Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 Jan 1.
Published in final edited form as: Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2022 Dec 16;144:105006. doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2022.105006

Table 2.

Key findings and study characteristics of studies on metal exposure.

First
author
(study
year)
Toxicant N Age at
toxicant
measure
Toxicant
measure
Age at
MRI
MRI
measure
Exposure
main effect
Aschner et al. (2015) Manganese 58 Newborn Survey, medical and pharmacy records, blood sample Newborn T1R in globus pallidus, putamen Greater parenteral nutrition and greater total Mn exposure associated with shorter T1R in globus pallidus and putamen. No association with whole blood Mn.
de Water et al. (2018) Manganese 15 Prenatal Blood sample 6.3 -7.6 years Resting state functional connectivity with seeds in bilateral ACC, insula, MFG, superior parietal lobule, R and L globus pallidus In children with higher prenatal Mn exposure, there was reduced R globus pallidus - dACC functional connectivity and a quadratic association between prenatal Mn and R globus pallidus-IFG connectivity. No other associations survived controlling for all covariates.
de Water, Papazahari as et al. (2019) Manganese 14 Prenatal, early postnatal, and childhood Deciduous teeth 12 – 18 years Resting state functional connectivity with seeds in L and R putamen, L and R caudate, L and R pallidum, and bilateral MFG Adolescents with higher early postnatal Mn exposure showed reduced functional connectivity between R putamen and L pre and post central gyri and increased bilateral MFG - L mPFC functional connectivity.
Dion et al. (2016) Manganese 23 9- 15 years Water sample from kitchen tap, questionnaire 9- 15 years T1R in globus pallidus, standard PI, pericranial PI High Mn group (vs. low Mn group) had lower signal intensity on the pericranial PI and longer T1R. No difference in standard PI.
Iannilli et al. (2016) Manganese 14 N/A Lifetime residency 14.65 years Brain activation during olfactory stimulation task, olfactory bulb vol. Whole brain task analysis: low Mn group had greater activation in secondary olfactory cortex, cerebellum, and SMA. ROI task analysis: low Mn group had greater activation in bilateral insula, R middle cingulate, and PCC. No association between Mn and olfactory bulb vol.
Karcher et al. (2021) Lead 10,328 9-10 years Geocoded lead risk 9-10 years ICV, cortical GMV, subcortical GMV, total SA, total CT, hippocampa l vol Lead risk associated with smaller ICV, subcortical GMV, cortical GMV, total SA, and total CT. Hippocampa l vol not associated with lead risk. Air pollution also assessed, but no analyses conducted with MRI measures.
Kim et al. (2018) Lead 150 6 – 17 years Blood sample 6 – 17 years 10-12 frontal lobe CT ROIs No effect of lead on any ROI.
Lao et al. (2017) Manganese 23 9-15 years Water sample from kitchen tap 9-15 years Basal ganglia vol. (caudate, putamen, globus pallidus) measured volumetrical ly and with mTBM Using mTBM, high Mn group displayed larger L and bilateral putamen, but no difference when measured volumetrically.
Marshall et al. (2020) Lead 9,712 9 – 10 years Geocoded lead risk 9 – 10 years Total CT, total SA,cortical vol. No main effect of lead risk on any MRI measure.
Marshall et al. (2021) Lead 8,524 9 – 10 years Geocoded lead risk 9 – 10 years Subcortical GMV, vol. of hippocampus, amygdala, cerebellum, brain stem, CC sub-regions, putamen, caudate, accumbens, pallidum, thalamus, ventricles Lead risk associated with smaller CC in all sub-regions studied, except anterior CC. No other brain regions associated with lead risk.
Meng et al. (2005) Lead 12 9 – 13 years Blood sample 9 – 13 years MRS voxel in L and R frontal lobe, L and R hippocampus (metabolites : NAA, Cr, Cho) Peak of NAA, Cr, Cho lower in high lead group in all regions. For NAA, difference between high and low lead groups more pronounced in frontal lobe than hippocampus, and even more pronounced in R frontal lobe than L.
Trope et al. (2001) Lead 21 Before age 5 Blood sample 8.75 years MRS voxel in L prefrontal lobe (metabolites : NAA, Cr, Cho, ml). The NAA/Cr ratio in the L prefrontal lobe was significantly lower in the high lead group.

Note. See notes following Table 9 for table notes and a comprehensive list of abbreviations.