Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 22;2023(2):CD013775. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013775.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Abougalambou 2015 Cross‐sectional study
Adderley 2020 No data on development of PDR
Adnitt 1970 No data on development of PDR
Advance Collaborative Group 2008 No data on development of PDR
Alattas 2022 Ineligible study design
Altaf 2013 Cross‐sectional study
Ashakiran 2011 Unable to access publication ‐ no contact details for author
Askarishahi 2011 Cross‐sectional study
Barr 2001 RCT
Beulens 2009 RCT
Borch‐Johnsen 1987 No data on development of PDR
Bresnick 1987 Ineligible patient population
Brinchmann‐Hansen 1985 RCT
Burton 2000 Case report
Cantagallo 1989 Review article
Chahal 1985 No data on development of PDR
Chaturvedi 1998 RCT
Chawla 2015 Cross‐sectional study
Chen 2017 No data on development of PDR
Chen 2020 Abstract ‐ no corresponding publication found
Chew 2014 RCT
Chittimoju 2013 Cross‐sectional study
Chung 2019 No data on development of PDR
Cikamatana 2007 No data on development of PDR
Cohen 1991 Rsk factors not given in a way that can be used to determine risk of PDR
Colin 2012 Abstract ‐ no corresponding publication found
Cuadras 2017 Cross‐sectional study, no data on development of PDR, and an abstract only
Danielsen 1983 Cross‐sectional study
DCCT 1993 RCT
Ding 2020 Ineligible study design ‐ DR self‐reported
Dizdarevic 2012 Cross‐sectional study
Duckworth 2009 RCT
Dujic 1998 Cross‐sectional study
Elshafei 2011 Cross‐sectional study
Estacio 2000 RCT
ETDRS 1991c Ineligible study design (RCT)
Foshati 2019 Cross‐sectional study
Friberg 1985 No data on development of PDR
Fung 2011 Cross‐sectional study
Fusi‐Rubiano 2015 Cross‐sectional study
Gallagher 2018 No data on development of PDR
Gao 2014 Cross‐sectional study
Garcia‐Medina 2011 No data on development of PDR
Garmo 2018 No data on development of PDR
Geetha 2019 Ineligible study design
González‐Villalpando 1994 Cross‐sectional study
Grauslund 2011 Review article
Gupta 2019 Survey, no data on development of PDR, and abstract only
Haffner 1993 No data on development of PDR
Hamman 1989 Cross‐sectional study
Hautala 2018 No data on development of PDR
Henricsson 1997 No data on development of PDR
Hoang 2020 Cross‐sectional study
Holman 2008 No data on development of PDR
Holt 2019 No data on development of PDR
Hwang 2019 No data on development of PDR
Jacobsen 2003 Unable to access publication ‐ author contacted but no response
Janka 1989 No data on development of PDR
Jin 2018 Cross‐sectional study
Jonas 2017 No data on development of PDR
Kawasaki 2005 Review article
Keech 2007 RCT
Kingsley 1988 No data on development of PDR
Klein 1988 No data on development of PDR
Kohner 1986 RCT
Kornerup 1955 No data on development of PDR
Kroc Collaborative Study 1984 RCT
Krolewski 1986 Unspecified number of patient population less than 18 years of age
Kulenovic 2006 No data on risk factors
Kyari 2014 Cross‐sectional study
Lamoureux 2018 No data on development of PDR
LaPorte 1986 No data on development of PDR
Lauritzen 1983 RCT
Lee 2010 No data on development of PDR
Lee 2011 Cross‐sectional study
Leese 2004 Correspondence author contacted to provide clarification on definition of outcome. Outcome may have included participants with pre‐PDR, so not included in review
Leske 2003 No data on risk factors
Li 2019 Ineligible outcomes
Lim 2015 Abstract
Lima 2016 Ineligible study design
Lin 2010 Ineligible outcomes
Liu 2019 Cross‐sectional study, and abstract only
Lorenzi 1983 Ineligible patient population ‐ adolescents
Low 2021 No data on development of PDR
Lu 2012 Cross‐sectional study
Lu 2013 Cross‐sectional study
Lv 2020 Cross‐sectional study
Malik 2005 Cross‐sectional study
Malik 2018 Cross‐sectional study
Man 2018 No data on development of PDR
Marshall 1993 No data on development of PDR
Mathur 2016 Correspondence author contacted to provide clarification on definition of outcome. Supplementary material provided which confirmed outcome of 'severe retinopathy' included participants with diabetic macular oedema
Mehlsen 2011 No data on development of PDR
Mehta 2019 RCT
Minuto 2009 Cross‐sectional study
Mitchell 1985 No data on development of PDR
Mohd Ali 2016 Cross‐sectional study
Moon 2018 Abstract
Mowatt 2013 Cross‐sectional study
Muhlhauser 1986 Cross‐sectional study
Muqit 2014 No data on risk factors
Nguyen 2009 Cross‐sectional study
Nicolucci 1993 Cross‐sectional study
Nordwall 2004 No data on development of PDR
Ohtani 1985 Ineligible study design
Padmajeya 2019 Abstract
Paetkau 1977 Cross‐sectional study
Pardhan 2004 Cross‐sectional study
Park 2015 Cross‐sectional study
Parving 1988 Cross‐sectional study
Pettitt 1980 No data on development of PDR
Pugliese 2012 Cross‐sectional study
Rahul 2015 Cross‐sectional study
Rasoulinejad 2022 Cross‐sectional study
Raum 2015 Cross‐sectional study
Ravi Theja 2017 Cross‐sectional study, and abstract
Reichard 1991 RCT
Resman 1993 Ineligible study design
Romero 2007 No DR at baseline
Romero‐Aroca 2016 No data on development of PDR
Rudnisky 2012 No data on development of PDR
Schellhase 2003 No data on development of PDR
Shriwas 1996 Cross‐sectional study
Singh 2020 No data on development of PDR
Sjolie 1985 No data on risk factors
Srikanth 2015 Ineligible participant population
Takaike 2018 Definition of outcome unclear and unable to contact authors to clarify
Tapp 2006 No data on risk factors
Taylor 1997 Cross‐sectional study
Thapa 2015 Cross‐sectional study
Tripathi 2010 No data on risk factors
Tseng 2012 No data on development of PDR
Tu 2011 No data on development of PDR
UKPDS Group 1996 No data on risk factors
Van Leiden 2003 No data on development of PDR
Villena 2011 Cross‐sectional study
Wang 2006 No data on risk factors
Xie 2009 Cross‐sectional study
Yokoyama 1997 Cross‐sectional study
Zhou 2006 No data on development of PDR, and abstract only

DR: diabetic retinopathy; PDR: proliferative diabetic retinopathy; RCT: randomised controlled trial