Table 2.
Study | Exercise | Advice/Education | Manual therapy | Home exercise | Oral analgesia/ neuropathic |
Frequency/duration of physiotherapy intervention | Additional interventions/ adjuncts |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Physiotherapy vs. minimal intervention (7 RCTs) | |||||||
Ferreira et al. [18] | √ | √ | √ | 4 treatment sessions over 2 weeks | |||
Fritz et al. [19] | √ | √ | √ | 6-8x during 4 wks, 2x each wk during first 2 wks and 1-2x in wks 3&4. Home exercises every 4-5 hours days between sessions. | |||
Ghoname et al. [20] | 30 mins 3x weekly for 3 weeks | TENS therapy, 4 x 2.5cm cutaneous pads at 4Hz, pulse duration 0.1s | |||||
Hofstee et al. [21] | √ | √ | √ | Twice weekly, minimum 4 wks maximum 8 wks | Hydrotherapy | ||
Konstantinovic et al. [22] | √ | √ | 5x weekly for a total of 15 treatments | Low level laser therapy, 5000 frequency, 100mW, 3J | |||
Luijsterburg et al. [23] | √ | √ | Not reported | ||||
Santilli et al. [24] | √ | 5 days per week for 30 days | |||||
Physiotherapy vs. surgical (11 RCTS) | |||||||
Amundsen et al. [25] | √ | Not reported | 3m inpatient stay, 3-point thoracolumbar hyperextension brace | ||||
Bailey et al. [26] | √ | √ | Spinal specialist medications, education & assessment of response to treatment on 6-wk basis min of 6m | Active physiotherapy at discretion of physiotherapists (number unspecified). Optional epidural injection | |||
Burton et al. [27] | √ | √ | 12 weeks maximum | Soft tissue stretching of lumbar and buttock muscles | |||
Erginousakis et al. [28] | √ | √ | Mean duration 22 days (range 7–35 days) | ||||
McMorland et al. [29] | √ | √ | √ | Not reported | Ice or heat | ||
Mondal et al. [30] | √ | √ | Not reported | ||||
Nikoobakht et al. [31] | √ | √ | √ | √ | 20 sessions, 12 weeks | Bed rest, local injections | |
Osterman et al. [32] | √ | √ | 3 times (at follow-ups 6wk, 3m, 12m) | ||||
Peul et al. [33] | √ | Not reported | Patients fearful of movement referred to physiotherapy (number unspecified) | ||||
Weber et al. [34] | √ | Not reported | Strict bed rest week 1, partial bed rest week 2. Group lessons in ‘back school’ | ||||
Weinstein et al. [35] | √ | √ | √ | √ | Not reported |
m month; wk week