC2–4, iso-PC2–4(βAla) | [73] | ||
Lamiaceae | |||||
Clinopodium vulgare | Roots | 20 mg/kg Cd 250 mg/kg Pb 400 mg/kg Cu 400 mg/kg Zn |
95, 105 days | All metals: PC2–5, iso-PC2(Ala); Cu: iso-PC2(Glu), iso-PC2–4(Cys); Cu, Cd, Pb: des-γGlu-iso-PC2–3(Gly); Cu, Cd, Pb: des-Gly-PC2 | [74] |
Shoots | 20 mg/kg Cd 250 mg/kg Pb 400 mg/kg Cu 400 mg/kg Zn |
95, 105 days | All metals: PC2–5Cu, Cd, Pb: des-γGlu-iso-PC2–3(Gly) Cu, Cd, Pb: des-Gly-PC2 |
||
Perilla frutescens | Roots, stems, leaves | 2, 5, 10 mg/L Cd | 14 days | PC2–4 | [75] |
21 days | PC2–3 | ||||
Marchantiaceae | |||||
Marchantia polymorpha | Gametophyte | 10–36 µM Cd | 6–120 h | PC2–4 | [76] |
10, 20, 36 µM Cd | 72 h | PC2–4 | [77] | ||
Poaceae | |||||
Agrostis tenuis | Cell culture | 20 µM Cd | 3 days | PC2–4 | [44] |
Avena sativa | Roots | 10 µM Cd | 4 days | PC2–3 | [78] |
Holcus lanatus | Roots | 5, 15, 40, 800 µM As | 7 days | PC2–4 | [79] |
Lolium perenne | Roots, shoots | 20, 80 µM Cd | 9 days | PC2–6 | [80] |
20, 80 µM Cd | 216 h | PC2–6 | [81] | ||
Oryza sativa | Roots | 10 µM Cd 20 µM As |
7 days | PC2–3, iso-PC2(Ser), iso-PC(Glu) | [82] |
Roots, stems, leaves |
50, 100 µM Cd | 7 days | PC2–4, iso-PC2–3(Gln), iso-PC2–3(Asn), iso-PC2(Cys), des-γGlu-iso-PC3(Ser), des-Cys-iso-PC2(Glu), des-Gly-PC2–4, iso-PC2–4(Ser), iso-PC2–4(Glu) | [83] | |
Roots, shoots | 100 µM As | 10 days | PC2–4 | [84] | |
Roots, shoots | 50 µM Cd | 14 days | PC2–4 | [85] | |
Panicum maximum | Roots | 100 µM Cd | 9 days | PC2–4, des-Gly-PC2–4, iso-PC2–3(βAla), des-γGlu-iso-PC2(Gly) |
[86] |
Stems | PC3, 5, 6, iso-PC2–4(βAla), des-Gly-PC4, des-γGlu-iso-PC2–3(Gly) |
||||
Leaves | PC6, iso-PC4(βAla) | ||||
Phragmites australis | Roots | 100 µM Cd | 21 days | PC2–4 | [87] |
Secale cereale | Roots | 50, 250 µM Cd | 3, 6, 12, 24 h, 3, 7, 14 days |
PC2–3, iso-PC2–3(Ser), des-Gly-PC2–3 | [88] |
Shoots | 50 µM Cd 250 µM Cd |
7,14 days 7 days |
PC2–3, iso-PC2–3(Ser), des-Gly-PC2–3 | ||
Triticum aestivum | Roots | 1 µM Cd | 12 days | PC2–3, iso-PC2–3(Ser) | [89] |
30 µM Cd | PC2–4, iso-PC2–4(Ser) | ||||
Roots | 1 mM Cd | 10, 20 days | PC2–4, des-Gly-PC2–3 | [90] | |
Shoots | PC2–4 | ||||
Triticum turgidum var. durum | Roots | 1 µM Cd | 12 days | PC2–3, iso-PC2–3(Ser) | [89] |
30 µM Cd | PC2–4, iso-PC2–4(Ser) | ||||
Triticum vulgare | Roots | 50, 250 µM Cd | 3, 6, 12, 24 h, 3, 7, 14 days |
PC2–3, iso-PC2–3(Ser), des-Gly-PC2–3 | [88] |
Shoots | 7,14 days | ||||
Zea mays | Roots | 50 µM Cd | 3, 6, 12, 24 h, 3, 7, 14 days |
PC2–4, iso-PC2(Glu), des-Gly-PC2–3 | [88] |
0.01 µM Cd 0.05, 0.1 µM Cd 0.5, 1, 10 µM Cd 3 µM Cd |
1 day 1 day 1 day 2, 4, 6 h; 1, 2 days |
PC2 PC2–3 PC2–4 PC2–4 |
[91] | ||
3 µM Cd | 1–7 days | PC2–4, des-Gly-PC2–4, iso-PC2–4(Glu) |
[92,93] | ||
Roots | 38 µM Cd | 5 days | PC2–5, iso-PC2–5(Ser) | [94] | |
Shoots | PC2–3, iso-PC2–3(Ser) | ||||
Roots | 10, 15, 25 µM Cd | 14 days | PC2–3, PC7, 8, PC10, PC4, 9 (10 and 15 µM Cd), PC5 (25 µM Cd), PC6 (10 and 25 µM Cd) |
[95] | |
Leaves | PC2,3,6,8,10 PC4 (25 µM Cd) |
||||
Seedlings | 20 µM Cd | 3 days | PC2–4 | [44] | |
Pontederiaceae | |||||
Pontederia crassipes (Eichhornia crassipes) | Seedlings | 20 µM Cd | 3 days | PC2–4 | [44] |
Roots | 1, 2.5, 3.5 ppm Cd | 45 days | PC2–4 | [96] | |
Proteaceae | |||||
Banksia seminuda | Roots | 10–250 µM Sb | 120 days | PC2, 3 | [69] |
Hakea prostrata | Roots | 10–250 µM Sb | 120 days | PC2, 3 | [69] |
Pteridaceae | |||||
Pteris cretica | Fronds | 100 mg/kg As | 1 year | PC2 | [97] |
Rubiaceae | |||||
Rubia tinctorum | Cell culture | 100 µM Cd | 3 days | PC2–4, des-Gly-PC2–4 | [98] |
Salicaceae | |||||
Salix atrocinerea | Roots | 18 mg/L As | 1, 3, 10, 30 days |
PC2–3, des-Gly-PC3, des-γGlu-iso-PC2–3(Gly) |
[99] |
Leaves | des-Gly-PC2–4 | ||||
Solanaceae | |||||
Nicotiana rustica | Leaves | 20 µM Cd | 7 days | PC3–4 | [100] |
Nicotiana tabacum | Cell culture | 250 µM Cd | 3 days | PC4–5 | [101] |
Seedlings | 30, 90 µM Cd | 3, 9 days | PC2–4 | [50] | |
Solanum lycopersicum (Lycopersicon esculentum) | Cell culture | 100 µM Cd | 2 h | PC3–5 | [102] |
100, 300 µM Cd | 1–12 days | PC2 | [103] | ||
600 µM Cd | 36 h | PC3–4 | [104] | ||
10, 50, 100 µM Cd |
4 days | PC2–4 | [105] | ||
100 µM Cd | 7 days | PC2–4 | [106] | ||
Roots | 3 µM Cd | 7 days | PC3 | [107] | |
Seedlings | 90 µM Cd | 21 days | PC2–6 | [44] | |
Roots, leaves | 25, 100 µM Cd | 14 days | PC2–4 | [108] | |
Vitaceae | |||||
Vitis vinifera | Roots | 100 mg/L Hg | 3 days | PC2–4 | [109] |
* n.d.—not determined.