Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 10;2023(2):CD014823. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD014823

1. Characteristics of studies included and sampled.

Author(s), Year Country Mode of rehabilitation delivery Description of study participants Health condition or disability addressed by the study/Type of rehabilitation  delivered Study design/ Data collection approach/ Data analysis approach
Argent 2018 Ireland Home‐based telerehabilitation Ten healthcare professionals (four physiotherapists, two clinical nurse specialists, two orthopaedic assistants, one occupational therapist and one staff nurse) Joint replacement/
Exercise therapy
Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis with a grounded‐theory approach
Borade 2019 India In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Twenty‐five patients having mobility related disabilities, who used one or more ads Mobility restriction/ Activities in daily living (ADL) Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis
Brouns 2018 Netherlands In‐person + home‐based telerehabilitation Thirty‐two patients, fifteen caregivers, and thirteen healthcare professionals (physiotherapists, psychologists, occupational therapists, speech therapists, physicians, and managers) Stroke/ Multidisciplinary  Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured individual and focus group interviews/ Direct content analysis using the implementation model of Grol
Bodker 2015 Denmark In‐person + home‐based telerehabilitation Eleven patients with COPD and the therapist of the programme (managing nurse and the physiotherapist) Chronic Obstructive
Pulmonary Disease/ Pulmonary  
Ethnographic/ Observations and semi‐structured interviews/ Analytical concepts developed within STS (Science and Technology Studies) in order to study the taming and unleashing of telecare
Damhus 2018 Denmark Home‐based telerehabilitation Twenty‐five healthcare professionals (6 nurses and 19 physiotherapists) Chronic Obstructive
Pulmonary Disease/ Respiratory
Theoretical domains framework/ Semi‐structured individual and focus group interviews/ Data were triangulated and was used as a coding framework in the analysis
Dennett 2020 England Home‐based telerehabilitation Eleven patients with multiple sclerosis Multiple Sclerosis/ Exercise therapy Qualitative study/ In‐depth, individual, face‐to‐face interviews/ Thematic analysis
Dinesen 2019 Denmark Home‐based telerehabilitation Fourteen cardiac patients, twelve patient spouses/partners, and one son Cardiac disease/ Cardiac Descriptive case study/ Documents, participant observation, and interviews/ Thematic analysis
Dubouloz 2004 Canada In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Six patients with rheumatoid arthritis Arthritis/ Activities in daily living (ADL) Grounded theory study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Constant comparative analysis
Edbrooke 2020 Australia In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Ninety‐two patients with non‐small cell lung cancer Cancer/ Exercise therapy Mixed methods study / Semi‐structured interviews, home visits and telephone calls/ Content analysis
Emmerson 2018 Australia Home‐based telerehabilitation Ten patients with stroke and upper limb impairment Stroke/ Exercise therapy  Convergent mixed methods design, based on phenomenology/ Semi‐structured interview in‐depth/ Thematic analysis
Folan 2015 Australia Home‐based telerehabilitation Seven patients ( 4 in‐patients and 3 out‐patients) with spinal cord injury Spinal cord injury/ Activities in daily living (ADL) Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis
Govender 2019 South Africa In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Five patients, five family caregivers, five community partners, five clinicians, and five researchers  Elderly/ Multidisciplinary Exploratory study/ Survey and semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis
Gélinas‐Bronsard 2019  Canada Home‐based telerehabilitation Eight patients who had suffered a stroke
                        
Stroke/ Multidisciplinary Individual qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Content analysis
Hale Gallardo 2020 United States Home‐based telerehabilitation Ten stakeholders (medical directors and program managers) Not specified/ Exercise therapy Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis
HeydariKhayat 2020 Iran In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Sixteen burn survivors patients  Burns/ Multidisciplinary Phenomenological study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis
Hoaas 2016 Norway Home‐based telerehabilitation Ten patients with moderate to severe COPD Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease /Respiratory  Mixed methods study/ Analysis of logs on the webpage, semi‐structured focus groups, standardised questionnaire and an individual open‐ended questionnaire/ Thematic analysis
Kamwesiga 2017 Uganda Home‐based telerehabilitation Eleven patients with stroke and nine family  caregivers Stroke/ Multidisciplinary Grounded theory study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Constant comparative analysis
Lawson 2020 Australia Home‐based telerehabilitation Twenty‐five patients with stroke and nine healthcare professionals Stroke/ Cognitive Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Inductive thematic analysis
Malmberg 2018 Sweden Home‐based telerehabilitation Twenty patients that had used Internet interventions for hearing aid Hearing impairment/ Communication  Qualitative exploratory study/ Semi‐structured telephone interviews/ Content analysis
Mendell 2019 Canada Home‐based telerehabilitation Thirty‐eight patients with acute coronary syndrome Acute coronary syndrome/ Cardiac Qualitative study/ Chat sessions/ Thematic analysis
Mohd Nordin 2014 Malaysia In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Fifteen rehabilitation professionals and eight stroke survivors Stroke/ Multidisciplinary Qualitative study/ Focus groups/ Thematic analysis
Ng 2013  Canada Home‐based telerehabilitation Three patients and their significant others Brain Injury/ Cognitive Case study/ Feedback interviews, therapist´s field notes and session recordings/ Descriptive analysis
Nordin 2017 Sweden Home‐based telerehabilitation Nineteen patients with persistent musculoskeletal pain Persistent Pain/ Multimodal for pain  Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Content analysis
O'Doherty 2013 Ireland In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Ten nurses Elderly/ Nursing in  Qualitative descriptive study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis
O'Shea 2020 Dublin and Belgium  Home‐based telerehabilitation Forty‐four patients with cardiovascular disease  Cardiovascular disease/ Cariac Qualitative study/ Participant debriefs, interviews/ Braun and Clarke framework for thematic analysis
Ownsworth 2020  Australia Home‐based telerehabilitation Thirteen multidisciplinary rehabilitation coordinators, nine patients, and eight family caregivers Brain injury/ Multidisciplinary Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Inductive analysis
Oyesanya 2019 United States Home‐based telerehabilitation Fifteen patients and twelve caregivers Brain Injury/ Multidisciplinary Qualitative exploratory study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Content analysis
Palazzo 2016 France In‐person + home‐based telerehabilitation Twenty‐nine patients with  chronic low back pain Chronic low back pain/ Multidisciplinary Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis
Palmcrantz 2017 Sweden Home‐based telerehabilitation Fifteen patients who had suffered stroke Stroke/ Exercise therapy Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Content analysis
Pekmezaris 2020 United States In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Approximately 20 community advisory board members,
one‐third were patients and caregivers, one‐third were providers (pulmonologists, researchers, and primary care physicians), and another one‐third were the other stakeholders (such as community‐based organizations)
Pulmonary diseases/ Respiratory Qualitative study/ Focus groups/ Content analysis
Pinto 2014 Brazil In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Twenty‐three patients with COPD Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease/ Respiratory Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic content analysis and contextualized semantic interpretation
Ranaldi 2018 United Kingdom In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Four hundred fifty‐seven patients with cardiac disease Cardiac disease/ Cardiac Qualitative study/ Questionnaires/ Thematic analysis
Randström 2012 Sweden In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Ten older patients Elderly/ Multidisciplinary Qualitative study/ Interviews/ Content analysis
Randstrom 2013 Sweden In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Six older patients and six family members Elderly/ Multidisciplinary Qualitative descriptive study/ Interviews/ Content analysis
Randström 2014 Sweden In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Twenty‐eight healthcare providers, six physiotherapists, three occupational therapists, five district nurses, five nurse assistants, one home helper, three home help officers responsible for needs assessment and five home help officers in charge of home help Elderly/ Multidisciplinary Qualitative descriptive study/ Focus groups/ Content analysis
Rietdijk  2020 Australia Home‐based telerehabilitation Thirty‐six patients and their caregivers Elderly/ Communication  Mixed methods study/ Skype interview, telephone interview or written questionnaire/ Inductive thematic analysis
Rizzo 2019 United States In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Ten patients with orthopaedic diagnoses Musculoeskeletal/ Exercise therapy Interpretative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Constant comparative analysis
Saywell 2015 New Zealand Home‐based telerehabilitation Fifteen patients who had suffered stroke Stroke/ Exercise therapy Qualitative descriptive study/ A brief questionnaire was used to gather data on mobile phone ownership/ Inductive analysis
Schopfer 2020 United States In‐person home‐based rehabilitation One hundred and seventy one patients with cardiac diseases (acute myocardial infarction, coronary artery bypass graft surgery, obstructive coronary artery disease, stable angina,  valve replacement and some outpatients with stable heart failure Cardiac disease/ Cardiac Mixed methods study/ Survey, and open‐ended semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis
Shulver 2016 Australia Home‐based telerehabilitation Forty‐four health workers (experienced and inexperienced) providing services to older people in the areas of rehabilitation and allied health, residential aged care and palliative care Elderly/ Multidisciplinary Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured focus groups/ Thematic analysis
Shulver 2017 Australia Home‐based telerehabilitation Thirteen older patients, three spouses and one caregiver Elderly/ Exercise therapy Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis
Silveira 2019 United States Home‐based telerehabilitation Twenty patients with multiple sclerosis who use wheelchairs Multiple Sclerosis/ Exercise therapy Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Deductive content analysis
Stark 2019 Germany In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Thirteen patients and nine non‐professional coaches (family members) Stroke/ Exercise therapy Mixed methods study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Hermeneutic phenomenological data analysis
Stuifbergen 2011 United States In‐person + home‐based telerehabilitation Thirty‐four patients with multiple sclerosis Multiple Sclerosis/ Cognitive Qualitative exploratory, descriptive study/ Qualitative data from a questionnaire administered by phone/ Content analysis
Sureshkumar 2016 India Home‐based telerehabilitation Sixty patients and their caregivers Stroke/ Multidisciplinary Mixed methods study/ Semi‐structured questionnaire/ Framework approach
Teriö 2019 Uganda Home‐based telerehabilitation Twelve participants: Four occupational therapists, three researchers, three information technology (IT) specialists and two rehabilitation managers  Stroke/ Activities in daily living (ADL) Single‐case study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Framework approach
Tsai 2016 Australia In‐person + home‐based telerehabilitation Eleven patients with COPD Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease/ Respiratory Mixed methods study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic descriptive analysis
Turner 2011 Australia In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Twenty patients and eighteen family caregivers Brain Injury/ Multidisciplinary Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Thematic analysis
Tyagi 2018 Singapore  Home‐based telerehabilitation Thirty‐seven participants: 13 patient‐caregiver dyads and 11 therapists Stroke/ Exercise therapy Qualitative study / Semi‐structured in‐depth interviews and focus group discussions/ Thematic analysis
Umb Carlsson 2019 Sweden In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Five residents, six staff members and five rehabilitation professionals Intellectual disability/ Promotion of healthy lifestyles Qualitative study/ Semi‐structured interviews/ Content analysis
Van der Meer 2020 Netherlands Home‐based telerehabilitation Nine patients and eleven orofacial physical therapists Temporomandibular
Disorders/ Exercise therapy
Qualitative descriptive study/ Open face‐to‐face interviews/ Thematic analysis
VanderVeen 2019 Netherlands In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Fourteen healthcare professionals: two occupational therapists, two physical therapists, two case managers, a psychologist, an elderly advisor, a nurse, a speech therapist, a nursing home manager, a manager in allied healthcare, a general practitioner and a geriatrician. Stroke/ Multidisciplinary Qualitative study/ Focus groups and semi‐structured interviews/ Content analysis
Vik 2009 Norway In‐person home‐based rehabilitation Three older patients Elderly/ Nursing in Case study/ Interviews/ Grounded theory