Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 15;20:21. doi: 10.1186/s12984-023-01142-7

Table 8.

Reproducibility table

Metric ICC(r,k) Score (p < 0.05) Rating Measurement device Notes Refs.
Isometric joint torque ICC(3,1) 0.80–0.98 (p < 0.01) ***-**** ARMin [76]
Isokinetic motion with EMG ICC(2,1) 0.890 (0.685–0.961) **-**** 1-DOF [85]
Isokinetic motion with torque ICC(2,1) 0.931 (0.791–0.978) ***-****
Manual motion with EMG ICC(2,1) 0.788 (0.493–0.920) *-****
Initial direction error ICC(2,k) 0.81, 0.95 ***,**** KINARM No vision, vision [88]
Initial direction error variability ICC(2,k) 0.84, 0.94 ***,****
Path length ratio ICC(2,k) 0.68, 0.44 **,*
Path length ratio variability ICC(2,k) 0.95, 0.97 ****
Response latency ICC(2,k) 0.92, 0.94 ****
Response latency variability ICC(2,k) 0.91, 0.95 ****
Peak speed ratio ICC(2,k) 0.71, 0.96 **,****
Peak speed ratio variability ICC(2,k) 0.86, 0.66 ***,**
Peak velocity ICCu 0.9 **** Extension [84]
Final angle ICCu 0.86 ***
Creep ICCu 0.66 **
Peak velocity ICCu 0.95 **** Extension difference
Final angle ICCu 0.91 ****
Creep ICCu 0.74 **
Peak velocity ICCu 0.87 *** Flexion
Final angle ICCu 0.84 ***
Creep ICCu 0.86 ***
Peak velocity ICCu 0.88 *** Flexion difference
Final angle ICCu 0.88 ***
Creep ICCu 0.79 ***
Var_xy ICCu 0.81 *** [24]
Cont/exp_xy ICCu 0.86 ***
Shift_xy ICCu 0.7 **
aROM elbow flexion ICC(2,k) 0.89–0.97 ***-**** Inertial sensors First session [152]
aROM elbow pronation ICC(2,k) 0.89–0.94 ***-****
aROM elbow supination ICC(2,k) 0.91–0.98 ****
aROM wrist flexion ICC(2,k) 0.94–0.99 ****
aROM wrist extension ICC(2,k) 0.86–0.97 ***-****
aROM radial deviation ICC(2,k) 0.92–0.98 ****
aROM ulnar deviation ICC(2,k) 0.90–0.98 ****

ICCu – Unable to determine

ICC(2,1)—Two-way random effects with a single measurement. ICC(2,k)—Two-way random effects with a mean of k measurements. ICC(3,1)—Two-way mixed effects with a single measurement. ICC(3,k)—Two-way mixed effects with a mean of k measurements. *Poor reliability (< 0.5). **Moderate reliability (0.5 ≤ ICC < 0.75). ***Good reliability (0.75 ≤ ICC < 0.9). ****Excellent reliability (≥ 0.9)